Ventilator Associated Pneumonia
Conditions
Brief summary
Increasing emergence of multidrug resistant (MDR) bacteria worldwide is now considered one of the most urgent threats to global health. The association between increase of antibiotics consumption and resistance emergence has been well documented for all patients admitted to the Intensive care unit (ICU) who received antibiotic treatment and for patients treated for ventilator associated pneumonia (VAP). Reduction of use of antibiotics is a major point in the war against antimicrobial resistance. VAP is the first cause of healthcare-associated infections in ICU and more than half of antibiotics prescriptions in ICU are due to VAP. Once the diagnosis of pneumonia under MV has been made, initiation of antibiotic treatment must be prompt but there is no clear consensus on its duration. In the case of a good clinical response to treatment, it has been shown in some situations that short course antibiotics can be effective without side effects and antimicrobial stewardship initiatives can be applied successfully and effectively to the management of Community Acquired Pneumonia (CAP). The hypothesis is that an antimicrobial stewardship is possible in the treatment of VAP with no increase in the rate of all-cause mortality, treatment failure or occurrence of new episode of pneumonia. The objective is to investigate whether an antimicrobial stewardship for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would be non-inferior in terms of all-cause mortality, treatment failure or occurrence of new episode of pneumonia. This study will be a prospective, national multicenter (31 centers), phase III, comparative randomized (1:1), single-blinded clinical trial comparing two management strategies of treatment of pneumonia on the basis of two parallel arms: Experimental group: Antimicrobial stewardship based on daily clinical assessment of clinical cure. Control group: standard management: duration of appropriate antibiotic therapy for confirmed VAP according to guidelines.
Detailed description
Increasing emergence of multidrug resistant (MDR) bacteria worldwide is now considered one of the most urgent threats to global health. The association between increase of antibiotics consumption and resistance emergence has been well documented for all patients admitted to the Intensive care unit (ICU) who received antibiotic treatment1 and for patients treated for ventilator associated pneumonia (VAP). Reduction of use of antibiotics is a major point in the war against antimicrobial resistance. VAP is the first cause of healthcare-associated infections in ICU and more than half of antibiotics prescriptions in ICU are due to VAP. Current international guidelines define VAP as a pneumonia occurring\>48 hours after endotracheal intubation and distinguishes early onset VAP occurring in the first five days after admission and late VAP, occurring after. Once the diagnosis of pneumonia under MV has been made, initiation of antibiotic treatment must be prompt but there is no clear consensus on its duration. In the case of a good clinical response to treatment, it has been shown in some situations that short course antibiotics can be effective without side effects and antimicrobial stewardship initiatives can be applied successfully and effectively to the management of Community Acquired Pneumonia (CAP). American guidelines strongly recommend a 7-day course of antibiotic therapy rather than a longer duration but remark that there exist situations in which a shorter or longer duration of antibiotics may be indicated, depending upon the rate of improvement of clinical, radiologic, and laboratory parameters. The hypothesis is that an antimicrobial stewardship is possible in the treatment of VAP with no increase in the rate of all-cause mortality, treatment failure or occurrence of new episode of pneumonia. The objective is to investigate whether an antimicrobial stewardship for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would be non-inferior in terms of all-cause mortality, treatment failure or occurrence of new episode of pneumonia. This study will be a prospective, national multicenter (31 centers), phase III, comparative randomized (1:1), single-blinded clinical trial comparing two management strategies of treatment of pneumonia on the basis of two parallel arms: Experimental group: Antimicrobial stewardship based on daily clinical assessment of clinical cure. Control group: standard management: duration of appropriate antibiotic therapy for confirmed VAP according to guidelines. The primary endpoint is a hierarchical endpoint with a first non-inferiority criteria and a second efficacy criteria.
Interventions
DRUGAntimicrobial Stewardship
Antimicrobial stewardship based on daily clinical assessment of clinical cure. Discontinuation of appropriate antibiotic therapy antibiotics if criteria of clinical cure of confirmed pneumonia are met. Intensivists will perform clinical assessment daily in order to decide on the pursuit or discontinuation of antibiotic therapy.
Standard management: duration of appropriate antibiotic for confirmed pneumonia fixed for 7 days according to guidelines. In the control group, intensivists will perform clinical assessment daily, but the antibiotic will not be discontinued until 7 days whatever the clinical cure.
