Skip to content

Opioid-free Analgesia for the Management of Acute Post-operative Pain Following Caesarean Section

Single-centre, Randomized, Clinical Trial of Opioid-free Analgesia Versus Routine Opioid-based Analgesia Regimen for the Management of Acute Post-operative Pain Following Caesarean Section

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT04539249
Acronym
OFAAPPCS
Enrollment
324
Registered
2020-09-04
Start date
2020-11-04
Completion date
2021-03-31
Last updated
2023-07-20

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Acute Post-operative Pain Following Caesarean Section

Brief summary

Background: Multimodal analgesia; a combination of opioid and non-opioid analgesics, for management of acute post-operative pain significantly reduces the incidence of adverse effects associated with liberal post-operative opioid use including sedation, respiratory depression, constipation, ileus, urinary retention, delayed recovery, addiction etc. However, opioid addiction remains a worsening public health problem and have followed administration of opioid analgesics for post-operative pain and subsequent chronic use in many addicts; especially the opioid naive. Caesarean section is a commonly performed surgery and is a common source of first exposure to opioids in women. Trend in post-operative analgesia is moving towards opioid-free (multimodal) analgesia; a combination of non-opioid and adjuvant analgesics. Magnesium sulphate is an adjuvant analgesic. When administered peri-operatively, it has been reported to prolong the duration of spinal anaesthesia, decrease post-operative pain and opioid use without adverse effect. Aim: To determine the effectiveness and safety of a combination of peri-operative intravenous magnesium sulphate, intravenous paracetamol, and post-operative rectal diclofenac as opioid-free, multimodal analgesia for management of acute post-operative pain after a caesarean section. Null Hypothesis: Combination of intravenous magnesium sulphate, intravenous paracetamol, and rectal diclofenac as analgesia regimen for acute post-operative pain after a caesarean section is not as effective and safe as a routine opioid-based multimodal analgesia regimen used in the study setting. Alternate Hypothesis: Combination of intravenous magnesium sulphate, intravenous paracetamol, and rectal diclofenac as analgesia regimen for acute post-operative pain after a caesarean section is as effective and safe as a routine opioid-based multimodal analgesia regimen used in the study setting. Materials and Methods: A randomized clinical trial, comparing a combination of peri-operative intravenous magnesium sulphate, intravenous paracetamol, and post-operative rectal diclofenac with an opioid-based multimodal regimen as control. Eligible patients will be consecutively selected from among women booked for caesarean section at the Federal Medical Centre, Yenagoa. Control group will receive a combination of post-operative intramuscular pentazocine, intravenous paracetamol and rectal diclofenac. Pain intensity will be determined in both groups and compared. Need for rescue opioid analgesic will be determined in both groups and compared. Incidence of any adverse event in both groups will be determined.

Interventions

DRUGMagnesium sulphate

1g of paracetamol as an I.V infusion and 4g of magnesium sulphate as an I.V. bolus preoperatively. Continuous infusion of 1g/hr of magnesium sulphate intraoperatively and for the first 2 hours post-operatively. Further post-operatively, 100 mg of suppository diclofenac 12 hourly, intravenous paracetamol 1g 6 hourly, both over 24 hours. N.B: Intramuscular pentazocine 30 mg (45 mg if patient is \> 70 kg) will be used as rescue analgesia as needed (that is, only on patients' request for further analgesia or following an assessment of moderate to severe pain despite the planned analgesic regimen) at least 4 hourly during the first 24 hours after caesarean section.

Post-operatively, suppository diclofenac 100mg 12 hourly, intramuscular pentazocine 30 mg (45 mg if patient is \> 70 kg) 6 hourly, intravenous paracetamol 1g 6 hourly, all for 24 hours. N.B: Intramuscular pentazocine 30 mg (45 mg if patient is \> 70 kg) will be used as rescue analgesia as needed (that is, only on patients' request for further analgesia or following an assessment of moderate to severe pain despite the planned analgesic regimen) at least 4 hourly during the first 24 hours after caesarean section.

Sponsors

Olakunle Ifeoluwa Makinde
Lead SponsorOTHER_GOV

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
SUPPORTIVE_CARE
Masking
SINGLE (Outcomes Assessor)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
FEMALE
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* Pregnant women booked for elective, scheduled and urgent caesarean section at the Federal Medical Centre, Yenagoa, Bayelsa State during the study period, * Pregnant women who give consent to participate in the study.

