Maternal Sepsis, Neonatal Sepsis
Conditions
Keywords
maternal health, neonatal health, patient discharge, post-natal care
Brief summary
This study aims to build a predictive algorithm that identifies mother-newborn dyads most at risk of death or complications in the 6 weeks after birth. The investigators will conduct a multi-site cohort study with 7,000 dyads in Uganda and engage with local stakeholders (e.g., patients, healthcare workers, and health policy-makers) to develop an evidence-based bundle of interventions that address key practice gaps and the critical factors leading to death and complications in these dyads. In the investigator's epidemiological study of post-delivery post-discharge outcomes in 3,236 dyads in Uganda (2017-2020), results indicated that most newborn and maternal readmissions were due to infectious illness (i.e. sepsis, surgical site infections, malaria), and primarily occurred early in the post-discharge period. Thus, the focus of this study will be identifying interventions that target these common and early outcomes, for both mothers and newborns, using World Health Organization recommendations, patient and caregiver experiences, and stakeholder recommendations. If successful, results will inform the next steps of this project, which is the external validation of the model and clinical evaluation of a personalized approach to improving health outcomes and health-seeking behaviour for mothers and newborns.
Detailed description
PURPOSE Neonatal outcomes are highly correlated with the health of the mother, an example of this is shown repeatedly by poor rates of survival of infants after maternal death. Prediction of risk, based on the mother and infant as a pair, is a major gap in current research and yet vital to the survival of both the mom and the infant. Thus, maternal and child health outcomes can be improved by identifying both mothers and babies at increased risk of mortality or serious morbidity after hospital discharge and allocating scarce resources for targeted follow-up to those most vulnerable. This allows the investigators to not only improve health outcomes but benefits the health system with efficient use of resources. JUSTIFICATION Since 2011, the investigators have been working with partners in Uganda to develop, validate, and implement an innovative program for children under 5 years who have been discharged following hospitalization for suspected sepsis. In this research and implementation program, called Smart Discharges, healthcare workers use an individualized risk prediction score to identify children at high risk of death or complications after discharge from a hospital following treatment for suspected sepsis. They can then use this score to guide the intensity of a counselling and community-referral program. While all participants receive counselling, only those above a certain risk threshold receive down-referrals to community health facilities. The investigators have shown that this approach may reduce post-discharge child mortality after in-hospital treatment for suspected sepsis by as much as 30%. Now, the investigators are working to expand their innovative precision public health approach to improving post-discharge care for mother-newborn dyads. Findings will inform the development an evidence-based bundle of care for both the mother and newborn. This package will ensure that low-risk mother-infant pairs receive less burdensome (yet pragmatic and feasible) postpartum care, while high risk pairs receive a more extensive bundle of interventions (such as education, nutrition, healthcare interaction and community support). The Smart Discharges for Mom & Baby package will include support targeting aspects of both clinical and emotional wellbeing. Additional extensions of this work will include validating the risk models in women who deliver at home or suffer a stillbirth to ensure that more women and babies can benefit from the proposed intervention. HYPOTHESIS Maternal and infant characteristics collected at the time of discharge following a facility delivery can predict the risk of maternal or neonatal death or need for re-admission within six weeks of birth. OBJECTIVE The primary objective is to inform the development of an integrated maternal and newborn risk-based post-discharge care program. Specifically, the study aims to (1) develop and internally validate clinical risk prediction models for identifying dyads at high-risk of death or hospital readmission in the 6-week post-delivery post-discharge period, and (2) identify gaps and opportunities during in-hospital, discharge, and post-discharge care to inform the future development of an evidence-and risk-based bundle of interventions to improve postnatal care (PNC) for dyads. DESIGN This is a mixed-methods study using both quantitative and qualitative techniques to explore and map the current postnatal discharge processes in Uganda using data from two distinct hospital settings. * Phase I) The team will conduct an observational cohort study informed through direct observation of the mother and newborn dyad prior to facility discharge and after delivery and follow-up telephone interviews conducted at six-weeks post-discharge. * Phase II) The team will conduct journey mapping with a subset of dyads enrolled in the observational cohort using direct observation and follow-up telephone interviews. * Phase III) The team will