Skip to content

Correlation of Several Formulas to Evaluate Insulin Sensitivity With the Predicted M Index

Correlation of Several Formulas to Evaluate Insulin Sensitivity With the Predicted M Index (PREDIM) in Healthy Individuals

Status
Completed
Phases
Unknown
Study type
Observational
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT04010370
Enrollment
25
Registered
2019-07-08
Start date
2019-02-01
Completion date
2020-02-28
Last updated
2020-12-03

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Healthy Lifestyle

Keywords

Insulin sensitivity, PREDIM, Correlation, Healthy individuals

Brief summary

Recently, an index based on the oral insulin sensitivity index with glucose (OGIS) has been proposed in combination with anthropometric variables, called PREDIcted M (PREDIM), however, there is no evidence of the correlation of this with respect to the various indices (McAuley, Belfiore, Cederholm, Avignon, Matsuda, Gutt, Stumvoll, HOMA-IR (Homeostatic Model Assessment for Insulin Resistance), ISI (Insulin Sensitivity Index), Raynaud, QUICKI (The quantitative insulin sensitivity check index), FIRI (Fasting Insulin Resistance Index), Bennett, TyG (triglycerides and glucose index)) in healthy patients.

Detailed description

Analytical cross-sectional study with 25 healthy patients of both genders (male and female) from 30 to 60 years old, residents of the metropolitan area of Guadalajara. They will be operated on for a 3-hour oral glucose tolerance test. The insulin sensitivity will be calculated with the PREDIM, Matsuda, McAuley, Belfiore, Cederholm, Avignon, Gutt, Stumvoll, HOMA-IR, ISI, Raynaud, QUICKI, FIRI, Bennett and TyG indexes. This protocol is already approved by the local ethics committee and written informed consent it's going to be obtained from all volunteers. The statistical analysis will be presented with measures of central tendency and dispersion, mean and standard deviation. The nominal variables in numbers and percentages. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test will be performed to determine if the variables follow a normal distribution. To correlate the formulas used to evaluate the insulin sensitivity with the PREDIcted M (PREDIM) technique, the Pearson or Spearman correlation will be used according to the distribution.

Interventions

None listed

Sponsors

University of Guadalajara
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Observational model
OTHER
Time perspective
CROSS_SECTIONAL

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
30 Years to 60 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

* Both genres * Age 30 to 60 years * BMI \<25 kg / m2, * Patients who are not sedentary or who participate in heavy physical activities * Stable weight in the last 3 months

Exclusion criteria

* Blood pressure \>120/80 mmHg * Glucose \>100 mg/dL * Postprandial glucose \>140 mg/dL * Cholesterol \>200 mg/dL * Triglycerides \>150 mg/dL * Smoking * Women with polycystic ovarian syndrome * History of metabolic, cardiovascular, thyroid, renal, pancreatic and/or arterial hypertension * Use of medications that modify insulin sensitivity (corticosteroids) * Previous surgery or infection * Symptoms of vomiting and/or excessive nausea