Exclusion criteria

* Pregnant women with active peptic ulcer disease, active liver disease, hepatic failure, and renal failure, * Pregnant women with previous history of ischaemic heart disease/myocardial infarction, heart failure, venous thrombosis and stroke, * Hypersensitivity to pentazocine, paracetamol, diclofenac or magnesium sulphate, * Pregnant women with history of non-medical use (abuse) of opioids, * Pregnant women on magnesium sulphate or have a clinical indication to receive magnesium sulphate, * Pregnant women booked for emergency caesarean section (because the urgency may not allow time for adequate patient counseling before recruitment) * Pregnant women booked for caesarean section under general anaesthesia or epidural anaesthesia, * Pregnant women who can neither communicate in english nor colloquial english.

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Mean Dose of Pentazocine Used24 hours post-operativeMean dose of Pentazocine used in each arm of the study
Post-operative Pentazocine Use24 hours post-operativeWhether or not Pentazocine was used post-operatively
Pentazocine Use as Rescue Analgesia24 hours post-operativeWhether or not pentazocine was used as rescue analgesia
Frequency and Nature of Pentazocine Use24 hours post-operativeFrequency of Pentazocine use per participant in each arm of the study and whether it was used as indicated in the protocol and/or for rescue analgesia
Post-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 4 Hours Post-operative4 hours post-operativePost-operative pain scores following caesarean section at 4 hours post-operative using the Numerical Rating Scale for pain. The Numerical Rating Scale for pain has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a worse outcome (0= No pain at all, 5= Moderate pain and 10= Worst pain imaginable)
Post-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 8 Hours Post-operative8 hours post-operativePost-operative pain scores following caesarean section at 8 hours post-operative using the Numerical Rating Scale for pain. The Numerical Rating Scale for pain has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a worse outcome (0= No pain at all, 5= Moderate pain and 10= Worst pain imaginable)
Post-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 24 Hours Post-operative24 hours post-operativePost-operative pain scores following caesarean section at 24 hours post-operative using the Numerical Rating Scale for pain. The Numerical Rating Scale for pain has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a worse outcome (0= No pain at all, 5= Moderate pain and 10= Worst pain imaginable)

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Number of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsFirst 24 hours post-operativeNumber of participants with post-operative adverse events including respiratory depression constipation, ileus, pruritus, urinary retention and any other adverse event recorded during the first 24 hours post-operative.
Apgar Scores of the NeonatesAt first and fifth minutes after birthApgar scores of the neonates delivered by the women who had caesarean section under the study, taken at first and fifth minutes after birth. Apgar score has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a better outcome (0-3= low Apgar score, 4-6= moderately abnormal Apgar score and 7-10= reassuring Apgar score
Number of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsTime of first administration of peri-operative analgesia to 2 hours postoperativeNumber of participants with peri-operative adverse events including hypersensitivity reaction, respiratory depression, bradycardia, hypotension, nausea and vomiting, lightheadedness, presyncope, and any other adverse event recorded from the time of first administration of peri-operative analgesia to 2 hours postoperative

Countries

Nigeria

Participant flow

Pre-assignment details

A total of 324 participants were enrolled and assessed for eligibility. A total of 224 of the enrolled participants were excluded from the study. Of the 224, one (1) declined to participate while the rest 223 did not meet the inclusion criteria.

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Magnesium Sulphate
Combination of intravenous magnesium sulphate, intravenous paracetamol and rectal diclofenac Magnesium sulphate: 1g of paracetamol as an I.V infusion and 4g of magnesium sulphate as an I.V. bolus preoperatively. Continuous infusion of 1g/hr of magnesium sulphate intraoperatively and for the first 2 hours post-operatively. Further post-operatively, 100 mg of suppository diclofenac 12 hourly, intravenous paracetamol 1g 6 hourly, both over 24 hours. N.B: Intramuscular pentazocine 30 mg (45 mg if patient is \> 70 kg) will be used as rescue analgesia as needed (that is, only on patients' request for further analgesia or following an assessment of moderate to severe pain despite the planned analgesic regimen) at least 4 hourly during the first 24 hours after caesarean section.
50
Pentazocine
Combination of intramuscular pentazocine, intravenous paracetamol and rectal diclofenac Pentazocine: Post-operatively, suppository diclofenac 100mg 12 hourly, intramuscular pentazocine 30 mg (45 mg if patient is \> 70 kg) 6 hourly, intravenous paracetamol 1g 6 hourly, all for 24 hours. N.B: Intramuscular pentazocine 30 mg (45 mg if patient is \> 70 kg) will be used as rescue analgesia as needed (that is, only on patients' request for further analgesia or following an assessment of moderate to severe pain despite the planned analgesic regimen) at least 4 hourly during the first 24 hours after caesarean section.
50
Total100