conduct a process mapping exercise using focus group discussion methodology with select facility staff. * Phase IV) The team will conduct focus group discussions with a subset of mothers enrolled in the observational cohort, as well as their family members. STATISTICAL ANALYSIS Quantitative analysis: The investigators will summarize all risk factors for mothers and newborns that do and do not experience poor outcomes and estimate univariate associations. For newborns, data will be reported by sex. Derivation of prediction models will be based on optimization of the area under the receiver operating curve (AUROC) and specificity across a variety of modeling and variable selection approaches (e.g., logistic regression, elastic net, support vector machines). Model performance will be based on appropriate re-sampling techniques for internal validation (e.g., cross-validation, bootstrapping). Focus will be on developing parsimonious predictive models (e.g., 5-10 predictor variables) with high sensitivity (\>80%). AUROC, sensitivity, and specificity will be reported for each model, along with positive and negative predictive values. Site specific metrics will be compared to ensure consistency across settings, and re-calibration may be considered if individual site performance is lower than expected. Finally, the investigators will assess combined sensitivity and specificity when each individual model is applied to the dyad. Outside of prediction modelling, the sample size will allow the investigators to detect an odds ratio of at least 1.30 for a given risk factor with 80% power and 5% significance and relative precision of 25%. Statistical analysis of quantitative data from journey mapping observation surveys and patient interviews will be performed using R Statistical software to obtain descriptive statistics of the frequency and distribution of each variable. Qualitative Analysis: the investigators will analyze data collected descriptively and report summary statistics. A diagram of the discharge process will be developed, identifying key areas for improvement during the peri-discharge and post-discharge process. Focus group discussion data will be analyzed using a framework method, which allows themes to be developed inductively from participants and deductively from existing literature. Through an iterative process, transcripts will be coded and analyzed for descriptive and interpretive themes using NVivo. Descriptive themes include barriers to care and post-discharge health-seeking behaviour, while interpretive themes focus on caregiver perspectives of maternal and neonatal death and the role of the health system. The investigators will generate frequencies to describe reported medical symptoms, health-seeking behaviour, and barriers to care, and summarize common themes. Member checking will be used to improve the validity of the results, creating a summary document of the main findings that will be reviewed by health workers who participated in the focus groups. Feedback from patients and families will be obtained over telephone with research nurses who will explain the main findings verbally.
Interventions
This is a non-interventional study
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
* Women and adolescent girls aged 12 and above delivering a single or multiple babies at the study hospital during the active recruitment phase.
Exclusion criteria
* Inability, for whatever reason, to provide informed consent. * Language barrier * Mother is from a refugee camp * Mother has no access to phone or other means for follow-up * Mother lives outside of hospital catchment area
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Post-discharge Readmission or Mortality | 6 weeks following delivery | Composite rate of maternal or neonatal death or re-admission within 6 weeks following delivery |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Post-natal Care Visits | 6 weeks following delivery | % patients who reported attending at least one post-natal care visits within 6 weeks following delivery |
| Post-discharge Health Seeking | 6 weeks following delivery | % of patients who reported seeking post-discharge care within 6 weeks following delivery |
Countries
Canada
Participant flow
Recruitment details
Recruited women presenting for delivery at Jinja and Mbarara Regional Referral Hospitals in Uganda between March 2022 and August 2023 through a quasi-random sampling method. All women enrolled were followed up with, including those who delivered stillbirths or newborns who died in hospital.
Participants by arm
| Arm | Count |
|---|---|
| Phase I: Observational, Mother Mother enrolled from the two participating hospitals. | 7,131 |
| Phase I: Observational, Neonate Neonate enrolled after delivery including those that were stillbirths or died before being discharged. | 7,359 |
| Total | 14,490 |
Withdrawals & dropouts
| Period | Reason | FG000 | FG001 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Study | Died after being admitted | 0 | 44 |
| Overall Study | Died during or after delivery | 2 | 85 |
| Overall Study | Lost to Follow-up | 69 | 77 |
| Overall Study | Stillbirth | 0 | 262 |
Baseline characteristics
| Characteristic | Phase I: Observational, Mother | Total | Phase I: Observational, Neonate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Admitted to hospital during pregnancy | 1002 Participants | 1002 Participants | — |
