Program Sustainability, Tobacco Use
Conditions
Brief summary
The purpose of this study is to empirically develop, test, and disseminate sustainability training to improve the institutionalization of evidence-based state tobacco control (TC) programs, and thus, tobacco-related health outcomes.
Detailed description
This study defines program sustainability as the ability to maintain programming and its benefits over time. The project builds upon the empirically-developed Program Sustainability Action Planning Model and Training Curricula. The training will incorporate experiential learning methods and includes: action planning workshops, development of action plans with measurable objectives to foster institutional changes, and technical assistance. The goal is to demonstrate change in sustainability outcomes in states who receive the Program Sustainability Action Planning Training compared to states that do not. After conclusion of the study, the sustainability training curriculum will be disseminated to all participating state TC programs. Additionally, the curriculum will be adapted for the use by any public health program in need of building sustainability capacity.
Interventions
BEHAVIORALProgram Sustainability Action Planning Model and Training Curricula
The Program Sustainability Action Planning Model and Training Curricula's conceptual model is driven by the theory of change and incorporates aspects of Kolb's experiential learning theory to produce a six step process: defining the program, assessing the program, developing an action plan, executing the action plan, evaluating sustainability, and reassessing and modifying. The study team will deliver in-person, hand-on workshops incorporating each of these aspects of the conceptual model. Following the workshop, intervention states will partake in technical assistance activities with the study team to track progress and troubleshooting challenges.
Sponsors
National Cancer Institute (NCI)
Washington University School of Medicine
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
PREVENTION
Masking
NONE
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
Yes
Inclusion criteria
* All participants will be non-institutionalized adults ages 18 and older.
Exclusion criteria
* Participants must be involved in their state's tobacco control program and must be selected by their state's Program Manager to participate.
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months,12 months, 24 months | The Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) allows stakeholders to rate their programs on the extent to which they have processes and structures in place that will increase the likelihood of sustainability. The minimum score is 1 and the maximum score is 7. A higher score indicates greater program capacity for sustainability. Assessment results can be used to identify next steps in building program capacity for sustainability in order to position efforts for long term success. |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months, 12 months, 24 months | -This measure is defined as whether a state's tobacco control program is established or continued through state statute or regulation and/or if the program is stated in organizational doctrine as a permanent component of the auspice organization. This is a direct measure of formal institutionalization of tobacco control programs and will be measured as a simple binary quantity, zero (0) for not present in law, regulation, or rule and one (1) for present in law, regulation, or rule. |
| State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months, 12 months, 24 months | Defined as whether a state's tobacco control program is a regular (annual, quarterly, or otherwise) item of the budget of its auspice organization. It directly indicated formal institutionalization and will take one of two possible values, zero (0) for not included in budget and one (1) for included in budget. |
| Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months, 12 months, 24 months | Defined as the percentage of the state health department budget garnered by its tobacco control program. The measure will be continuous and theoretically range from 0% (no funding) to 100% (entire health department budget). This quantity measures institutionalization of a program both individually and relative to other state health programs. |
| Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months, 12 months, 24 months | Defined as the amount of program funding as a percentage of the amount recommended by the CDC. This quantity measures institutionalization of a program relative to an objective level of funding computed uniformly from state characteristics by the CDC. The measure ranges from 0% (no funding) to over 100% (above CDC-recommended level). |
Countries
United States
Participant flow
Recruitment details
23 state tobacco-control programs were randomized to either the intervention group or the control group. Stakeholders from those state tobacco-control programs were consented and enrolled and the participant flow indicates the stakeholders that started and completed the trial.
Participants by arm
| Arm | Count |
|---|---|
| Program Sustainability Training * Selected publicly funded tobacco control programs receive the intervention in the form of custom training curricula designed to identify and enable sustainable tobacco control programming at a state-organizational level. Sustainability is assessed at t=12 months and 1=24 months to capture potential impact of the training and curricula.
