Skip to content

Comparative Study on the Effectiveness, Comfort and Compliance of HFNC and Noninvasive Mechanical Ventilation BiPAP Mode in the Treatment of Hypoxemia Patients

Comparative Study on the Effectiveness, Comfort and Compliance of High-flow Nasal Oxygen Therapy and Noninvasive Mechanical Ventilation BiPAP Mode in the Treatment of Hypoxemia Patients

Status
UNKNOWN
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT05784636
Enrollment
243
Registered
2023-03-27
Start date
2023-03-31
Completion date
2024-06-06
Last updated
2023-03-27

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Hypoxemia

Keywords

Hypoxemia, High-flow nasal cannula, Mechanical ventilation

Brief summary

Patients who met the inclusion criteria were included and signed an informed consent form, which complied with the requirements of the ethics committee of our unit. All subjects were inpatients. Subjects were randomized into two groups. patients in group A were first treated with HFNC on top of conventional treatment, and after 24 hours, patients were treated with non-invasive ventilator-assisted ventilation BiPAP mode until discharge. patients in group B were treated with a non-invasive ventilator on top of conventional treatment, and after 24 hours of treatment, patients were treated with HFNC until discharge. Patient information was collected during treatment.

Detailed description

Patients who met the inclusion criteria were included and signed the informed consent, which met the requirements of the ethics committee of our unit. All subjects were hospitalized patients. Subjects were randomly divided into two groups. Patients in group A were treated with HFNC on the basis of conventional treatment. The initial parameters were: temperature:31-37℃, flow: 30-40l /min, SpO2 \> 92% maintained, the oxygen concentration was adjusted according to the patient's oxygen saturation, and the treatment time was 24h. Twenty-four hours later, the patients were treated with non-invasive ventilator-assisted ventilation BiPAP mode until discharge. On the basis of conventional treatment, patients in group B were given a non-invasive ventilator with the following initial parameters: BiPaP mode, initial inspiratory pressure (IPAP) of 8-15cmH2O, initial expiratory pressure (EPAP) of 4-8cmH2O. The parameters were adjusted according to the specific conditions of the patients. After 24 hours of treatment, the patient was treated with HFNC until discharge. Patient information was collected during treatment.

Interventions

DEVICENon-invasive BiPAP ventilation

Patients were first treated with HFNC (High-flow nasal cannula) on the basis of conventional treatment. The initial parameters were temperature: 31-37 °C, flow rate: 30-40l /min, maintaining SpO2\>92%, adjusting oxygen concentration according to blood oxygen saturation, and treatment duration was 24 h. After 24 h, patients were treated with non-invasive ventilator-assisted ventilation BiPAP mode until discharge.

DEVICEHFNC

On the basis of conventional treatment, patients were first administered a noninvasive ventilator with the following initial parameters. BiPAP mode with an initial inspiratory pressure (IPAP) of 8-15 cmH2O and an initial expiratory pressure (EPAP) of 4-8 cmH2O. These parameters were adjusted according to the patient's specific conditions. After 24 hours of treatment, patients received HFNC (High-flow nasal cannula) until discharge.

Sponsors

Qilu Hospital of Shandong University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
CROSSOVER
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
SINGLE (Outcomes Assessor)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
20 Years to 80 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

1. . PaO2 \< 60mmHg, SpO2 \< 92%(without oxygen inhalation); 2. Mild to moderate type I respiratory failure (100 mmHg \< PaO/Fi02≤300 mmHg);

Exclusion criteria

1. Missing primary outcome measures 2. Terminal stage of various chronic diseases; 3. The patient or family members do not agree to NIV or HFNI treatment; 4. Severe type I respiratory failure (PaO2/Fi02≤100 mmHg) 5. Ventilation dysfunction (pH\<7.30) 6. Contradictory breathing 7. The patient abandons or terminates treatment, automatically discharges or transfers to another hospital; 8. Serious diseases, such as organ function damage and sepsis;

