Skip to content

Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurement Using Multimodal Devices

Measurement of Oxygen Saturation in Healthy Human Volunteers Before, During, and After Hyperemic Events Using Multi-Modal Techniques: Spatial Frequency Domain Imaging, Transcutaneous Oxygen Measurement, Pulse Oximeter, and Apple Watch

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT05784103
Enrollment
20
Registered
2023-03-24
Start date
2022-03-09
Completion date
2022-07-07
Last updated
2023-11-29

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Oxygen Saturation

Keywords

SFDI, oxygenation, healthy volunteers

Brief summary

Pulse oximeters are common medical devices used to measure blood oxygen saturation (SpO2). These devices are either stand-alone or integrated into physiologic monitoring systems, using 2 wavelengths of light to determine SpO2. With recent advances in technology, Spatial Frequency Domain Imaging (SFDI) uses a range of light wavelengths from red to near-infrared (NIR), and smartphones such as Apple Watch, and transcutaneous oximetry TCOM now have pulse oximetry capabilities. Since it is possible that most patients could utilize this technology, we sought to assess the accuracy, reliability, and usability of these oximeters and compare outcomes. In this study, a cohort of 20 healthy volunteers above the age of 18 including males and females of different skin colors will be assessed at the same site and data will be compared. We aim to provide a set of data that will support the clinical and scientific community and identify more than one reliable skin oxygen measurement modality.

Detailed description

The subjects will go through a questionnaire session about their medical history by a designated study team member. The questionnaire data will be placed in RedCap using a subject ID that cannot be linked back to the subject. Then the subject will consent and be enrolled. Then the non-invasive data-collecting procedure will start on the following equipment. Spatial Frequency Domain Imaging (SFDI): During the consenting period, the Modulim equipment will be calibrated and set up ready for scanning. The subject's volar aspect of the thumb along with the palm surface will be ready to target the optical camera head. Actual scanning takes less than 60 seconds. The images will be processed offline. During processing 3-5 different regions of interest (ROI) will be taken to measure the oxygen parameters such as tissue oxygen saturation (StO2), oxy-hemoglobin (HbO2), deoxy-hemoglobin (HbR), superficial hemoglobin (HbT1, sub-surface hemoglobin (HbT2). The model used is a Clarifi Modulim Transcutaneous oxygen monitoring (TCOM): Transcutaneous oxygen monitoring (TCOM or TcpO2) is a noninvasive, clinically-approved method to obtain skin oxygen levels. The method is quantitative and measures oxygen delivery to the skin from underlying tissue. Before positioning the electrode, an adhesive fixation ring will be placed on the dry skin on the volar aspect of the thumb and an electrolyte as a contact liquid will be filled in half and the probe is aligned into it by rotating clockwise to fasten it. The recording will be started and waited for the oxygen level to stabilize and a fixed value will be recorded. The model used is a Perimed PeriFlux 5000. The probe will be heated to about 45 degrees C. Although this device has other options, only the measurement of O2 will be performed using this device. Apple Watch Oxygen Sensor: Smartwatch blood oxygen sensors also measure blood oxygen levels in the tissue. Apple Watch Series 6 introduced this new feature for monitoring blood oxygen levels using light-emitting diodes (LEDs) at the back of apple watches. A low blood oxygen level can be indicative of a serious health issue that needs immediate attention. The apple watch is equipped with green, red, and infrared LEDs that shine light onto the blood vessels in the wrist, with photodiodes measuring the amount of light reflected back. Apple's algorithms use this information to calculate the color of the blood, which is an indication of how much oxygen is in the blood. Bright red blood is well-oxygenated, while darker blood has less oxygen. This can measure blood oxygen levels between 70 and 100 percent. Most healthy people have blood oxygen levels that range from 95 to 100 percent. The apple watch sensor will be positioned on the user's preferred wrist. Pulse Oximeter for Oxygen Monitoring: The pulse oximeter enables transcutaneous monitoring of the oxygen saturation of hemoglobin in arterial blood (StO2). Pulse oximetry is so widely prevalent in medical care that it is often regarded as a fifth vital sign\[3\]. It is important to understand how the technology functions as well as its limitations. To recognize the settings in which pulse oximeter readings of oxygen saturation (SpO2), an understanding of two basic principles of pulse oximetry is required: (i) how oxyhemoglobin (HbO2) is distinguished from deoxyhemoglobin (HbR) and (ii) how the SpO2 is calculated only from the arterial compartment of blood. Pulse oximetry is based on the principle that HbO2 and HbR differentially absorb red and near-infrared (IR) light. It is fortuitous that HbO2 and HbR have significant differences in absorption at red and near-IR light because these two wavelengths penetrate tissues well whereas blue, green, yellow, and far-IR light are significantly absorbed by non-vascular tissues and water \[3\]. HbO2 absorbs greater amounts of IR light and lower amounts of red light than does HbR; this is consistent with experience - well-oxygenated blood with its higher concentrations of HbO2 appears bright red to the eye because it scatters more red light than does HbR. On the other hand, HHR absorbs more red light and appears less red. Exploiting this difference in light absorption properties between HbO2 and HbR, pulse oximeters emit two wavelengths of light, red at 660 nm and near-IR at 940 nm from a pair of small light-emitting diodes located in one arm of the finger probe. The light that is transmitted through the finger is then detected by a photodiode on the opposite arm of the probe. In this study, the volar aspect of the thumb and index finger of the subject will be used to measure SpO2.