* The intervention group will receive a follow-up survey inviting them to evaluate the training and their progress on executing their sustainability plan. The intervention group will also receive a follow-up survey inviting them to evaluate the technical assistance they have received from the research team. Responses on neither follow-up survey impact participants standing in the study | 127 |
| Control Condition * In this condition, publicly funded tobacco control programs do not receive the designated program sustainability training and proceed with standard operations. Sustainability is assessed at t=12 months and t=24 months to compare against tobacco control programs receiving sustainability training
* The control group will receive a follow-up survey inviting them to evaluate their progress on creating their sustainability plan. Responses on the follow-up survey do not impact participants' standing in the study | 128 |
| Total | 255 |
Withdrawals & dropouts
| Period | Reason | FG000 | FG001 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Study | Staff turnover/left the program | 3 | 39 |
Baseline characteristics
| Characteristic | Program Sustainability Training | Control Condition | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age, Customized 20-29 years | 3 Participants | 6 Participants | 9 Participants |
| Age, Customized 30-39 years | 18 Participants | 19 Participants | 37 Participants |
| Age, Customized 40-49 years | 20 Participants | 28 Participants | 48 Participants |
| Age, Customized 50-59 years | 17 Participants | 18 Participants | 35 Participants |
| Age, Customized 60-69 years | 8 Participants | 11 Participants | 19 Participants |
| Age, Customized 70-79 years | 2 Participants | 1 Participants | 3 Participants |
| Age, Customized Unknown or not reported age | 59 Participants | 45 Participants | 104 Participants |
| Ethnicity (NIH/OMB) Hispanic or Latino | 1 Participants | 2 Participants | 3 Participants |
| Ethnicity (NIH/OMB) Not Hispanic or Latino | 72 Participants | 82 Participants | 154 Participants |
| Ethnicity (NIH/OMB) Unknown or Not Reported | 54 Participants | 44 Participants | 98 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) American Indian or Alaska Native | 0 Participants | 2 Participants | 2 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Asian | 2 Participants | 0 Participants | 2 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Black or African American | 7 Participants | 5 Participants | 12 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) More than one race | 4 Participants | 2 Participants | 6 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander | 2 Participants | 0 Participants | 2 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Unknown or Not Reported | 55 Participants | 45 Participants | 100 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) White | 57 Participants | 74 Participants | 131 Participants |
| Region of Enrollment United States | 127 participants | 128 participants | 255 participants |
| Sex/Gender, Customized Female | 61 Participants | 67 Participants | 128 Participants |
| Sex/Gender, Customized Male | 14 Participants | 19 Participants | 33 Participants |
| Sex/Gender, Customized Unknown or not reported | 52 Participants | 42 Participants | 94 Participants |
Adverse events
| Event type | EG000 affected / at risk | EG001 affected / at risk |
|---|---|---|
| deaths Total, all-cause mortality | 0 / 127 | 0 / 128 |
| other Total, other adverse events | 0 / 127 | 0 / 128 |
| serious Total, serious adverse events | 0 / 127 | 0 / 128 |
Outcome results
Primary
Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores
The Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) allows stakeholders to rate their programs on the extent to which they have processes and structures in place that will increase the likelihood of sustainability. The minimum score is 1 and the maximum score is 7. A higher score indicates greater program capacity for sustainability. Assessment results can be used to identify next steps in building program capacity for sustainability in order to position efforts for long term success.
Time frame: 0 months,12 months, 24 months
Population: The results are the state's tobacco control program PSAT sustainability scores at each timepoint.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (MEDIAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.9 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 5.1 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.8 |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 1.3 |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 3.8 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.3 |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.8 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 1 |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.1 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.8 |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 5.1 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.8 |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 5.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.3 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 6.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.8 |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 5.3 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.2 |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 5.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 3.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 3.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.3 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.3 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.2 |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 3.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 3.8 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 1.1 |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 3.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.9 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.9 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 5.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.2 |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 3.6 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.3 |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.3 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 5.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.9 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 3.9 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.6 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.3 |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 5.7 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.3 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.9 |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.1 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.0 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.8 |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.1 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.8 |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 4.4 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 4.6 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.3 |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 4.2 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.4 |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 24 months | 3.5 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.7 |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 0 months | 2.9 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.6 |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Program Sustainability Assessment Tool (PSAT) Sustainability Scores | 12 months | 2.8 score on a scale | Standard Deviation 0.5 |
Secondary
Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent
Defined as the amount of program funding as a percentage of the amount recommended by the CDC. This quantity measures institutionalization of a program relative to an objective level of funding computed uniformly from state characteristics by the CDC. The measure ranges from 0% (no funding) to over 100% (above CDC-recommended level).
Time frame: 0 months, 12 months, 24 months
Population: The data for this outcome measure was gathered at a state level and not at the stakeholder level.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|---|
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 31.93 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 28.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 28.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 98.10 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 102.22 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 102.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 10.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 2.0 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 3.43 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 6.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 8.54 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 8.40 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 21.10 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 20.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 20.92 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 58.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 45.0 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 43.40 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 43.00 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 32.40 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 42.99 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 36.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 37.60 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 36.22 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 8.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 8.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 9.0 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 14.0 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 13.14 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 13.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 30.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 51.27 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 36.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 53.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 58.89 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 45.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 43.10 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 41.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 42.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 28.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 23.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 23.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 10.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 10.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 3.53 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 10.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 10.21 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 11.00 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 8.30 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 9.00 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 8.27 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 11.02 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 11.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 10.60 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 4.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 4.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 4.50 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 19.30 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 19.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 16.00 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 13.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 7.57 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 7.60 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 13.20 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 12.90 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 12.11 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 24 months | 7.40 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 0 months | 7.10 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of CDC-recommended Tobacco Control Funding Level Actually Spent | 12 months | 6.70 % of CDC-recommended funding spent |
Secondary
Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program
Defined as the percentage of the state health department budget garnered by its tobacco control program. The measure will be continuous and theoretically range from 0% (no funding) to 100% (entire health department budget). This quantity measures institutionalization of a program both individually and relative to other state health programs.
