Direct Brow Lift, Scarring
Conditions
Keywords
onabotulinum toxin, direct brow lift, scarring, Botox
Brief summary
The brow lift is a surgical procedure that has been practiced for several decades. A typical indication is brow ptosis, which can be secondary to involutional changes or facial nerve palsies. Several techniques have been described, including direct, mid-forehead, coronal, and endoscopic approaches. Of these options, the direct brow lift allows for predictable post-operative brow contour and excellent control over the degree of lift achieved. As with any surgical procedure, with direct brow lift comes known undesirable post-operative outcomes, the most common of which is forehead paresthesia from supraorbital nerve damage. Other complications include alopecia and brow asymmetry. However, one of the main critiques of direct brow lift remains the poor cosmesis that can result from scarring just above the brow. A study conducted by Cho et al. concluded that of the main surgical techniques currently employed for treatment of brow ptosis, direct brow lifts held the highest rates of visible scarring. Scarring can significantly impair an individuals' quality of life. This is particularly true of facial scarring, which is often difficult to conceal. Much research has been conducted in the area of treating postoperative, traumatic, and burn-related scarring. Cadet et al completed a randomized controlled trial using topical silicone gel for direct brow lift-related scarring, given the known benefit of silicone gel sheeting for the same, but did not find a significant difference between treatment and control groups. Some effective techniques described in the literature to date include long-pulsed non-ablative Nd:YAG laser, as well as intralesional steroid injection. On the rise are studies looking into the use of botulinum toxin A for treatment of unfavourable scarring and improved facial cosmesis. Botulinum toxin is a neuromodulatory agent that has garnered usage in a variety of therapeutic and cosmetic settings. More recently, injection of botulinum toxin as a means to reduce scarring and improve outcomes in wound healing has been investigated. Several studies, including two large metaanalyses, have shown this to be an effective method of treatment. Proposed mechanisms include increased apoptosis and suppressed proliferation of fibroblasts treated with botulinum toxin, modulated via the PTEN/PI3K/Akt pathway. Park et al added to the in vitro literature by demonstrating that fibroblasts treated with botulinum toxin A produced fewer extracellular matrix proteins and pro-fibrotic factors compared to untreated cells. Another underlying mechanism that results in suboptimal wound healing is the constant contraction and relaxation of facial muscles, causing repetitive microtrauma that ultimately increases inflammation and impairs wound healing. It therefore stands to reason that by temporarily paralyzing local musculature during the post-operative period, collagen maturation can take place uninterrupted by excessive tensile forces. Despite scarring being a widely known and undesirable complication of direct brow lift surgery, there have been no studies to date examining the use of onabotulinum toxin injection to reduce said scarring and improve outcomes. With this double masked, prospective, randomized controlled trial, the investigators aim to determine whether injection of onabotulinum toxin immediately following direct brow lift surgery can improve scores on validated patient and observer scar scales.
Interventions
The side randomized to receive treatment will be injected with onabotulinum toxin A. Wound healing, scar characteristics, and patient satisfaction will be assessed post operatively. Scarring will be assessed by the patient, medical observers and a lay observer, all masked to the treatment vs placebo side. Standardized scales will be used, and pre-operative, intra-operative, and post-operative photographs will be taken for all participants. ImageJ software will be used to analyze the photos and measure the degree of brow lift achieved on each side, to ensure this has not been affected by onabotulinum toxin injection.
This group (of brows) will be receiving placebo injections containing normal saline. They will be assessed in the same manner as the treatment side.
Sponsors
Dalhousie University
Nova Scotia Health Authority
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
QUADRUPLE (Subject, Caregiver, Investigator, Outcomes Assessor)
Masking description
Computer randomization software will be used to determine whether the right or left side will receive onabotulinum toxin injection. The contralateral side will receive a placebo injection of equal volume (normal saline). The health care professional assisting with the procedure will not be masked to randomization. He/she will draw up the onabotulinum toxin A and placebo in two separate identical syringes marked A (right side) and B (left side). They will reference a form showing the results of the computer generated randomization, which will be kept in a study chart separate from the patient's normal oculoplastic visits. They will sign this form, as well as record the lot number of the onabotulinum toxin A and normal saline. The oculoplastic surgeon will visually divide each incision in half, and inject half of the volume of syringe A at each side of the right direct brow lift incision, and half of the volume of syringe B at each side of the left direct brow lift incision.
Intervention model description
This is a double masked, prospective, randomized controlled trial. Participants will function as their own internal control, with one side (i.e. brow) being randomized to the treatment arm, and the other to placebo.
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
Yes
Inclusion criteria
The patient population to be studied will include patients undergoing bilateral direct brow lifts at the Victoria General Hospital in Halifax, Nova Scotia. Patients must meet all of the following inclusion criteria, and have none of the
Exclusion criteria
listed below. Inclusion criteria: * Participants must be over 18 years of age * Participants must be able to attend outpatient appointments at the Victoria General Hospital * Participants must be able to give informed consent
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Effect of onabotulinum toxin A on scarring in direct brow lift surgery | 1 to 12 months | * At 1 month following surgery, photographs will be taken of both brows. The patient will then be given a mirror, and under consistent lighting conditions and in a private setting, will complete the Patient Scar Assessment Scale (PSAS) and Visual Analog Scale (VAS), after adequate explanation of each parameter. These scores will be combined for a total score ranging from 7 to 70, again with lower numbers indicating higher patient satisfaction. A masked lay observer (consistent person with every patient) will also complete the VAS. * The above step will be repeated at 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months after surgery, as well as the following additional steps. Scars will be graded by a masked observer using the Observer Scar Assessment Scale (OSAS), Observer Modified Scar Assessment Scale (OMSAS), and Visual Analog Scale (VAS). These scores will be combined for a total score ranging from 11 to 81, with lower scores indicating better outcome. |
| Degree of brow lift achieved | Pre-operative to 12 months | Pre-operative, intra-operative, and post-operative (at month 1, 3, 6, and 12) photographs will be taken for all participants. ImageJ software will be used to analyze the photos and measure the degree of brow lift achieved on each side, to ensure this has not been affected by botulinum toxin injection. This will be measured from the pupillary light reflex to the upper border of the eyebrow (in mm). These measurements will be done by a masked observer. |
Countries
Canada
Outcome results
None listed