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicMagnesium SulphatePentazocineTotal
Age, Continuous31.7 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 3.4
30.8 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.3
31.3 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 3.9
Age, Customized
20-24
0 Participants1 Participants1 Participants
Age, Customized
25-29
12 Participants19 Participants31 Participants
Age, Customized
30-34
25 Participants16 Participants41 Participants
Age, Customized
35-39
13 Participants14 Participants27 Participants
Parity
Multiparous (Carried two (2) or more pregnancies up to 28 weeks and beyond, irrespective of outcome)
33 Participants33 Participants66 Participants
Parity
Nulliparous (Never carried a pregnancy up to 28 weeks gestation or beyond)
6 Participants11 Participants17 Participants
Parity
Primiparous (Carried one (1) pregnancy up to 28 weeks and beyond, irrespective of outcome)
11 Participants6 Participants17 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Igbo
21 Participants18 Participants39 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Ijaw
23 Participants20 Participants43 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Others
6 Participants12 Participants18 Participants
Region of Enrollment
Nigeria
50 participants50 participants100 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
50 Participants50 Participants100 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Weight84.5 Kilograms
STANDARD_DEVIATION 12.8
77.9 Kilograms
STANDARD_DEVIATION 8.9
81.2 Kilograms
STANDARD_DEVIATION 11.5

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
EG002
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 40 / 460 / 50
other
Total, other adverse events
4 / 419 / 4620 / 50
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 41 / 460 / 50

Outcome results

Primary

Frequency and Nature of Pentazocine Use

Frequency of Pentazocine use per participant in each arm of the study and whether it was used as indicated in the protocol and/or for rescue analgesia

Time frame: 24 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureGroupValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseFour times (as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseTwo times (as rescue analgesia)11 Participants
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseFour times (per protocol)0 Participants
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseOnce (as rescue analgesia)35 Participants
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseThree times (as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseNot used at all4 Participants
Magnesium SulphateFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseMore than 4 times (per protocol + as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseNot used at all0 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseMore than 4 times (per protocol + as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseFour times (per protocol)50 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseFour times (as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseThree times (as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseTwo times (as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
PentazocineFrequency and Nature of Pentazocine UseOnce (as rescue analgesia)0 Participants
Primary

Mean Dose of Pentazocine Used

Mean dose of Pentazocine used in each arm of the study

Time frame: 24 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Magnesium SulphateMean Dose of Pentazocine Used52.83 MilligramsStandard Deviation 21.85
PentazocineMean Dose of Pentazocine Used164.40 MilligramsStandard Deviation 28.59
Primary

Pentazocine Use as Rescue Analgesia

Whether or not pentazocine was used as rescue analgesia

Time frame: 24 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureGroupValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Magnesium SulphatePentazocine Use as Rescue AnalgesiaPentazocine NOT used as rescue analgesia4 Participants
Magnesium SulphatePentazocine Use as Rescue AnalgesiaPentazocine used as rescue analgesia46 Participants
PentazocinePentazocine Use as Rescue AnalgesiaPentazocine used as rescue analgesia0 Participants
PentazocinePentazocine Use as Rescue AnalgesiaPentazocine NOT used as rescue analgesia50 Participants
Primary

Post-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 24 Hours Post-operative

Post-operative pain scores following caesarean section at 24 hours post-operative using the Numerical Rating Scale for pain. The Numerical Rating Scale for pain has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a worse outcome (0= No pain at all, 5= Moderate pain and 10= Worst pain imaginable)

Time frame: 24 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Magnesium SulphatePost-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 24 Hours Post-operative2.06 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 1.42
PentazocinePost-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 24 Hours Post-operative2.37 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 1.54
Primary

Post-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 4 Hours Post-operative

Post-operative pain scores following caesarean section at 4 hours post-operative using the Numerical Rating Scale for pain. The Numerical Rating Scale for pain has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a worse outcome (0= No pain at all, 5= Moderate pain and 10= Worst pain imaginable)

Time frame: 4 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Magnesium SulphatePost-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 4 Hours Post-operative2.98 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 1.18
PentazocinePost-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 4 Hours Post-operative3.16 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 1.45
Primary

Post-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 8 Hours Post-operative

Post-operative pain scores following caesarean section at 8 hours post-operative using the Numerical Rating Scale for pain. The Numerical Rating Scale for pain has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a worse outcome (0= No pain at all, 5= Moderate pain and 10= Worst pain imaginable)

Time frame: 8 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Magnesium SulphatePost-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 8 Hours Post-operative2.58 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 1.81
PentazocinePost-operative Pain Scores Following Caesarean Section at 8 Hours Post-operative2.68 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 1.63
Primary

