Dysphagia, Rehabilitation, Stroke
Conditions
Keywords
dysphagia, stroke, biofeedback, rehabilitation, randomized controlled study
Brief summary
The aim of the study is to evaluate whether the effect of biofeedback treatment is more effective than a control treatment in the recovery of dysphagia. This study will be a multicentric randomized, single-blind controlled study. The investigators intend to recruit 100 patients who have suffered a stroke and have dysphagia. Fifty patients will undergo training with bio-feedback (experimental group) and the other fifty patients will undergo standard training, using only verbal feedback rather than visual feedback (control group). Our hypothesis, based on the results obtained in some previous studies, is that in the control group the efficacy of the treatment will be lower in the absence of immediate visual feedback of strength, timing, coordination and efficacy of the swallowing act.
Detailed description
The procedure is divided into the following steps: * Clinical and instrumental evaluation (fibroendoscopy) of swallowing functions before the treatment; * 20 sessions with bio feedback treatment or 20 session of control treatment; * Clinical and instrumental evaluation (fibroendoscopy) of swallowing functions after the training; * Clinical and instrumental evaluation (fibroendoscopy) of swallowing functions after 2 months as follow up. Each participant will attend 5 sessions per week for a total duration of 4 weeks. The duration of each session will take 1 hour, including bio-feedback preparation that will take about 10 minutes for assembly and 5 minutes for removal. At the beginning of the bio-feedback session, two surface electrodes will be applied to the mylohyoid muscle. The computer will analyze the electromyographic signal of the patient in real time and will produce visual feedback of the muscular activity on the screen. The patient will be required to swallow at a given time, with food bolus if possible, and perform maneuvers that favor swallowing strength and efficacy. During the first session, participant will be instructed to use the tool before starting the training phase. Patients of both groups will participate in similar sessions, with classical maneuvers favoring swallowing efficacy that is effortful swallow and specific task of timing and coordination (with bolus administration, if possible) and Masako maneuver. The experimental group will perform this training for 45 minutes with the support of visualization of muscle activity on the screen (biofeedback), while the control group will attend the same training for 45 minutes, but receiving verbal feedback from the speech and language therapist. Data analysis On the measures collected, a descriptive statistical analyzis and distribution will be studied. Initial instrumental and clinical data will be collected administrating: FOIS scale (Functional Oral Intake Scale), PAS (Penetration-Aspiration Scale), Yale Scale, MASA (Mann Assessment of Swallowing Abilities),SWAL QOL (outcomes tool for oropharyngeal dysphagia in adults), TOMASS (test of masticated and swallowing solids); Cranial nerves. All the tests will be analyzed using parametric (t-test) and non-parametric (Wilcoxon test) tests with a p-value considered significant if \<0.05, while longitudinal variations will be analysed using ANOVA for repeated measurements.
Interventions
DEVICEBiofeedback
Each participant will attend 5 sessions per week for a total duration of 4 weeks. The duration of each session will take 1 hour, including bio-feedback preparation. At the beginning of the bio-feedback session, two surface electrodes will be applied to the mylohyoid muscle. The patient will be required to swallow at a given time, with food bolus if possible, and perform maneuvers that favour swallowing strength and efficacy: effortful swallow, specific task for timing and coordination, Masako maneuver. The experimental group will perform this training for 45 minutes, plus they will receive a verbal feedback from the speech and language therapist in relation to the efficacy of the performance.
OTHERConventional
Each participant will attend 5 sessions per week for a total duration of 4 weeks. The patient will be required to swallow at a given time, with food bolus if possible, and perform maneuvers that favour swallowing strength and efficacy: effortful swallow, specific task for timing and coordination, Masako maneuver. The control group will perform this training for 45 minutes, with a verbal feedback from the speech and language therapist in relation to the efficacy of the performance.
Sponsors
IRCCS San Camillo, Venezia, Italy
Ospedale Policlinico San Martino
Azienda Ulss 6 Euganea
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE
Intervention model description
simple randomization in two groups
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 89 Years
Healthy volunteers
No
Inclusion criteria
* first stroke injury * onset from more than six weeks * presence of dysphagia * good comprehension ( not below PT 53 in Token Test) * good eyesight and hearing, or adequately corrected
Exclusion criteria
* All the elements that hinder a good recording of the electromyographic signal (for instance a cutaneous infection, a wound or a dermatitis in the submandibular area); * Severe concomitant illnesses (fever, infections, metabolic problems, serious cardiac insufficiency) that can influence patient's collaboration; * Serious dystonia or unintentional movements * presence of disorders of consciousness; * encephalopathy due to multiple infarcts; * inability to sustain the experimental treatment; * other neurological diseases (for example Parkinson disease)
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Positive changes of efficacy of swallowing | The evaluation of swallowing functions will be done before treatment, then up to 4 weeks (after 20 treatment sessions) finally up to two months | Efficacy of swallowing is defined as patient's ability to start a functional swallowing reflex and to manage deglutition of saliva, then small bolus in ever greater quantities until getting to a full meal in safety. It will be measured by FOIS (Functional Oral Intake Scale- minimum value is the worst: 1; maximum value:7 |
| Changes in penetration/aspiration of saliva or bolus | The evaluation of swallowing the entity of penetration/aspiration will be done before treatment, then up to 4 weeks (after 20 treatment sessions) finally up to two months] | Penetration is a generic term refering to the action of material penetrating the larynx and entering the airway and remains above the true vocal folds, while aspiration Aspiration is a generic term refering to the action of material penetrating the larynx and entering the airway below the true vocal folds. The presence, entity and gravity of that parameters will be measured by Penetration Aspiration Scale during fibroscopy. The minimum value is 1, and indicates the better performance; the maximum value is 8, that is the worst. |
| Changes in pharyngeal residues | The evaluation of swallowing the entity of pharyngeal residue will be done before treatment, then up to 4 weeks (after 20 treatment sessions) finally up to two months | They consist in presence of bolus or saliva post deglutition in the pharyngeal zone. The presence and entity/severity of these parameters will be assessed by Yale Scale during fibroscopy. The minimum value is 1, that means only coating, while 5 is the maximum level that means abundant residues. |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Quality of life in relation to swallowing disorders | The evaluation of the level of perceived quality of life will be done before treatment, then up to 4 weeks (after 20 treatment sessions), finally up to two months] | Dysphagia has an high impact on quality of life. It will be measured through SWAL\_QOL (quality of life in swallowing disorders). 100 indicates the most favorable state, 0 the least favorable. |
Countries
Italy
Contacts
CONTACTSara Nordio
PRINCIPAL_INVESTIGATORSara Nordio
IRCCS San Camillo
Outcome results
None listed