| Age, Continuous | 26 years | 26 years | — |
| Apgar at 1 minute | — | 9 score | 9 score |
| Apgar at 5 minutes | — | 10 score | 10 score |
| Birth Weight | — | 3.1 kg | 3.1 kg |
| Diagnosed with a pregnancy-related illness during pregnancy | 4291 Participants | 4291 Participants | — |
| Diagnosed with chronic illness before pregnancy | 865 Participants | 865 Participants | — |
| Education level ≤ P3 | 263 Participants | 263 Participants | — |
| Education level P4-P7 | 2263 Participants | 2263 Participants | — |
| Education level Post-secondary | 1400 Participants | 1400 Participants | — |
| Education level S1-S6 | 3200 Participants | 3200 Participants | — |
| Had admission vitals taken | 7020 Participants | 7020 Participants | — |
| Had any children who have died | 854 Participants | 854 Participants | — |
| Household had sufficient food during pregnancy | 1243 Participants | 1243 Participants | — |
| Length | — | 49.5 cm | 49.5 cm |
| Lives with the father of the baby | 6439 Participants | 6439 Participants | — |
| Low birthweight (<2500g) | — | 1038 Participants | 1038 Participants |
| Mode of Delivery Assisted vaginal | 15 Participants | 15 Participants | — |
| Mode of Delivery Caesarean with labour | 1995 Participants | 1995 Participants | — |
| Mode of Delivery Caesarean without labour | 572 Participants | 572 Participants | — |
| Mode of Delivery Vaginal | 4546 Participants | 4546 Participants | — |
| Mother admitted to higher care following delivery | 570 Participants | 570 Participants | — |
| Number of antenatal care visits <4 | 1862 Participants | 1862 Participants | — |
| Number of antenatal care visits 4-8 | 5140 Participants | 5140 Participants | — |
| Number of antenatal care visits >8 | 125 Participants | 125 Participants | — |
| Number of babies delivered Individual | 6907 Participants | 6907 Participants | — |
| Number of babies delivered Triplet | 5 Participants | 5 Participants | — |
| Number of babies delivered Twin | 217 Participants | 217 Participants | — |
| Parity | 2 pregnancies | 2 pregnancies | — |
| Race and Ethnicity Not Collected | — | 0 Participants | — |
| Referral | 3163 Participants | 3163 Participants | — |
| Resuscitation at birth Not Resuscitated | 4560 Participants | 4560 Participants | — |
| Resuscitation at birth Resuscitation without oxygen | 1877 Participants | 1877 Participants | — |
| Resuscitation at birth Resuscitation with oxygen | 265 Participants | 265 Participants | — |
| Sex: Female, Male Female | 7131 Participants | 10554 Participants | 3423 Participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Male | 0 Participants | 3763 Participants | 3763 Participants |
| Socioeconomic Index Score | 3 score on a scale | 3 score on a scale | — |
| Surgical urgency of caesarean births At a time to suit the patient and maternity team | 400 Participants | 400 Participants | — |
| Surgical urgency of caesarean births Immediate threat to woman or fetus | 1246 Participants | 1246 Participants | — |
| Surgical urgency of caesarean births Maternal/fetal compromise but not immediately life threatening | 877 Participants | 877 Participants | — |
| Surgical urgency of caesarean births Needs early delivery but no maternal/fetal compromise | 30 Participants | 30 Participants | — |
| Transport time >1 hour | 1001 Participants | 1001 Participants | — |
| Transport time 30 minutes to 1 hour | 2713 Participants | 2713 Participants | — |
| Transport time Less than 30 minutes | 3414 Participants | 3414 Participants | — |
Adverse events
| Event type | EG000 affected / at risk | EG001 affected / at risk |
|---|---|---|
| deaths Total, all-cause mortality | 3 / 7,131 | 453 / 7,359 |
| other Total, other adverse events | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
| serious Total, serious adverse events | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
Outcome results
Post-discharge Readmission or Mortality
Composite rate of maternal or neonatal death or re-admission within 6 weeks following delivery
Time frame: 6 weeks following delivery
| Arm | Measure | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|
| Phase I: Observational, Mother | Post-discharge Readmission or Mortality | 231 Participants |
| Phase I: Observational, Neonate | Post-discharge Readmission or Mortality | 349 Participants |
Post-discharge Health Seeking
% of patients who reported seeking post-discharge care within 6 weeks following delivery
Time frame: 6 weeks following delivery
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phase I: Observational, Mother | Post-discharge Health Seeking | Care seeking resulted in readmission | 230 Participants |
| Phase I: Observational, Mother | Post-discharge Health Seeking | Care seeking did not result in readmission | 2637 Participants |
| Phase I: Observational, Neonate | Post-discharge Health Seeking | Care seeking resulted in readmission | 287 Participants |
| Phase I: Observational, Neonate | Post-discharge Health Seeking | Care seeking did not result in readmission | 1161 Participants |
Post-natal Care Visits
% patients who reported attending at least one post-natal care visits within 6 weeks following delivery
Time frame: 6 weeks following delivery
| Arm | Measure | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|
| Phase I: Observational, Mother | Post-natal Care Visits | 446 Participants |
| Phase I: Observational, Neonate | Post-natal Care Visits | 187 Participants |