Skip to content

Thyroid Cartilage Plane VS Superior Laryngeal Nerve Space Block in Awake Tracheal Intubation

Thyroid Cartilage Plane Versus Superior Laryngeal Nerve Space for Ultrasound-guided Superior Laryngeal Nerve Block in Awake Tracheal Intubation: a Randomised Non-inferiority Clinical Trial

Status
Recruiting
Phases
Unknown
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT07397234
Enrollment
94
Registered
2026-02-09
Start date
2026-02-11
Completion date
2027-09-01
Last updated
2026-07-28

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Superior Laryngeal Nerve Block

Keywords

Thyroid Cartilage plane, Superior laryngeal nerve space, Difficult airway, Superior Laryngeal Nerve, Awake tracheal intubation, Nerve block

Brief summary

The aim of this clinical trial is to compare the effectiveness and safety of ultrasound-guided thyroid cartilage plane approach with the superior laryngeal nerve space approach for superior laryngeal nerve block in awake tracheal intubation. Patients were randomized into the thyroid cartilage plane block group (T group) or the superior laryngeal nerve space block group (C group). In Group T, bilateral thyroid cartilage plane block was performed under ultrasound with thyroid cartilage as the landmark, and local anesthetic was injected on the surface of the thyroid cartilage. In Group C, local anesthetic was injected into the space between the thyrohyoid membrane and muscle groups above. The investigators aim to evaluate whether the thyroid cartilage plane approach is not inferior to the superior laryngeal nerve space approach for ultrasound-guided superior laryngeal nerve block in awake tracheal intubation

Detailed description

After entering the operation room, ECG, SPO2, and invasive blood pressure were monitored. Sedation was facilitated. The proper anaesthesia depth was maintained at 60-80 using the bispectral index. Additionally, 0.5 mg of Penehyclidine Hydrochloride was injected intravenously once the venous access was established. 100% oxygen 4 L min-1 was administered with a nasal cannula throughout the procedure. All patients received topical pharyngeal anesthesia using lidocaine spray. The investigators used a 5-12 MHz linear probeto perform bilateral block. The probe was placed parasagittally to locate the thyroid cartilage and superior laryngeal nerve space. After identification of related structure, the investigators advanced a 22-gauge needle medial to the transducer at the upper half of the thyroid cartilage laminae until it touched the laminae or superior laryngeal nerve space using the out-of-plane technique. The correct location of the needle tip in the fascial deep to the muscle groups was confirmed by injecting 0.5-1 ml saline. A total of 2% lidocaine 2.5 ml was administered after negative aspiration bilaterally. "Spray-as-you-go" technique guided by a fiberoptic bronchoscope was performed to the tracheal with 5 ml of 2% lidocaine. After airway anesthesia, intubation completed. The primary outcome was the proportion of acceptable intubation conditions (AIC). Secondary outcomes were the performance time, Ramsay sedation score, the patient's cough condition, comfort score, and tracheal tube tolerance score and other perioperative complications including airway hemorrhage and superior laryngeal nerve damage.

Interventions

Use a SonoSite high-frequency linear array transducer (5-13 MHz, SonoSite, USA). Placing the transducer parallel to the spine on one side of the neck, ensuring clear visualization of the thyroid cartilage under ultrasound. Using the out-of-plane technique to visualize the needle insertion path and tip. Once the needle tip contacts the cranial half of the thyroid cartilage, injecting 2.5ml of 2% lidocaine on the surface of the thyroid cartilage each side.

PROCEDUREUltrasound-guided bilateral Superior Laryngeal Nerve Space Block

Use a SonoSite high-frequency linear array transducer (5-13 MHz, SonoSite, USA). Placing the transducer parallel to the spine on one side of the neck, ensuring clear visualization of the superior laryngeal nerve space under ultrasound. Using the out-of-plane technique to visualize the needle insertion path and tip. 2% lidocaine 2.5ml was injected into the space between the thyrohyoid membrane and muscle groups above.

Sponsors

Nanjing First Hospital, Nanjing Medical University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
Masking
TRIPLE (Subject, Investigator, Outcomes Assessor)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 85 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

1. Patients scheduled for awake tracheal intubation under general anesthesia. 2. Patients with difficult airways (e.g., limited cervical spine mobility, full stomach, partial airway obstruction, craniofacial deformities or trauma, micrognathia, mouth opening \<3cm, Mallampati III or IV classification) posing challenges for mask ventilation or intubation. 3. Age between 18 and 85 years old. 4. Gender is not restricted. 5. ASA classification of I - III.

