Depression in Old Age
Conditions
Keywords
elderly depression, stigma, iCGI
Brief summary
This study aims to test for a wheelchair effect , as a potential impact of stigma, during the evaluation of clinical global impression of depression.Elderly patients will be asked to sit in a wheelchair, or in a regular chair during recording a 5 minute video of spontaneous speech collected the iCGI semi-structured interview. The videos are showed to 10 different psychiatrists whom each proceed to 10 iCGI rating assessments.The psychiatrists are blinded evaluators. They are not aware of the real objective of the study.
Detailed description
This is a multicentric, randomized study of depression severity assessments (by iCGI) for wheelchair sitting elderly patients versus regular chair sitting elderly patients.The iCGI is a validated scale to assess depression severity through 5 min videos viewing of semi-structured interviews. The frame of the interviews is made to obtain the material provided by the patients expected to facilitate the formation of an impression, an empathetic feeling, based on phenomenological concepts. The clinical interview is close to day-to-day clinical practice. Patients are randomized (1:1) into 2 groups: wheelchair group and control group. After randomization, a 5-minute video of spontaneous speech collecting the semi-structured iCGI interview is recorded. These videos will square the participant's face, torso, and thighs, with a ¾ angle, in order to visualise the patient and the chair he is sitting in. The face will not be blurred in order to access non his non-verbal communication. The videos are viewed by 10 different psychiatrists whom each proceed to 10 iCGI rating assessments, The psychiatrists are blinded evaluators. They are not aware of the objective of the study focusing on the impact of the wheelchair. They will be decepted with the information that the study aim to evaluate the iCGI, as a new version of the CGI with elderly patients. The 10 videos each psychiatrist have to assess are randomly selected following the next rules : * Un unbalanced number of wheelchair and regular chair videos, so as they don't guess the study directly focuses on the wheelchair. * The wheelchair/regular chair video ratio is 7/3 or 3/7 for each psychiatrist. * Each video is visualised once by one psychiatrist. Our objective is to highlight an assessment bias related to physical disability in depression in the elderly with the aim of improving the practices of all professionals involved.
Interventions
OTHERWheelchair
Patient will be asked to sit in a wheelchair, and a 5-minute video recording of spontaneous speech capturing the semi-structured iCGI interview is made.
Sponsors
Hospital Center Guillaume Régnier
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
OTHER
Masking
SINGLE (Outcomes Assessor)
Masking description
Participants included in the wheelchair group settle into a hospital wheelchair. The wheelchair comes from a batch of two, without specific brand, standard color. The videos are showed to 10 different psychiatrists whom each proceed to 10 iCGI rating assessments, after receiving methodological informations. The psychiatrists are blinded evaluators. They are not aware of the objective of the study focusing on the impact of the wheelchair. They will be decepted with the information that the study aim to evaluate the iCGI, as a new version of the CGI with elderly patients (we will procede to a feedback afterward).
Intervention model description
We procede in a randomization 1:1, stratified by site. In one group, patients will be seated in a wheelchair and in the second group, patients will be seated in an regular chair. Allocation concealment will be ensured by the use of sequentially numbered, opaque, sealed envelopes (SNOSE).
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
65 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No
Inclusion criteria
* Hospitalised or ambulatory patients * Suffering mild to severe depression, according to PHQ-9 (Patient Health Questionnaire-9) score ⩾ 5 \[11\]. * Ability to understand the protocol. * Signed consent of the participant regarding the given information. * Subscription to the social security system.
Exclusion criteria
* Walking disability (including walking with human help required). * Severe cognitive impairment diagnosed with MMSE (Mini Mental State Examination) score \<18 within the last three months. * Historical or current schizophrenia diagnosis recorded on the medical file. * Historical or current neurological disease recorded on the medical file : Neurodegenerative disorders, stroke, epilepsy. * Patients under guardianship or trusteeship.
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| psychiatrists' assessment of depression severity with the iCGI scale | after including all patients in the study, up to 24 month | The iCGI is a validated scale to assess depression severity through 5 min videos viewing of semi-structured interviews. We will compare the iCGI in the wheelchair group and the control group. Analyzes will be based on each group's mean score. |
Countries
France
Outcome results
None listed