Time frame: 0 months, 12 months, 24 months
Population: The data for this outcome measure was gathered at a state level and not at the stakeholder level.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|---|
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 31.80 percentage of health department budget |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 13.10 percentage of health department budget |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 12.10 percentage of health department budget |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 19.80 percentage of health department budget |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 12.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 22.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 5.10 percentage of health department budget |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 0.90 percentage of health department budget |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 0.80 percentage of health department budget |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 3.40 percentage of health department budget |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 1.70 percentage of health department budget |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 4.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 7.90 percentage of health department budget |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 8.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 2.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 20.40 percentage of health department budget |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 3.90 percentage of health department budget |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 13.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 18.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 13.60 percentage of health department budget |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 6.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 17.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 16.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 18.10 percentage of health department budget |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 4.80 percentage of health department budget |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 3.70 percentage of health department budget |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 4.90 percentage of health department budget |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 7.40 percentage of health department budget |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 9.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 7.10 percentage of health department budget |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 10.80 percentage of health department budget |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 5.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 13.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 22.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 16.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 19.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 11.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 10.90 percentage of health department budget |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 11.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 12.40 percentage of health department budget |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 10.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 10.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 6.60 percentage of health department budget |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 6.80 percentage of health department budget |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 2.40 percentage of health department budget |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 4.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 4.70 percentage of health department budget |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 4.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 3.70 percentage of health department budget |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 4.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 3.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 7.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 6.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 6.30 percentage of health department budget |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 2.60 percentage of health department budget |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 2.70 percentage of health department budget |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 2.60 percentage of health department budget |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 5.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 5.60 percentage of health department budget |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 4.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 5.20 percentage of health department budget |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 3.10 percentage of health department budget |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 3.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 7.70 percentage of health department budget |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 7.50 percentage of health department budget |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 7.60 percentage of health department budget |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 24 months | 4.00 percentage of health department budget |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 0 months | 3.90 percentage of health department budget |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Change in Percentage of Organizational Budget Allotted to Tobacco Control Program | 12 months | 3.50 percentage of health department budget |
Secondary
Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule
-This measure is defined as whether a state's tobacco control program is established or continued through state statute or regulation and/or if the program is stated in organizational doctrine as a permanent component of the auspice organization. This is a direct measure of formal institutionalization of tobacco control programs and will be measured as a simple binary quantity, zero (0) for not present in law, regulation, or rule and one (1) for present in law, regulation, or rule.
Time frame: 0 months, 12 months, 24 months
Population: The data for this outcome measure was gathered at a state level and not at the stakeholder level.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (COUNT_OF_UNITS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 2 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 3 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 5 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 7 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 10 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 12 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 14 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 16 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 17 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 20 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 22 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 23 - Control Condition | Number of State Tobacco Control Programs Present in Law, Regulation, or Rule | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
Secondary
State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget
Defined as whether a state's tobacco control program is a regular (annual, quarterly, or otherwise) item of the budget of its auspice organization. It directly indicated formal institutionalization and will take one of two possible values, zero (0) for not included in budget and one (1) for included in budget.
Time frame: 0 months, 12 months, 24 months
Population: The data for this outcome measure was gathered at a state level and not at the stakeholder level. The 12 month data time point for state 23 is missing.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (COUNT_OF_UNITS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 1 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 2 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 2 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 2 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 3 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 3 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 3 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 4 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 5 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 5 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 5 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 6 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 7 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 7 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 7 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 8 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 9 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 10 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 10 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 10 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 11 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 12 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 12 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 12 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 13 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 14 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 14 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 14 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 15 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 16 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 16 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 16 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 17 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 17 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 17 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 18 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 19 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 20 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 20 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 20 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 21 - Program Sustainability Training | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 22 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 22 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 22 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 12 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 23 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 0 months | 0 State Tobacco Control Programs |
| State 23 - Control Condition | State Tobacco Control Program is Included as Part of Regular Budget | 24 months | 1 State Tobacco Control Programs |