Evaluation of a Diagnostic to Identify Glucose-6-phosphate Dehydrogenase (G6PD) Deficiency in Brazil

Evaluation of a Diagnostic to Identify G6PD Deficiency in Brazil

Status

Completed

Phases

Study type

Interventional

Source

ClinicalTrials.gov

Registry ID

NCT04033640

Enrollment

1754

Registered

2019-07-26

Start date

2019-06-27

Completion date

2019-12-31

Last updated

2021-11-11

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

G6PD Deficiency

Keywords

G6PD deficiency

Brief summary

Th objectives of this study are: * To determine the performance of G6PD tests in detecting G6PD activity and hemoglobin (Hb) compared to a reference assay * To assess the comprehension of the G6PD test packaging and labelling among intended users * To assess the usability of G6PD test result outputs among intended users

Detailed description

This is a cross-sectional diagnostic accuracy study that includes both participants and health worker participants. The participant population will be recruited at clinics and through a household survey using an enriched sample of a population with known G6PD status, established through previous epidemiological studies. Clinic staff will take capillary blood samples and conduct two point of care (POC) tests: 1) HemoCue® hemoglobin test, and 2) the investigational Standard Diagnostics (SD) Biosensor STANDARD POC test for glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) deficiency. Venous blood will be collected and transferred to a laboratory where reference assays will be performed on venous samples using the Pointe Scientific G6PD Analyzer and hemoglobin tests. The health worker participants will include trained intended users of the G6PD tests. Trained health workers will be surveyed to assess product usability through a questionnaire to assess label and packing comprehension as well as results interpretation.

Interventions

DIAGNOSTIC_TESTSD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test

The SD Biosensor G6PD Analyzer is designed to measure the quantitative determination of total hemoglobin concentration and G6PD enzymatic activity in fresh human whole blood specimens based on reflectometry assays in a point-of-care (POC) setting. The test is intended to aid in the identification of people with G6PD deficiency. The test is currently not licensed for use in Brazil and is considered an investigational product.

DIAGNOSTIC_TESTPointe Scientific Test Kit

The Pointe Scientific test kit will serve as the reference assay to assess G6PD activity. Its intended use is for the quantitative, kinetic determination of G6PD in blood at 340 nm.

DIAGNOSTIC_TESTHemoCue System

The HemoCue hemoglobin (Hb) 201+ system is designed for quantitative point-of-care whole blood hemoglobin determination in primary care using a specially designed analyzer, the HemoCue Hb 201+ Analyzer, and specially designed microcuvettes, the HemoCue Hb 201+Microcuvettes.

DIAGNOSTIC_TESTComplete blood count (CBC)

In Manaus, hemoglobin concentration was determined by CBC using an automated hematology analyzer (Sysmex KX-21N).

Study design

Allocation

NON_RANDOMIZED

Intervention model

PARALLEL

Primary purpose

OTHER

Masking

NONE

Eligibility

Sex/Gender

ALL

Age

2 Years to No maximum

Healthy volunteers

Yes

Inclusion criteria

1. Participants with unknown G6PD status Inclusion criteria: * Febrile patients seeking care at the Manaus or Porto Velho clinics * 2 years age or older * Willing to provide informed consent

Exclusion criteria

* Younger than 2 years of age * Participants who received a blood transfusion in the last 3 months, self report * Unwilling to provide informed consent 2. Participants with known G6PD status Inclusion criteria: * Included in previous G6PD surveys and provided consent to be contacted again * 2 years of age or older * Willing to provide informed consent or assent