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Insulin Sensitivity With PREDIM (PREDIcted M) IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the PREDIM index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with PREDIM index: A + B × log\_e (OGIS) + C × log\_e (IMC) + D × log\_e (2hGlu) + log\_e (INSf). A higher result is better. In the formula A=2.8846219; B=0.5208520; OGIS=1/2 x (B + sqrt (Bˆ2 + 4 x p5 x p6 (G120 - Gcl) x Cl OGTT)); C=-0.8223363; D=-0.4191242; E=-0.2427896; INSf=fasting insulin.
Insulin Sensitivity With McAuley IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the McAuley index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with McAuley index: e\[2.63-0.28 In(Insulin minute 0) - 0.31 In(Triglycerides minute 0)\]. A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With Belfiore IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Belfiore index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Belfiore index: 2/((glucose minute 0/glucose minute 120) (Insulin minute 0/Insulin minute 120))+1. A higher result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With Bennett IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Bennett index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Bennett index: 1 / (log Fasting insulin) x (log Fasting glucose). A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With Cederholm IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Cederholm index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Cederholm index: (75000+(Glucose minute 0- Glucose minute 120) x 19 x weight) / ((AUC Glucose/18) x log (AUC insulin/120)). A lower result is better. In the formula AUC=area under the curve.
Insulin Sensitivity With Avignon IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Avignon index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Avignon index: ((0.137 x Sib) + Si2h)/2. A higher result is better. In the formula Sib=10ˆ8 / ((insulin minute 0) x (glucose minute 0) x (VD=150 ml/kg of Body weight)); Si2h=10ˆ8 / ((insulin minute 120) x (glucose minute 120) x (VD=150 ml/kg of Body weight)).
Insulin Sensitivity With Matsuda IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Matsuda index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Matsuda index: \[10,000 / √glucose minute 0 x insulin minute 0) (mean glucose (OGTT) x mean insulin OGTT)\]. A higher result is better. In the formula OGTT: oral glucose tolerance test.
Insulin Sensitivity With Gutt IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Gutt index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Gutt index: ((75000 + (Glucose minute 0 - Glucose minute 120) x 0.10 x m) / (120 x Glucose mean x log Insulin mean). A higher result is better. A lower result is better. In the formula m=body weight
Insulin Sensitivity With Stumvoll IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Stumvoll index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Stumvoll index: 0.156 - 0.0000459 × Insulin minute 120 - 0.000321 × Insulin minute 0 - 0.00541 × Glucose minute 120. A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With FIRI (Fasting Insulin Resistance Index) IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the FIRI index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with FIRI index: (Fasting Insulin) x (Fasting Glucose) / 25. A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With HOMA-IR (Homeostatic Model Assessment for Insulin Resistance) IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the HOMA-IR index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with HOMA-IR index: (Glucose minute 0) (Insulin minute 0) / 22.5. A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With ISI (Insulin Sensitivity Index) IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the ISI index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with ISI index: 10000 / (Insulin minute 0) (Glucose minute 0). A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With Raynaud IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Raynaud index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Raynaud index: 40 / (Fasting insulin). a lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With QUICKI (The Quantitative Insulin Sensitivity Check Index) IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the QUICKI index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with QUICKI index: 1 / (log fasting insulin) + (log fasting glucose). A lower result is better.
Insulin Sensitivity With TyG (Triglycerides and Glucose Index) IndexBaselineWith the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the TyG index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with TyG index: \[ln (Triglycerides) x (Fasting Glucose) / 2\]. A lower result is better.

Countries

Mexico

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Healthy Individuals
3-hour oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) with 75 grams of glucose load in a single time
25
Total25

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicHealthy Individuals
Age, Continuous32.44 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 2.79
Body mass index (BMI)22.42 kg/m^2
STANDARD_DEVIATION 1.75
Body weight62.2 kg
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.1
Creatinine78.7 mmol/L
STANDARD_DEVIATION 23.9
Diastolic blood pressure71.36 mmHg
STANDARD_DEVIATION 6.53
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Hispanic or Latino
25 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Not Hispanic or Latino
0 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants
Fasting glucose4.58 mmol/L
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.41
Region of Enrollment
Mexico
25 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
17 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
8 Participants
Systolic blood pressure105.6 mmHg
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.72
Total cholesterol4.5 mmol/L
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.5
Triglycerides0.82 mmol/L
STANDARD_DEVIATION 0.29
Uric acid273.01 mmol/L
STANDARD_DEVIATION 69.59
Waist circumference78.88 cm
STANDARD_DEVIATION 7.9

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 25
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 25
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 25

Outcome results

Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Avignon Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Avignon index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Avignon index: ((0.137 x Sib) + Si2h)/2. A higher result is better. In the formula Sib=10ˆ8 / ((insulin minute 0) x (glucose minute 0) x (VD=150 ml/kg of Body weight)); Si2h=10ˆ8 / ((insulin minute 120) x (glucose minute 120) x (VD=150 ml/kg of Body weight)).

