Skin Care
Conditions
Brief summary
To assess the irritation potential of four prototype daily defense serum formulations after 24 (± 2) hours under semi-occlusive patch application to the skin of healthy volunteers.
Detailed description
This is an evaluator (single) blind, test site randomized and intra-subject comparison patch test study to evaluate the cutaneous irritation potential of four experimental daily defense serum formulations, including a saline solution as a negative control.
Interventions
OTHERExperimental Daily Defense Serum A
Participants will apply 0.02mL/cm2 of product topically via semi-occlusive patches onto dorsum (Scapular region).
OTHERExperimental Daily Defense Serum C
Participants will apply 0.02mL/cm2 of product topically via semi-occlusive patches onto dorsum (Scapular region).
OTHERExperimental Daily Defense Serum G
Participants will apply 0.02mL/cm2 of product topically via semi-occlusive patches onto dorsum (Scapular region).
OTHERExperimental Daily Defense Serum N
Participants will apply 0.02mL/cm2 of product topically via semi-occlusive patches onto dorsum (Scapular region).
OTHERSaline Solution Sodium Chloride
Participants will apply 0.02mL/cm2 of product topically via semi-occlusive patches onto dorsum (Scapular region).
Sponsors
GlaxoSmithKline
Study design
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
BASIC_SCIENCE
Masking
SINGLE (Outcomes Assessor)
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 65 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes
Inclusion criteria
* Demonstrates understanding of the study procedures, restrictions and willingness to participate as evidenced by voluntary written informed consent and has received a signed and dated copy of the informed consent form. * General health: Good general and mental health with, in the opinion of the investigator or medically qualified designee no clinically significant and relevant abnormalities in medical history or upon physical examination and participants must have intact skin on the proposed application site; dorsum (scapular region). * Fitzpatrick photo type I to IV. * Agreement to comply with the procedures and requirements of the study and to attend the scheduled assessment visits.
Exclusion criteria
* Women who are known to be pregnant or who are intending to become pregnant over the duration of the study. * Women who are breast-feeding. * Any history of significant dermatological diseases or conditions or medical conditions known to alter skin appearance or physiologic response (e.g. diabetes,) which could, in the opinion of the Investigator, preclude topical application of the investigational products and/or interfere with the evaluation of the test site reaction. * Presence of open sores, pimples, or cysts at the application site. * Active dermatosis (local or disseminated) that might interfere with the results of the study * Considered immune compromised. * History of diseases aggravated or triggered by ultraviolet radiation. * Participants with dermatographism. * Currently using any medication which in the opinion of the investigator, may affect the evaluation of the study product, or place the participant at undue risk. * Use of the following topical or systemic medications: immunosuppressants, antihistamines, non-hormonal anti-inflammatory drugs, and corticosteroids up to 2 weeks before Screening visit. * Oral or topical treatment with vitamin A acid and/or its derivatives up to 1 month before the screening visit. * Intention of being vaccinated during the study period or vaccination within 3 weeks of the Screening visit. * Currently receiving allergy injections, or due to receive an injection within 7 days prior to Visit 1, or expects to begin injections during study participation. * Previous history of atopy, allergic reactions, irritation or intense discomfort feelings to topical-use products, cosmetics or medication. * Known or suspected intolerance or hypersensitivity to any of the study materials (or closely related compounds) or any of their stated ingredients, including any component of the patches. * History of sensitization in a previous patch study. * Participation in another clinical study (including cosmetic studies) or receipt of an investigational drug within 30 days of the Screening visit. * Previous participation in this study. * Recent history (within the last 5 years) of alcohol or other substance abuse. * Intense sunlight exposure or sun tanning sessions up to 30 days before the Screening evaluation Intention of bathing, sauna, water sports, or activities that lead to intense sweating. * Any participant who, in the judgment of the Investigator, should not participate in the study. * Any skin marks on the test site that might interfere with the evaluation of possible skin reactions (e.g. pigmentation disorders, vascular malformations, scars, tattoos, excessive hair, numerous freckles). * Prisoner or involuntary incarcerated participant. * Participant from an indigenous tribe. * An employee of the sponsor or the study site or members of their immediate family.
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | At Day 4 (48 hours post patch removal) | Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 48 hours following patch removal on Day 4 post 72 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site. |
| Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | At Day 2 (15-30 minutes post patch removal) | Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 15-30 minutes following patch removal on Day 2 post 24 hrs of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site. |
| Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | At Day 3 (24 hours post patch removal) | Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 24 hours following patch removal on Day 3 post 48 hrs of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site. |
| Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | At Day 4 (48 hours post patch removal) | Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 48 hours following patch removal on Day 4 post 72 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site. |
| Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | At Day 2 (15-30 minutes post patch removal) | Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 15-30 minutes following patch removal on Day 2 post 24 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site. |
| Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | At Day 3 (24 hours post patch removal) | Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 24 hours following patch removal on Day 3 post 48 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site. |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | At Day 2 (15-30 minutes), Day 3 (24 hours) and Day 4 (48 hours) post patch removal | A trained assessor assessed all patch sites.Following scores were used to express response observed at time of examination:0=No evidence of irritation,1=Minimal erythema;barely perceptible,2=Definite erythema,readily visible;or minimal edema; or minimal papular response,3=Erythema and papules,4=Definite edema,5=Erythema, edema,and papules,6=Vesicular eruption,7=Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.Other features indicative irritation (Superficial irritation) scores were:GradeA/Score0=Slight glazed appearance,GradeB/Score1=Marked glazing,GradeC/Score2=Glazing with peeling and cracking,GradeF/Score3=Glazing with fissures,Grade G/Score 3=Film of dried serous exudate covering all or portion of patch,Grade H/Score3=Small petechial erosions and/or scabs.The letter grades were converted to scores.Superficial irritation scores were only provided if there was a dermal response score \>0.No effect is 0 score(i.e. no evidence).Full Range 0-10.Lower score indicates better product tolerabily |
Countries
Brazil
Participant flow
Recruitment details
All the participants were enrolled at one center in Brazil.
Pre-assignment details
A total of 46 participants were screened, out of which 3 participants did not meet study criteria, 43 participants were enrolled in the study out of which 3 participants withdrew their consent. Remaining 40 participants were randomized to the study.
Participants by arm
| Arm | Count |
|---|---|
| Overall Participants All participants randomized to the study. Test and control products were applied to a paper disc (or cell) contained within an adhesive patch. The number of cells available on the patch test tape is 6 (but only 5 cells were used, 4 test and 1 reference products). The patch was then applied onto the dorsum (scapula region) of each participant for a period of 24 ± 2 hours, the sequence of the product application to the cells was as per the randomization schedule. | 40 |
| Total | 40 |
Withdrawals & dropouts
| Period | Reason | FG000 |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Study | Lost to Follow-up | 1 |
Baseline characteristics
| Characteristic | Overall Participants |
|---|---|
| Age, Continuous | 35.7 Years STANDARD_DEVIATION 11.65 |
| Race (NIH/OMB) American Indian or Alaska Native | 0 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Asian | 0 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Black or African American | 11 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) More than one race | 0 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander | 0 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) