Skip to content

Adherence Interventions for HIV Youth Via Text & Cell Phone - Sequential Multiple Assignment Randomized Trial (SMART)

Adaptive Antiretroviral Therapy Adherence Interventions for Youth Living With HIV Through Text Messaging and Cell Phone Support Embedded Within the Sequential Multiple Assignment Randomized Trial (SMART) Design

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT03535337
Acronym
SMART
Enrollment
83
Registered
2018-05-24
Start date
2018-09-01
Completion date
2022-05-31
Last updated
2024-12-13

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

HIV Infections

Keywords

Interventions, youth living with HIV, mHealth, ART adherence, adaptive intervention, cell phone, text messaging

Brief summary

The purpose of this study is to test an adaptive adherence intervention, which utilizes two mobile health (mHealth) intervention designs, in an effort to promote adherence to antiretroviral therapy (ART) and achieve and maintain viral load (VL) suppression in youth living with HIV (YLH) while increasing understanding of the context for wide-scale implementation of cell phone support (CPS) and text messaging support (SMS), with and without incentives.

Detailed description

The study will consist of two points of randomization. The first step involves randomization of participants to receive either CPS or SMS using a 1:1 allocation ratio. Both intervention conditions will receive 3 months of intervention (i.e., 12 weeks of CPS or SMS). The second step involves a stratified randomization in blocks with 8 possible intervention trajectories. Within each condition, participants are categorized into two groups - responders with VL\<200 (Rsp) and non-responders with VL ≥200 (NRsp). Responders in the CPS condition will be randomly assigned to receive either 3 months of CPS tapered (CPS-T) intervention followed by standard care (SC) or only SC. Similarly, responders in the SMScondition will be randomly assigned to receive either 3 months of SMS tapered (SMS-T) intervention followed by SC or only SC. Non-responders in both CPS and SMS conditions will be randomly assigned to receive either 3 months of incentivized CPS (CPS-I) followed by 3 months of CPS-T and 3 months of SC or 3 months of incentivized SMS (SMS-I) followed by 3 months of SMS-T and 3 months of SC.

Interventions

BEHAVIORALCPS

Assessment of participant's medication adherence and barrier problem solving via phone conversation

BEHAVIORALSMS

Participants will receive a text message, which will be an electronic reminder regarding medication adherence. Participants will then text back a confirmatory response.

Sponsors

Children's Hospital Los Angeles
CollaboratorOTHER
Hunter College of City University of New York
CollaboratorOTHER
Wayne State University
CollaboratorOTHER
Florida State University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
SEQUENTIAL
Primary purpose
SUPPORTIVE_CARE
Masking
NONE

Intervention model description

Multiple Assignment Randomized Trial

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
15 Years to 24 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* HIV diagnosis * Viral load ≥ 200 copies/mL within 3 months prior to enrollment or self-reported adherence ≤ 80% * ART medication regimen prescribed minimum of 3 months prior to eligibility VL or self-reported adherence * Sole owner of device capable of sending/receiving calls and text messages * Willingness to permit research team to communicate with their HIV care provider team

Exclusion criteria

* Mental, physical, or emotional capacity prevents completion of protocol as written * Inability to understand written/spoken English * Concurrent participant in any adherence behavioral research intervention

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Undetectable Viral Loadbaseline, month 3, month 6, month 9, and month 12Percent of participants that have an undetectable HIV Viral Load.
Medication Adherence Rate - 7 Daybaseline, month 3, month 6, month 9, and month 12Self reported percentage of medication taken in the past 7 days prior to assessment point. Medication adherence rates will be compared between CPS and SMS groups.
Medication Adherence - 30 Daysbaseline, month 3, month 6, month 9, and month 12Self reported percentage of medication taken in the past 30 days prior to assessment point. Medication adherence rates will be compared between CPS and SMS groups.

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Stage 1 Cell Phone Support
CPS: Assessment of participant's medication adherence and barrier problem solving via phone conversation
40
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)
SMS: Participants will receive a text message, which will be an electronic reminder regarding medication adherence. Participants will then text back a confirmatory response.
43
Total83

Withdrawals & dropouts

PeriodReasonFG000FG001FG002FG003FG004FG005FG006FG007FG008FG009
Stage 2 RandomizationLost to Follow-up0021543602

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicStage 1 Cell Phone SupportTotalStage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)
Age, Continuous22.58 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 1.63
22.27 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 1.78
21.9 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 1.8
Education
High School or Equivalent
17 Participants32 Participants15 Participants
Education
Less than High School
7 Participants13 Participants6 Participants
Education
Some College or Above
16 Participants38 Participants22 Participants
Employed24 Participants44 Participants20 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
African American/Black
20 Participants44 Participants24 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Latino
9 Participants19 Participants10 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Multiracial/Other
7 Participants13 Participants6 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
White
4 Participants7 Participants3 Participants
Region
Midwest United Stated
8 Participants12 Participants4 Participants
Region
Northeast United States
3 Participants11 Participants8 Participants
Region
Southeastern United States
20 Participants44 Participants24 Participants
Region
Western United States
9 Participants16 Participants7 Participants
Sex/Gender, Customized
Female
5 Participants11 Participants6 Participants
Sex/Gender, Customized
Male
32 Participants67 Participants35 Participants
Sex/Gender, Customized
Other
3 Participants5 Participants2 Participants
Sexual Identity
Gay
29 Participants63 Participants34 Participants
Sexual Identity
Heterosexual or Other
11 Participants20 Participants9 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
EG002
affected / at risk
EG003
affected / at risk
EG004
affected / at risk
EG005
affected / at risk
EG006
affected / at risk
EG007
affected / at risk
EG008
affected / at risk
EG009
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 400 / 430 / 20 / 40 / 110 / 160 / 140 / 140 / 30 / 5
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 400 / 430 / 20 / 40 / 110 / 160 / 140 / 140 / 30 / 5
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 400 / 430 / 20 / 40 / 110 / 160 / 140 / 140 / 30 / 5

Outcome results

Primary

Medication Adherence - 30 Days

Self reported percentage of medication taken in the past 30 days prior to assessment point. Medication adherence rates will be compared between CPS and SMS groups.

Time frame: baseline, month 3, month 6, month 9, and month 12

Population: Numbers are different due to attrition.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence - 30 DaysBaseline68.55 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 27.18
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month87.56 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 20.35
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month83.94 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 22.73
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month78.34 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 27.92
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month85.48 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 21.14
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month80.60 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 28.73
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence - 30 DaysBaseline74.33 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 23.6
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month84.87 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 22.73
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month82.13 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 20.08
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month83.74 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 21.33
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month93.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 1.4
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month77.50 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 23.3
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month75.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 0
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month53.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 32.5
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month88.50 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 16.3
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month90.50 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 13.4
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month52.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 67.9
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month87.40 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 21.7
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month96.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 9.8
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month94.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 5.5
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month95.10 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 6
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month77.20 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 27
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month67.90 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 35.5
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month88.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 22
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month85.60 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 12.8
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month94.30 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 8.4
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month96.20 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 4.6
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month97.10 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 6.3
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month94.60 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 6
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month75.40 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 29.8
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month73.50 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 28.3
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month91.10 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 8.7
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month83.90 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 24.5
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month95.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 7.1
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month56.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 39.3
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month69.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 28.6
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month70.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 0
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days9 Month58.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 19.6
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days6 Month55.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 35.2
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days3 Month58.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 31.1
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence - 30 Days12 Month17.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 24
p-value: 0.8295% CI: [-1.32, 1.66]Mixed Models Analysis
Primary

Medication Adherence Rate - 7 Day

Self reported percentage of medication taken in the past 7 days prior to assessment point. Medication adherence rates will be compared between CPS and SMS groups.

Time frame: baseline, month 3, month 6, month 9, and month 12

Population: Numbers are different due to attrition.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence Rate - 7 DayBaseline63.68 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 34.91
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month90.69 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 15.57
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month73.33 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 38.12
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month79.17 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 29.18
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month80.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 31.93
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month79.63 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 30.19
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence Rate - 7 DayBaseline74.52 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 29.81
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month76.18 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 34.2
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month84.55 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 20.09
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Medication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month82.76 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 23.89
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month100 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 0
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month100 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 0
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month70.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 0
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month100 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 0
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month40 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 45.8
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month76.70 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 40.4
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month33.30 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 57.7
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month85.70 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 21.5
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month96.30 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 7.4
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month98.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 4.5
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month94.60 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 8.2
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month74.40 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 33.2
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month72.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 35.5
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month88.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 19.3
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month79.10 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 29.5
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month94.60 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 8.8
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month95.40 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 8.8
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month97.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 6.7
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month94.60 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 5.2
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month70.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 36.3
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month76.70 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 28.1
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month92.50 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 7.1
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month79.30 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 32.5
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month95.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 7.1
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month56.70 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 40.4
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month66.70 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 25.2
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month15.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 21.2
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day9 month54.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 28.8
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day6 month70.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 24.5
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day3 month42.00 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 35.6
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IMedication Adherence Rate - 7 Day12 month46.70 percentage of medication adherenceStandard Deviation 47.3
p-value: 0.0395% CI: [0.28, 4.59]Mixed Models Analysis
Primary

Undetectable Viral Load

Percent of participants that have an undetectable HIV Viral Load.

Time frame: baseline, month 3, month 6, month 9, and month 12

Population: Significant attrition at follow-ups for viral load testing. Therefore the overall model would not converge.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (NUMBER)
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportUndetectable Viral Load12 Month80.0 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportUndetectable Viral Load9 Month83.3 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportUndetectable Viral Load6 Month93.8 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportUndetectable Viral Load3 Month89.5 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Cell Phone SupportUndetectable Viral LoadBaseline58.8 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Undetectable Viral Load12 Month100.0 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Undetectable Viral LoadBaseline62.9 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Undetectable Viral Load3 Month87.5 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Undetectable Viral Load6 Month89.5 percentage of participants
Stage 1 Short Message Service (SMS)Undetectable Viral Load9 Month83.3 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IUndetectable Viral Load3 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IUndetectable Viral Load9 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-IUndetectable Viral Load6 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IUndetectable Viral Load3 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SMS-IUndetectable Viral Load9 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TUndetectable Viral Load12 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TUndetectable Viral Load9 Month80.0 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TUndetectable Viral Load3 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support CPS-TUndetectable Viral Load6 Month85.7 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCUndetectable Viral Load3 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCUndetectable Viral Load6 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCUndetectable Viral Load9 Month80.0 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Cell Phone Support SCUndetectable Viral Load12 Month50.0 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TUndetectable Viral Load6 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TUndetectable Viral Load3 Month90.0 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TUndetectable Viral Load9 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-TUndetectable Viral Load12 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCUndetectable Viral Load6 Month85.7 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCUndetectable Viral Load3 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCUndetectable Viral Load12 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SCUndetectable Viral Load9 Month83 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service CPS-IUndetectable Viral Load12 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IUndetectable Viral Load9 Month100 percentage of participants
Stage 2 Short Message Service SMS-IUndetectable Viral Load6 Month100 percentage of participants

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Mar 4, 2026