Breast Cancer, Breast-Conserving Surgery, Mastectomy
Conditions
Keywords
early breast cancer, surgery, shared decision-making, m-health, application, patient decision aid
Brief summary
To develop application-enabled shared decision-making among patients with early breast cancer and evaluate the preliminary effects of the interventions.
Detailed description
Female breast is an amazing organ that it symbolizes not only the female gender, but also the continuity of human race. In the past treating breast cancer may signal a termination of the breast's predestined role in a woman or a mother. Nowadays, surgical treatment of early breast cancer has two options, one is breast-conserving surgery and the other one is total mastectomy. The former treatment option preserves most of the breast tissue but may spare dormant cancer cells in the preserved tissue. The latter treatment option spares no breast tissue and as a result no dormant cancer cells would remain. This treatment dilemma may bother most of the patients especially when they are still under the shade of the bad news. Many women are reluctant to discuss their diseased breasts with their folks or even their doctors because of privacy; instead they would seek information through internet. Unfortunately, most of their final decision is doctor's preferred choice despite they may have doubts or concerns on doctor's choice of treatment. Share decision making (SDM) is a recently developed strategy that allows patients taking part in their treatment plan. Patients are invited to join the meeting where doctors explain the latest treatment options and patients express their concerns and finally a decision, both doctors' and patients' concerns well integrated, is reached. One of the drawbacks of SDM is too time consuming; doctors have to prepare a lot of pertinent information, while patients have to try their best to understand the provided information, though many patients may not fully understand their treatment options. It has been reported that a well designed patient decision aids (PDAs) could serve as a virtue connection between patients and doctors. Instead of merely taking information from the PDAs, it allows patients to know all the possible options of treatment and the side effects in an interactive way. It is supposed that patients could be well prepared to discuss with their doctors after interaction with the customized PDAs. In Taiwan, decision conflict and decision regret are commonly encountered among most cancer patients. The impetus for developing a PDAs for female breast cancer patients and evaluating its role on lowering decision conflict and decision regret among these patients comes from the high rates of decision conflict and decision regret among cancer patients in Taiwan.
Interventions
OTHERmobile application (BC-SDM)
The mobile application (BC-SDM)includes four functions to support SDM activity: Understanding breast cancer, Surgical approach, Choose the right breast cancer knowledge, and Let's make a decision for myself. Patients first read the information in Understanding breast cancer and Surgical approach to receive a tailored education in breast cancer
Sponsors
Chang Gung Memorial Hospital
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
FEMALE
Age
20 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No
Inclusion criteria
* women, aged \>20 years * newly diagnosed early breast cancer (stages 0-II) * no surgery yet * no metastases * tumor size \<3 cm
Exclusion criteria
•tumor located \<2 cm from the nipple
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| knowledge tests | immediately after the intervention | The knowledge tests included five items,1. Are the survival rates of breast cancer the same with conserving surgery and total mastectomy? 2. Breast-conserving surgery has a higher local-regional recurrence rate? 3. Is radiation therapy required for Breast-conserving surgery? 4. Does total mastectomy require longer recovery time? 5. Do both total mastectomy and breast-conserving surgery have the same bleeding and infection rate? The knowledge tests included five items, such as Are the survival rates of breast cancer the same with conserving surgery and total mastectomy? The correct answer was coded as one point. The scores of the knowledge tests ranged from zero to five points. Higher scores indicated more correct knowledge. |
| decision conflict-sure | immediately after the intervention | The Decision Conflict Scale (DCS\_SURE) included four items: uncertainty, information, values clarity, and support and effective decision. On the scale, Yes answers scored one point, while No responses were zero points. The higher score, the lesser conflict. |
| Decision Regret Scale DRS | immediately after the intervention | The Decision Regret Scale was composed of five items: It was the right decision, I regret the choice that was made, I would go for the same choices if I had to do it over again, The choices did me a lot of harm, and The decision was a wise one. Items were scored using a five-point Likert scale, ranging from very agreed (1 point) to very disagreed (5 points), but two items were reversely scored. The higher score, the more regret. |
Countries
Taiwan
Outcome results
None listed