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Avignon Index271.11 indexStandard Deviation 115.37
Comparison: Correlation of Avignon index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.246Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Belfiore Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Belfiore index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Belfiore index: 2/((glucose minute 0/glucose minute 120) (Insulin minute 0/Insulin minute 120))+1. A higher result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Belfiore Index1.52 indexStandard Deviation 0.194
Comparison: Correlation of Belfiore index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.319Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Bennett Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Bennett index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Bennett index: 1 / (log Fasting insulin) x (log Fasting glucose). A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Bennett Index0.64 indexStandard Deviation 0.15
Comparison: Correlation of Bennett index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.726Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Cederholm Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Cederholm index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Cederholm index: (75000+(Glucose minute 0- Glucose minute 120) x 19 x weight) / ((AUC Glucose/18) x log (AUC insulin/120)). A lower result is better. In the formula AUC=area under the curve.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Cederholm Index153.25 indexStandard Deviation 38.93
Comparison: Correlation of Cederholm index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.27Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With FIRI (Fasting Insulin Resistance Index) Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the FIRI index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with FIRI index: (Fasting Insulin) x (Fasting Glucose) / 25. A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With FIRI (Fasting Insulin Resistance Index) Index26.13 indexStandard Deviation 12.25
Comparison: Correlation of FIRI index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.531Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Gutt Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Gutt index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Gutt index: ((75000 + (Glucose minute 0 - Glucose minute 120) x 0.10 x m) / (120 x Glucose mean x log Insulin mean). A higher result is better. A lower result is better. In the formula m=body weight

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Gutt Index79.99 indexStandard Deviation 16.5
Comparison: Correlation of Gutt index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.69Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With HOMA-IR (Homeostatic Model Assessment for Insulin Resistance) Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the HOMA-IR index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with HOMA-IR index: (Glucose minute 0) (Insulin minute 0) / 22.5. A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With HOMA-IR (Homeostatic Model Assessment for Insulin Resistance) Index1.61 indexStandard Deviation 0.76
Comparison: Correlation of HOMA-IR index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.69Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With ISI (Insulin Sensitivity Index) Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the ISI index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with ISI index: 10000 / (Insulin minute 0) (Glucose minute 0). A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With ISI (Insulin Sensitivity Index) Index18.61 indexStandard Deviation 8.3
Comparison: Correlation of ISI index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.69Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Matsuda Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Matsuda index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Matsuda index: \[10,000 / √glucose minute 0 x insulin minute 0) (mean glucose (OGTT) x mean insulin OGTT)\]. A higher result is better. In the formula OGTT: oral glucose tolerance test.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Matsuda Index8.15 indexStandard Deviation 3.2
Comparison: Correlation of Matsuda index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.259Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With McAuley Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the McAuley index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with McAuley index: e\[2.63-0.28 In(Insulin minute 0) - 0.31 In(Triglycerides minute 0)\]. A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With McAuley Index46.69 indexStandard Deviation 62.28
Comparison: Correlation of McAuley index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: <0.001Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With PREDIM (PREDIcted M) Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the PREDIM index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with PREDIM index: A + B × log\_e (OGIS) + C × log\_e (IMC) + D × log\_e (2hGlu) + log\_e (INSf). A higher result is better. In the formula A=2.8846219; B=0.5208520; OGIS=1/2 x (B + sqrt (Bˆ2 + 4 x p5 x p6 (G120 - Gcl) x Cl OGTT)); C=-0.8223363; D=-0.4191242; E=-0.2427896; INSf=fasting insulin.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With PREDIM (PREDIcted M) Index72.48 indexStandard Deviation 14.47
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With QUICKI (The Quantitative Insulin Sensitivity Check Index) Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the QUICKI index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with QUICKI index: 1 / (log fasting insulin) + (log fasting glucose). A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With QUICKI (The Quantitative Insulin Sensitivity Check Index) Index0.36 indexStandard Deviation 0.03
Comparison: Correlation of QUICKI index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.69Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Raynaud Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Raynaud index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Raynaud index: 40 / (Fasting insulin). a lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Raynaud Index6.05 indexStandard Deviation 2.59
Comparison: Correlation of Raynaud index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.541Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With Stumvoll Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the Stumvoll index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with Stumvoll index: 0.156 - 0.0000459 × Insulin minute 120 - 0.000321 × Insulin minute 0 - 0.00541 × Glucose minute 120. A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With Stumvoll Index0.1339 indexStandard Deviation 0.0242
Comparison: Correlation of Stumvoll index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.022Spearman correlation
Primary

Insulin Sensitivity With TyG (Triglycerides and Glucose Index) Index

With the results of the oral glucose tolerance test at baseline, insulin sensitivity was calculated with the TyG index. Insulin sensitivity was calculated with TyG index: \[ln (Triglycerides) x (Fasting Glucose) / 2\]. A lower result is better.

Time frame: Baseline

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Healthy IndividualsInsulin Sensitivity With TyG (Triglycerides and Glucose Index) Index1.88 indexStandard Deviation 0.08
Comparison: Correlation of TyG index with PREDIM index at baseline.p-value: 0.787Spearman correlation

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026