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Diaphragm thicknessAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyIncludes end-inspiratory diaphragm thickness and end-expiratory diaphragm thickness;The patient is lying flat on the bed. A linear array probe is placed in the mid-axillary line or between the anterior and mid-axillary lines between the eighth and tenth ribs, and measurements are taken.
BUNOn the first day after enrollmentUrea nitrogen in venous blood
Cys-COn the first day after enrollmentCystatin C in venous blood
Stay in the ICUduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysYes or No
IBILOn the first day after enrollmentIndirect bilirubin in venous blood
Diaphragm mobilityAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyThe patient is lying in a flat position. The convex array probe is placed at the junction of the anterior axillary line, midclavicular line, and rib margin (bilaterally), with the probe mark facing outward and downward for measurement.
CrOn the first day after enrollmentcreatinine in venous blood
eGFROn the first day after enrollmentEstimate glomerular filtration rate in venous blood
Respiratory support timeduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysDaily respiratory support time after patients were enrolled in the clinical study,h/Day
Relief time for dyspneaduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysRemission time of dyspnea after intervention
Tracheal intubationduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysYes or No
PaO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studyPartial arterial oxygen pressure
ASTOn the first day after enrollmentAspartate Transaminase in venous blood
PAOn the first day after enrollmentSerum prealbumin in venous blood
TPOn the first day after enrollmentTotal serum protein in venous blood
HRAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyHeart rate
RRAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyRespiratory rate
BPAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyBlood pressure (Includes systolic and diastolic blood pressure)
SO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studyPulse oxygen saturation
pHAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyDegree of pH in arterial blood
SaO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studyArterial oxygen saturation
PCO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studypartial pressure of carbon dioxide in arterial blood
FiO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studyFraction of inspiration O2
LacAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyLactic acid in arterial blood
GluAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyArterial blood glucose in arterial blood
GLuOn the 4th day after enrollment (On the third day after crossover)Arterial blood glucose in arterial blood
A-aDO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studyThe difference between the oxygen partial pressure of alveolar air and the oxygen partial pressure of arterial blood
BEAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyBase excess in arterial blood
RIAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyRespiratory Index
Arterial blood HCO3- concentrationAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyArterial blood HCO3- concentration,including arterial blood HCO3- std concentration
Arterial blood K+ concentrationAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyArterial blood K+ concentration
Arterial blood Ca2+ concentrationAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyArterial blood Ca2+ concentration
ALBOn the first day after enrollmentAlbumin protein in venous blood
GLBOn the first day after enrollmentGlobulin globulin in venous blood
Arterial blood Na+ concentrationAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyArterial blood Na+ concentration
TCO2At the time of enrollment in the clinical studyTotal carbon dioxide in arterial blood
HCTAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyhematocrit in arterial blood
tHbcAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyTotal hemoglobin in arterial blood
heightAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studym
WeightAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyKg
genderAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyMale and female
ageAt the time of enrollment in the clinical studyyear
WBCOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of white blood cells in venous blood
NEUOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of Neutrophil granulocyte in venous blood
LYMOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of Venous blood lymphocytes in venous blood
EOSOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of Venous blood eosinophils in venous blood
BASOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of Venous blood Basophils in venous blood
MONOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of Venous blood Monocyte cell in venous blood
RBCOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of red blood cells in venous blood
HGBOn the first day after enrollmentThe number of haemoglobin in venous blood
MCVOn the first day after enrollmentMean Corpuscular Volume in venous blood
MCHOn the first day after enrollmentMean Corpuscular Haemoglobin Concentration in venous blood
RDWOn the first day after enrollmentred blood cell distribution width in venous blood
PLTOn the first day after enrollmentplatelet in venous blood
PDWOn the first day after enrollmentPlatelet distributionwidth in venous blood
MPVOn the first day after enrollmentMean Platelet Volume in venous blood
plateletcritOn the first day after enrollmentplateletcrit in venous blood
CRPOn the first day after enrollmentC-reactive protein in venous blood
PCTOn the first day after enrollmentProcalcitonin in venous blood
NT-proBNPOn the first day after enrollmentNT-proBNP in venous blood
ESROn the first day after enrollmenterythrocytesedimentationrate in venous blood
PTOn the first day after enrollmentprothrombin time in venous blood
APTTOn the first day after enrollmentactivated partial thromboplastin time in venous blood
TTOn the first day after enrollmentThrombin time in venous blood
D-DiOn the first day after enrollmentD-Dimer in venous blood
ALTOn the first day after enrollmentalanine transaminase in venous blood
Complicationsduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysFacial injury, flatulence,Gastroesophageal reflux,Dry throat, sore throat,pneumothorax,Eye irritation discomfort,Low blood pressure.
Outcome of diseaseduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysGet better, get worse, die
Total bilirubinOn the first day after enrollmentSerum total bilirubin in venous blood
DBILOn the first day after enrollmentDirect bilirubin in venous blood

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Patient compliance to the treatmentduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysPatients were managed for compliance with the treatment.Dependent judgment 1. Complete dependence: patients actively cooperate with medical staff in treatment 2. Partial dependence: in most cases, patients can cooperate with the treatment, and in a few cases, patients resist the treatment but receive treatment after being enlightened by the medical staff. 3. Non-dependence: patients have strong resistance and resistance, so that they are unable to use ventilators or nasal high-flow humidification instruments.
Kolcaba Comfort Scale (GCQ) assessment assesses patient comfortduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysKolcaba's General Comfort Questionnaire (GCQ) is composed of 28 items from 4 dimensions: physiological, psychological, spiritual, socio-cultural and environmental. The modification Scale adopts 1 to 4Likert Scale, with 1 indicating strongly disagree and 4 indicating strongly agree. In the negative question, 1 means strongly agree and 4 means strongly disagree. A higher score indicates more comfort.
Dyspnea rating scaleduring hospitalization, approximately 9 daysAccording to the degree of dyspnea and symptoms of the patient, the lowest score is 0, the highest score is 10.

Countries

China

Contacts

Primary ContactDedong Ma, MD
ma@qiluhuxi.com18560082806
Backup Contactchunwei He, master
hechw160814@163.com17361616499

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026