Design outcomes

Primary

Measure	Time frame	Description
Sensitivity of SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test for Identifying G6PD Deficient Individuals	All samples were collected on study day 1	For the purposes of this study, an individual was considered G6PD deficient if they tested positive in the Pointe Scientific assay. A true positive was defined as a participant with ≤ 30% of normal G6PD activity in circulating venous blood determined by the Pointe Scientific test. Diagnostic sensitivity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test is defined as the percentage of participants who tested positive for G6PD deficiency on the reference test who were identified by the test assay as positive, calculated as: Number of participants who were both test and true positive / (Number of participants who were test and true positive + Number of participants who were test negative but true positive \[ie false negative\]) \* 100%. Sensitivity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test was calculated from both venous and capillary blood samples.
Sensitivity of SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test for Identifying Women With Intermediate G6PD Activity	All samples were collected on study day 1	To investigate the performance of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test to distinguish females with intermediate G6PD activity from females with normal activity, assay sensitivity was determined at a G6PD activity threshold of 70%. A true positive for intermediate G6PD activity in females was defined as G6PD activity between 30 and 70% of normal in circulating venous blood as determined by the Pointe Scientific test. Sensitivity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test is the percentage of women who tested positive for intermediate G6PD activity on the reference test who were identified by the test assay as positive, calculated as: Number of women who were both test and true positive / (Number of women who were test and true positive + Number of women who were test negative but true positive \[ie false negative\]) \* 100%. Sensitivity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test for identifying females with intermediate G6PD activity was calculated from both venous and capillary blood samples.
Specificity of SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test for Identifying G6PD Deficient Individuals	All samples were collected on study day 1	For the purposes of this study, an individual was considered G6PD deficient if they tested positive by the Pointe Scientific assay. A true negative was defined as \> 30% of normal G6PD activity in circulating venous blood as determined by the Pointe Scientific test. Specificity is the percentage of participants who tested negative for G6PD deficiency on the reference test who were identified as negative using the test assay, calculated as: Number of participants who were both test and true negative / (Number of participants who were test and true negative + Number of participants who were test positive but true negative \[ie false positive\]) \* 100%. Specificity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test was calculated from both venous and capillary blood samples.
Specificity of SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test for Identifying Women With Intermediate G6PD Activity	All samples were collected on study day 1	To investigate the performance of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test to distinguish females with intermediate G6PD activity from females with normal activity, the specificity was determined at a G6PD activity threshold of 70%. A true negative for intermediate G6PD activity in females was defined as G6PD activity \> 70% of normal in circulating venous blood as determined by the Pointe Scientific test. Specificity is the percentage of participants who tested negative for G6PD deficiency on the reference test who were identified as negative using the test assay, calculated as: Number of participants who were both test and true negative / (Number of participants who were test and true negative + Number of participants who were test positive but true negative \[ie false positive\]) \* 100%. Specificity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test was calculated from both venous and capillary blood samples.

Secondary

Measure	Time frame	Description
Number of Participants Who Met Acceptance Criteria for Label Comprehension	Day 1	After completing training, health worker participants were asked to complete a questionnaire to assess their comprehension of the test label. The questionnaire consisted of 13 multiple-choice questions with mutually exclusive options and a single correct answer focused on aspects of the product label including key warnings, limitations, and restrictions as well as the proper test procedure. Acceptance (success) criterion for label comprehension was defined as at least 85% correct responses (11 out of 13 possible points).
Accuracy Between the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test Assay and the Pointe Scientific Test Kit	All samples were collected on study day 1	Accuracy between the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test assay and the Pointe Scientific G6PD reference assay was calculated as the percent agreement between both G6PD tests, ie, the percentage of participants with the same diagnosis according to both tests (either deficient, intermediate, or normal G6PD levels). Accuracy of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test was calculated from both venous and capillary blood samples.
Number of Participants Who Met Acceptance Criteria for Accurate Results Interpretation	Day 1	After completing training, health worker participants were asked to complete a questionnaire to assess their ability to interpret the test result outputs. The questionnaire consisted of seven short-answer questions (5 valid results, 2 invalid results) focused on the participant's ability to read the results screen, record the simulated G6PD and hemoglobin quantitative results, and classify the results as normal, intermediate, deficient, or invalid. For each valid result, three points were possible: (one for G6PD result transcription, one for hemoglobin result transcription, and one for result interpretation) and for each invalid result, one point was possible, resulting in a total of 17 possible points. Acceptance (success) criterion for results interpretation was defined as at least 85% correct responses (15 out of 17 possible points).
Accuracy Between the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test Measure of Hemoglobin and the Reference HemoCue Hemoglobin Test	All samples were collected on study day 1	Accuracy between the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test measure of hemoglobin and the HemoCue hemoglobin reference assay was calculated as the percentage agreement between both tests, ie, the percentage of participants with the same diagnosis according to both tests (either non/mild anemia, moderate anemia or severe anemia).
Accuracy Between the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test Measure of Hemoglobin and the Hemoglobin Measured in a Complete Blood Count	All samples were collected on study day 1	Accuracy between the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test measure of hemoglobin and the hemoglobin result from the complete blood count (CBC) reference assay (using an automated hematology analyzer) was calculated as the percentage agreement between both tests, ie, the percentage of participants with the same diagnosis according to both tests (either non/mild anemia, moderate anemia or severe anemia). Complete blood counts were only conducted for participants enrolled at the site in Manaus.
Median G6PD Values Measured by the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test for Venous and Capillary Blood Samples	All samples were collected on study day 1	—