Interventions

DEVICEClarifi Modulum

During consenting period, the Modulim equipment will be calibrated and setup ready for scanning. Subject's volar aspect of the thumb along with the palm surface will be ready to target the optical camera head. Actual scanning takes less than 60 seconds. The images will be processed offline. During processing 3-5 different regions of interest will be taken to measure the oxygen parameters such as tissue oxygen saturation, oxy-hemoglobin, deoxy-hemoglobin, superficial hemoglobin, and sub-surface hemoglobin.

DEVICEPerimed PeriFlux 5000

Transcutaneous oxygen monitoring (TCOM or TcpO2) is a noninvasive, clinically-approved method to obtain skin oxygen levels. The method is quantitative, and measures oxygen delivery to the skin from underlying tissue. Before positioning the electrode, an adhesive fixation ring will be placed on the dry skin on the volar aspect of the thumb and an electrolyte as a contact liquid will be filled half and the probe is aligned into it by rotating clock-wise to fasten it. Recording will be started and waited for the oxygen level to stabilize and a fixed value will be recorded. The probe will be heated to about 45oC. Although this device has other options, only the measurement of O2 will be performed using this device.

DEVICEApple Watch Oxygen Sensor

The apple watch is equipped with green, red, and infrared LEDs that shine light onto the blood vessels in the wrist, with photodiodes measuring the amount of light reflected back. Apple's algorithms use this information to calculate the color of the blood, which is an indication of how much oxygen is in the blood. Bright red blood is well oxygenated, while darker blood has less oxygen. This can measure blood oxygen levels between 70 and 100 percent. Most healthy people have blood oxygen levels that range from 95 to 100 percent. The apple watch sensor will be positioned on the user's preferred wrist.

DEVICEInnovo iP 900AP

The pulse oximeter enables transcutaneous monitoring of the oxygen saturation of hemoglobin in arterial blood. In this study, volar aspect of thumb and index finder of the subject will be used to measure blood oxygen saturation.

Sponsors

Indiana University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
NA
Intervention model
SINGLE_GROUP
Primary purpose
OTHER
Masking
NONE

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 65 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

* Healthy volunteers * Able to understand and complete the Informed Consent * Both males and females * Age between 18-65 years * All ethnic backgrounds

Exclusion criteria

* Patients or limited health conditions * Smoking tobacco product * Prisoners * Cannot consent for themselves

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Device-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementVisit 1, up to 2 hours in duration4 devices used to measures the tissue oxygen saturation on healthy human volunteers
Male vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurement1 visit, 2hrsGoal is to see if there is a variation in the gender biased. The criteria for the male vs female comparison were considered to find better or worse outcomes.
Skin Type Based Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation1 visit, 2hrs durationFitzpatrick chart-based skin categorization of the skin type. The criteria for the Fitzpatrick Skin Type grades IV, II & III were matched with Fitzpatric table and grades were considered to find better or worse outcomes. Please Note: The skin type analysis was performed irrespective to the devices. Only skin types were considered. So, there is no need of adding arms/groups other than the (1) Skin type IV and (2) the skin type II& III.

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Multi-Modal Measurement of Tissue Oxygenation on Healthy Volunteers
In a single study visit, oxygen saturation was measured on participants with SFDI, TCOM, Apple Watch Oxygen Sensor, and a Pulse Oximeter. The thumb and index fingers are at rest, during the occlusion, and during the hyperemic post-occlusion period. Completion of all planned interventions may take up to 2 hours on the study visit day. Modulum: Equipment will be calibrated and set up ready for scanning. volar aspect of the thumb surface imaged. parameters: tissue oxygen saturation, oxy-hemoglobin, deoxy-hemoglobin, superficial hemoglobin, and sub-surface hemoglobin. PeriFlux 5000: tcpO2 is a noninvasive, clinically-approved method to obtain skin oxygen levels. The probe is placed on dry skin on the volar aspect of the thumb. A recording will be started and waited for the oxygen level to stabilize and a fixed value will be recorded. Apple Watch Oxygen Sensor: The Apple watch wrist's Bright red blood is well-oxygenated, while darker blood has less oxygen. Can measure blood oxygen levels between 70 and 100 percent. Healthy people have blood oxygen levels that range from 95 to 100 percent. Oximeter: The pulse oximeter enables monitoring of the oxyhemoglobin in arterial blood. volar aspect index finder of the subject was used to measure blood oxygen saturation.
20
Total20

