Closed-loop Brain Stimulation
Conditions
Keywords
neuromodulation, electrical stimulation, transcranial low-intensity focused ultrasound stimulation, closed-loop neuromodulation
Brief summary
The goal of this study is to establish if non-invasive closed-loop neuromodulation is an effective approach to enhance cognitive function in healthy 18-40 years old volunteers. The main questions it aims to answer are: * Can closed-loop stimulation increase stimulation effectiveness? * Can closed-loop focused ultrasound specifically engage with excitatory or inhibitory neural populations in the target structure as measured through MRS? * Can observed stimulation outcomes for FUS be predicted through connectome analysis and computational models of indirect changes? Researchers will compare different closed-loop options to their open-loop counterpart to see if closed-loop approaches can increase efficacy and reduce the variability of the stimulation compared to open-loop approaches. Participants will: * Answer some questionnaires at the start of the study and after each intervention session. * Undertake a MRI scanning session. * Undertake one open-loop FUS session. * Undertake one tES session. * Undertake one closed-loop FUS sessions involving tES and FUS, followed by a MRI scanning * Undertake one sham FUS session * Attend one visit in person to assess eligibility through questionnaires and one cognitive task
Detailed description
Closed-loop approaches may offer greater efficacy and lower variability across individuals compared to current open-loop stimulation approaches, yet they remain a relatively new approach, with no studies evaluating closed-loop transcranial low-intensity focused ultrasound stimulation (FUS) yet. For this reason, we will collect and evaluate cognitive, biological and metabolic data from healthy participants, before and after closed-loop and open-loop stimulation interventions. This will allow us to compare our proposed closed-loop stimulation approach to stablished non-invasive techniques and to investigate the underlying mechanisms through which FUS can alter brain activity. For this study, participants will attend multiple visits. To assess eligibility, participants will attend one initial session in-person before the start of the study. Following safety guidelines, each participant will receive a maximum of two 1-hour MRI scanning sessions in a single week. This study will be separated into two blocks of stimulation sessions: one block for tACS-FUS, and another block for TI-FUS. Participants will be randomly allocated to receive one of the blocks. Before the during recruitment, participants will be asked to complete online some baseline questionnaires such as the O-Life inventory, BECK, MAIA, or STAI. Furthermore, full eligibility will be assessed in person. At the first appointment, participants will have a brain scan at Sir Peter Mansfield Imaging Centre or Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham, UK. This will help us to apply the brain stimulation to the right part of the participant's brain, as well as obtain baseline functional, metabolic and structural information. Participants will be randomly allocated to either receive open-loop FUS (FUS with Sham tES), closed-loop FUS (dual FUS-tES), tES with Sham FUS, or double sham FUS-tES, in the second appointment and the other interventions in the subsequent visits for their assigned block. During all stimulation sessions, we will use an AntNeuro neuronavigation system to guide the location of the transducer. During either of the stimulation visits, participants will have physiological (EEG) and cognitive markers recorded. Some emotional assessments (i.e., through a short STAI) will be performed before and after stimulation. EEG recordings will be conducted before, during and after stimulation on the same day. Rest-state EEG will be recorded pre-stimulation before the start of the cognitive tasks, and post-stimulation after the end of the cognitive tasks. The participant will then undergo one cognitive assessment, which will consists on a visual working memory task (delayed-spatial-estimation-task). The task involves visual stimuli, with responses recorded via keyboard. The task is designed to take approximately 5-15 minutes to complete on pre and post-stimulation. The duration of the task during stimulation will be adapted to the duration of the stimulation. Following this, participants will receive the allocated intervention. Participants will have the same physiological and cognitive assessments recorded during the stimulation and after the stimulation has been completed. For the closed-loop stimulation, participants will also undergo an MRI scanning after the stimulation. The first visit, consisting of brain scan, will be separated by at least 24 hours from the second visit. Subsequent visits will be separated by at least one week from each other. During each consecutive appointment, participants will be asked about any changes to their eligibility and continued consent.