Countries

Brazil

Participant flow

Recruitment details

This diagnostic accuracy study was conducted at 2 centers situated in the Brazilian Amazon and included both participants and health workers. Participants were recruited at clinics and through an enriched sample in Manaus and Porto Velho, Brazil. Health worker participants included both health care providers, such as community health workers/field agents, and laboratory technicians who perform malaria rapid diagnostic tests and other malaria testing near the point of care (POC).

Participants by arm

Arm	Count
G6PD Diagnostic Testing Participants provided whole blood samples as well as finger-stick capillary blood samples. At the clinic site, study staff performed SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test and the POC HemoCue hemoglobin test on finger stick blood samples. At the reference laboratories, G6PD activity was measured from whole blood samples using the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test and the Pointe Scientific G6PD reference assay and hemoglobin was measured using the HemoCue hemoglobin test and by CBC.	1,736
Health Workers Participants were trained on use of the STANDARD G6PD test by members of the study team with extensive experience with G6PD diagnostics and the STANDARD G6PD test. Health worker participants were surveyed to assess label and packing comprehension as well as results interpretation.	18
Total	1,754

Baseline characteristics

Characteristic	Total	G6PD Diagnostic Testing	Health Workers
Age, Continuous	37.7 years STANDARD_DEVIATION 13.9	37.7 years STANDARD_DEVIATION 13.9	—
Age, Customized 12-15 years	22 Participants	22 Participants	—
Age, Customized 16-64 years	1632 Participants	1632 Participants	—
Age, Customized 2-11 years	24 Participants	24 Participants	—
Age, Customized 65+ years	58 Participants	58 Participants	—
Race and Ethnicity Not Collected	0 Participants	—	—
Region of Enrollment Brazil	1754 participants	1736 participants	18 participants
Sex: Female, Male Female	948 Participants	948 Participants	—
Sex: Female, Male Male	788 Participants	788 Participants	—

Adverse events

Event type	EG000 affected / at risk	EG001 affected / at risk
deaths Total, all-cause mortality	0 / 1,736	0 / 0
other Total, other adverse events	0 / 1,736	0 / 0
serious Total, serious adverse events	0 / 1,736	0 / 0

Outcome results

Primary

Sensitivity of SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD Test for Identifying G6PD Deficient Individuals

For the purposes of this study, an individual was considered G6PD deficient if they tested positive in the Pointe Scientific assay. A true positive was defined as a participant with ≤ 30% of normal G6PD activity in circulating venous blood determined by the Pointe Scientific test. Diagnostic sensitivity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test is defined as the percentage of participants who tested positive for G6PD deficiency on the reference test who were identified by the test assay as positive, calculated as: Number of participants who were both test and true positive / (Number of participants who were test and true positive + Number of participants who were test negative but true positive \[ie false negative\]) \* 100%. Sensitivity of the SD Biosensor STANDARD G6PD test was calculated from both venous and capillary blood samples.