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicMulti-Modal Measurement of Tissue Oxygenation on Healthy Volunteers
Age, Categorical
<=18 years
0 Participants
Age, Categorical
>=65 years
0 Participants
Age, Categorical
Between 18 and 65 years
20 Participants
Age, Continuous34.2 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 6.06
Race (NIH/OMB)
American Indian or Alaska Native
0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Asian
10 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Black or African American
0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
More than one race
0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
White
10 Participants
Region of Enrollment
United States
20 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
7 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
13 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
EG002
affected / at risk
EG003
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 200 / 200 / 200 / 20
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 200 / 200 / 200 / 20
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 200 / 200 / 200 / 20

Outcome results

Primary

Device-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurement

4 devices used to measures the tissue oxygen saturation on healthy human volunteers

Time frame: Visit 1, up to 2 hours in duration

Population: The Apple watch and the Pulse Oximeters are the devices designed to measure blood oxygenation based on the blood pulses occurring in the blood vessels when there is actual flow. At the time of occlusion there is no blood vessels pulsating, so the data were measured zero.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
SFDIDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementbaseline62.7 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 18.11
SFDIDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementduring occlusion44.8 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 16.03
SFDIDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementreactive hyperamia71.1 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 17.41
SFDIDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementRecovery65.8 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 17.94
TCOMDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementduring occlusion67.95 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 14.97
TCOMDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementreactive hyperamia87.21 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 9.09
TCOMDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementRecovery79.9 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 10.7
TCOMDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementbaseline91.2 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 11.98
Apple WatchDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementreactive hyperamia97.88 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 1.16
Apple WatchDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementduring occlusion0 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 0
Apple WatchDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementRecovery97.50 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 1.12
Apple WatchDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementbaseline97.58 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 1.14
Pulse OximeterDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementRecovery97.56 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 1.04
Pulse OximeterDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementduring occlusion0 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 0
Pulse OximeterDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementbaseline97.95 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 1.05
Pulse OximeterDevice-wise Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurementreactive hyperamia99.24 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 1.09
Primary

Male vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation Measurement

Goal is to see if there is a variation in the gender biased. The criteria for the male vs female comparison were considered to find better or worse outcomes.

Time frame: 1 visit, 2hrs

Population: The Apple watch and the Pulse Oximeters are the devices designed to measure blood oxygenation based on the blood pulses occurring in the blood vessels when there is actual flow. At the time of occlusion there is no blood flow, the vessels are not pulsating, so the data were measured zero.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
SFDIMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementMale61.40 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 21.75
SFDIMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementFemale65.48 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 6.48
TCOMMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementFemale85.61 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 14.54
TCOMMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementMale94.15 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 10.67
Apple WatchMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementMale97.43 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 1
Apple WatchMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementFemale97.85 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 0.96
Pulse OximeterMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementMale97.87 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 0.91
Pulse OximeterMale vs Female Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation MeasurementFemale98.09 percentage of OxygenStandard Deviation 0.62
Primary

Skin Type Based Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation

Fitzpatrick chart-based skin categorization of the skin type. The criteria for the Fitzpatrick Skin Type grades IV, II & III were matched with Fitzpatric table and grades were considered to find better or worse outcomes. Please Note: The skin type analysis was performed irrespective to the devices. Only skin types were considered. So, there is no need of adding arms/groups other than the (1) Skin type IV and (2) the skin type II& III.

Time frame: 1 visit, 2hrs duration

Population: Type II: Fitzpatrick grades were according to the following criteria:- Fair skin, blue eyes; burns easily, tans poorly.~Type III: Fitzpatrick grades were according to the following criteria:- Darker white skin; tans after initial burn.~Type IV: Fitzpatrick grades were according to the following criteria:- Light brown skin; burns minimally, tans easily.~This was used to grade from the Fitzpatrick skin type scale questionnaire.

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
SFDISkin Type Based Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation21.62 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 3.09
TCOMSkin Type Based Comparison of Tissue Oxygenation24.64 percentage of oxygenStandard Deviation 2.66

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026