Interventions
OTHERTranscranial low intensity focused ultrasound (FUS)
Low intensity focused ultrasound stimulation (FUS) with 500kHz transducer for following either the continuous theta burst or intermittent theta burst protocol using the NeuroFus PRO system
OTHERtranscranial electrical stimulation
Transcranial electrical stimulation (by means of transcranial alternating current stimulation (tACS) or non-invasive temporal interference (TI) electrical stimulation) using the DS5 isolated bipolar constant current stimulator together connected to a wave generator and with two electrodes for tACS (TI implementation will be carried out with two DS5 systems, separate wave generators and four electrodes).
PROCEDUREMagnetic Resonance Imaging
We obtain baseline functional, metabolic and structural information through MRI and MRS scanning
Sponsors
University of Nottingham
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
BASIC_SCIENCE
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 40 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes
Inclusion criteria
* Participant is willing and able to give informed consent for participation in the study * Aged between 18 and 40 * Good general health * Not consume alcohol 48 hours prior study visit * Not currently taking any medications (except contraceptive pills) or if on long-term medication for a non-neurological/non-psychiatric condition (r.g. inhalers) to be considered otherwise healthy and stable with no symptoms * Be right handedness
Exclusion criteria
* Inability to complete MRI/FUS/TMS/tES safety questionnaire and / or informed consent process. * Current or previous diagnosis of a neurological, neurosurgical, psychiatric disorders. * Other significant medical condition (specific details to be reviewed by the CI prior to inclusion). * Currently pregnant, breast feeding, or on planned pregnancy. * Medication intake (such as beta-blocker, glucocorticoids, anti-depressants, anti-inflammatory drugs in the last 7d). * Medication intake (such as antidepressants, antipsychotics, anti-epileptics, beta blockers, glucocorticoids, anti-inflammatories, benzodiazepines, hypnotics, sedating antihistamines or any illicit substances in the past seven days). * Significant use of medication or recreational drugs that affect the nervous system. * Excessive consumption of alcohol. * Known allergy to any required consumables (such as aquasonic gel). * History of anaphylaxis to any substance * Have tightly coiled, curly or voluminous texture hair type (e.g., hair type 3, 4, or afro hair). * Having skin disease or sensitive skin on or close to the head.
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame |
|---|---|
| Change from Baseline in EEG Power in Alpha Band (8-12Hz) | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Change from Baseline in EEG Power in Theta Band (4-7Hz) | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Change from Baseline in EEG Power in Beta Band (13-30Hz) | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Change from Baseline in EEG Power in Gamma Band (31-45Hz) | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Changes from Baseline in EEG-derived spectral power | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Changes from Baseline in Functional connectivity (e.g., through changes in Phase-locked value (PLV)) | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Average Reaction time (ms) measured from the Visual Working memory task | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Average Overall accuracy (%) measured from Visual Working Memory task | Baseline to 10 weeks, measured immediately before, during, and immediately after stimulation |
| Change from Baseline in Target-Region metabolite Concentration measured via Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) | Baseline (Day 1) to immediately after closed-loop post-stimulation intervention |
| Changes from Baseline in Functional Connectivity calculated from functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) | Baseline (Day 1) to immediately after closed-loop post-stimulation intervention |
| Changes from Baseline on Structural connectivity metrics derived from multi-shell diffusion MRI (dMRI) tractography | Baseline (Day 1) to immediately after closed-loop post-stimulation intervention |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame |
|---|---|
| Structured questionnaire assessing adverse effects of the intervention | Immediately after stimulation, 24 hours after stimulation and 1 week after stimulation |
Countries
United Kingdom
Contacts
CONTACTDr. Falcon Caro
CONTACTDr. Halls
PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATORMarcus Kaiser, PhD
University of Nottingham
Outcome results
None listed