Post-operative Pentazocine Use

Whether or not Pentazocine was used post-operatively

Time frame: 24 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureGroupValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Magnesium SulphatePost-operative Pentazocine UsePentazocine used46 Participants
Magnesium SulphatePost-operative Pentazocine UsePentazocine NOT used4 Participants
PentazocinePost-operative Pentazocine UsePentazocine used50 Participants
PentazocinePost-operative Pentazocine UsePentazocine NOT used0 Participants
Secondary

Apgar Scores of the Neonates

Apgar scores of the neonates delivered by the women who had caesarean section under the study, taken at first and fifth minutes after birth. Apgar score has a minimum score of 0, a maximum score of 10 and a range of 0-10, where higher scores mean a better outcome (0-3= low Apgar score, 4-6= moderately abnormal Apgar score and 7-10= reassuring Apgar score

Time frame: At first and fifth minutes after birth

ArmMeasureGroupCategoryValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Magnesium SulphateApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 1st minuteLess than 40 Participants
Magnesium SulphateApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 1st minute4-62 Participants
Magnesium SulphateApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 1st minute7-1048 Participants
Magnesium SulphateApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 5th minuteLess than 40 Participants
Magnesium SulphateApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 5th minute4-60 Participants
Magnesium SulphateApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 5th minute7-1050 Participants
PentazocineApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 5th minute4-60 Participants
PentazocineApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 1st minuteLess than 40 Participants
PentazocineApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 5th minuteLess than 41 Participants
PentazocineApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 1st minute4-66 Participants
PentazocineApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 5th minute7-1049 Participants
PentazocineApgar Scores of the NeonatesApgar score at the 1st minute7-1044 Participants
Secondary

Number of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse Events

Number of participants with peri-operative adverse events including hypersensitivity reaction, respiratory depression, bradycardia, hypotension, nausea and vomiting, lightheadedness, presyncope, and any other adverse event recorded from the time of first administration of peri-operative analgesia to 2 hours postoperative

Time frame: Time of first administration of peri-operative analgesia to 2 hours postoperative

Population: Number analyzed under severe (symptomatic) systolic hypotension (n=14; MgSo4 arm, n=5; Pentazocine arm ) and under severe (symptomatic) diastolic hypotension (n=24; MgSo4 arm, n=18; Pentazocine arm ) are subsets of the outcome measures systolic hypotension and diastolic hypotension with participant counts of (n=14; MgSo4 arm, n=5; Pentazocine arm ) and (n=24; MgSo4 arm, n=18; Pentazocine arm ) respectively

ArmMeasureGroupCategoryValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsBradycardiaPresent0 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsBradycardiaAbsent50 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSystolic hypotensionPresent14 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSystolic hypotensionAbsent36 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) systolic hypotensionPresent1 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) systolic hypotensionAbsent13 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsDiastolic hypotensionPresent24 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsDiastolic hypotensionAbsent26 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) diastolic hypotensionPresent1 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) diastolic hypotensionAbsent23 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsVomitingPresent1 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsVomitingAbsent49 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsLightheadednessPresent1 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsLightheadednessAbsent49 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsPresyncopePresent1 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsPresyncopeAbsent49 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsPresyncopeAbsent50 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsBradycardiaPresent2 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) diastolic hypotensionPresent0 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsBradycardiaAbsent48 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsLightheadednessPresent0 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSystolic hypotensionPresent5 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) diastolic hypotensionAbsent18 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSystolic hypotensionAbsent45 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsPresyncopePresent0 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) systolic hypotensionPresent0 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsVomitingPresent0 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsSevere (Symptomatic) systolic hypotensionAbsent5 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsLightheadednessAbsent50 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsDiastolic hypotensionPresent18 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsVomitingAbsent50 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Peri-operative Adverse EventsDiastolic hypotensionAbsent32 Participants
Secondary

Number of Participants With Post-operative Adverse Events

Number of participants with post-operative adverse events including respiratory depression constipation, ileus, pruritus, urinary retention and any other adverse event recorded during the first 24 hours post-operative.

Time frame: First 24 hours post-operative

ArmMeasureCategoryValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsPresent0 Participants
Magnesium SulphateNumber of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsAbsent4 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsPresent0 Participants
PentazocineNumber of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsAbsent46 Participants
Pentazocine OnlyNumber of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsPresent0 Participants
Pentazocine OnlyNumber of Participants With Post-operative Adverse EventsAbsent50 Participants

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 11, 2026