Sponsors
Assistance Publique - Hôpitaux de Paris
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No
Inclusion criteria
* Diagnosis of microbiologically confirmed of first episode of VAP * Initial appropriate antibiotic therapy (whether empirical or not) * Written informed consent from the patient or a legal representative if appropriate. If absence of a legal representative the patient may be included in emergency procedure Definitive diagnosis of pneumonia (in agreement with international guidelines) is defined by association: * Patient under MV\>48 hours at the time of the microbiological sampling * New pulmonary infiltrate of which an infectious origin is strongly suspected * Worsening oxygenation * Have the following clinical criteria within the 24 hours prior to the first dose of antibiotic therapy * Purulent tracheal secretions * And at least 1 of the following : documented fever (body temperature \>38,3°C) or hypothermia (body temperature \<35°C) or white blood cell (WBC) count \>10,000 cells/mm3 or \<4,000 cells/mm3 * Microbiological criteria (positive quantitative culture of a lower respiratory tract (LRT): bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BAL) (significant threshold ≥10\^4 colony-forming units/mL) or plugged telescopic catheter (PTC) (significant threshold ≥ 10\^3 colony-forming units/mL) or quantitative endotracheal aspirate (ETA) distal pulmonary secretion samples (significant threshold ≥10\^5 colony-forming units/mL)
Exclusion criteria
* Patient under selective decontamination of the digestive tract * Duration of antibiotic therapy prior to inclusion \> 72h (for any reason) appropriate to the germs found in the bacterial documentation of the first episode of VAP * Inclusion in another interventional study concerning antimicrobial strategies * Moribund (IGS II\>80) * Thoracic trauma with Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) thorax ≥ 3 * Severely immunocompromised patients (such as congenital immunodeficiency, neutropenia (\<1leucocyte/ml or \<0.5 neutrophil/ml) or acute hematologic malignancy or stem cell transplant, HIV infection with CD4 count below 200/mm3 * Patients undergoing immunosuppressive therapy and long term corticotherapy \> 0.5 mg/kg * VAP due to: Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Carbapenem-resistant Acinetobacter spp, Carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae * VAP occurring in the context of co-infection of COVID-19 or other viral pneumonia (confirmed by RT-PCR) * Patients with empyema, necrotizing and abscessed pneumonia * Patients requiring extracorporeal oxygen therapy (ECMO), either veno-venous or veno-arterial * Pregnant women * No health insurance coverage
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would be non-inferior in terms of all-cause mortality, treatment failure or occurrence of new episode of pneumonia | 28 days | The primary endpoint is a composite endpoint with non-inferiority criteria including: 1\. all-cause mortality (ACM) measured at day 28 after initiation of therapy |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would be non-inferior in term of occurrence of treatment failure | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of treatment failure |
| investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would be non-inferior in term of occurrence of new episode of pneumonia | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of new episode of VAP |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would increase the number of antibiotic free-alive days, from initiation of VAP antibiotic therapy to day 28 | 28 days after inclusion | Number of antibiotic free alive-days |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion of VAP antibiotic therapy the global DOOR score | 28 days after inclusion | Global score constructed with the DOOR and RADAR |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion the duration of invasive mechanical ventilation | 28 days after inclusion | Duration of invasive MV |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion the length of stay in intensive care unit | 28 days after inclusion | Length of ICU stay |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would be non-inferior in term of all-cause mortality | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of all-cause mortality |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion the rate of complications of antibiotic therapy | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of antibiotic related side effects |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion the rate of acquisition of carriage of MDR bacteria | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of acquisition of MDR bacteria |
| Investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion: The rate of subsequent infection due to : carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of subsequent infection of MDR bacteria |
| Study if an AMS based on daily clinical assessment of clinical cure of VAP versus standard management would improve survival at days 28 and 90 after inclusion | 28 and 90 days after inclusion | Rate of death |
| Study the adherence to the AMS strategy (in order to identify factors associated to this adherence) in the intervention group only at day 28 after inclusion | 28 days after inclusion | Adherence to AMS strategy |
| Assess the medico-economic impact of antimicrobial stewardship applied to VAP at day 28 after inclusion | 28 days after inclusion | Total cumulative costs |
| To investigate whether an AMS for VAP based on daily assessment of clinical cure and antimicrobial discontinuation, if it is obtained, would reduce at day 28 after inclusion the rate of VAP recurrence | 28 days after inclusion | Rate of VAP recurrence |
Countries
France
Contacts
Primary ContactArnaud Foucrier
Backup ContactEmmanuel Weiss
Outcome results
None listed