Exclusion criteria

1. Cardiovascular dysfunction or arterial aneurysms. 2. Mental or neurological disorders or concomitant arterial aneurysms. 3. Infection at the puncture site. 4. Allergy to local anesthetics. 5. Continuous use of antiplatelet or anticoagulant medications preoperatively. 6. Hoarseness or coughing while drinking water. 7. Bronchial asthma. 8. Participation in other clinical trials within the previous 3 months before enrollment 9.r current participation in other clinical trials.

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
The proportion of patients with acceptable intubation conditions (AIC)Upon intubationThe evaluation of the intubation condition was based on the Cormack-Lehane classification, vocal cord movement, 5-point reaction scale, and severity of coughing. Clinically, AIC was defined when each part was scaled to Grade 1 or Grade 2. The proportion of AIC = number of participants with AIC/number of participants who received ATI in each group.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Quality of airway anesthesiaUpon intubationThe quality of airway anesthesia assessed on a 5-point scale,Quality of airwayanesthesia was graded as: 0=no coughing or gagging in response to intubation, 1=mild coughing and/or gaggingthat did not hinder intubation, 2=moderate coughing and/or gagging that interfered minimally with intubation,3=severe coughing and/or gagging that made intubation difficult and 4=very severe coughing and/or gaggingthat required additional local anesthetic and/or change in technique.The lower grade means a better quality of airway anesthesia.
Mean Arterial PressureT0: upon entry to the operating room,T1: before insertion of the tracheal tube,T2: immediately after tracheal tube insertion,T3: 5 minutes after successful intubationStable blood pressure indicates a good neural blockade effect.
Heart RateT0: upon entry to the operating room,T1: before insertion of the tracheal tube,T2: immediately after tracheal tube insertion,T3: 5 minutes after successful intubationTime Frame: T0: upon entry to the operating room,T1: before insertion of the tracheal tube,T2: immediatelyafter tracheal tube insertion,T3: 5 minutes after successful intubation
Ramsay Sedation ScoreT0: upon entry to the operating room,T1: before insertion of the tracheal tube,T2: immediately after tracheal tube insertion,T3: 5 minutes after successful intubationThe Ramsay Sedation Score is as follows: 6 points for unarousable, 5 points for slow response to stimulus, 4points for asleep but easily aroused, 3 points for quiet and cooperative with orientation, 2 points for asleep,anxious, restless, and 1 point for asleep, agitated, and restless. Satisfactory sedation falls within 2-4 points,while oversedation is indicated by 5-6 points.
The number of patients with lowered pitchBefore intubationA lowered pitch might indicate a good neural blockade effect.
The time needed for blockade procedureFrom ultrasounography localization to completion of local anesthetic administrationThe neural blockade procedure time reflects the ease of the operation, with a shorter time indicating a simpler neural blockade procedure.
Record coughing in patients when the fiberoptic bronchoscope touches the glottisBefore intubationThe patient's coughing upon contact of the fiberoptic bronchoscope with the vocal cords before intubation reflects the effectiveness of neural blockade. A lower degree of coughing indicates a better neural blockadeeffect. 1 point for no response, 2 points for mild cough, 3 points for severe cough.
The tolerance score after the tube insertionFive minutes after successful intubationThe tolerance of the tube reflects the patient's tolerance to awake tracheal intubation. A higher score indicates a better outcome. 3 points for severe resistance requiring immediate general anesthesia, 2 points for restlessness and mild resistance, 1 point for cooperation.
Adverse reactions such as coughing and nausea/vomitingDuring intubationThe lower the incidence of coughing, nausea, and vomiting, the better the neural blockade effect.
Occurrences of sore throat and lowered pitchPost-extubation,24 hours after surgeryPharyngeal pain and decreased vocal tone are used to assess postoperative complications of neural blockade.
Total procedure time needed for awake intubationFrom the initiation of topical anesthesia to the accomplishment of tracheal intubationThe total procedure time reflects the ease of the operation, with a shorter time indicating a simpler procedure.
Airway hemorrhage or nerve damageDuring intubationObservation of bleeding of the laryngeal mucosa via fiberoptic bronchoscope or observation of bloody secretions via coughing or suction

Countries

China

Contacts

CONTACTTao Shan
858727933@qq.com+8618852095135
CONTACTYing Zhang
1070434273@qq.com+8615380998716
PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATORTao Shan

Nanjing First Hospital, Nanjing Medical University

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Jul 29, 2026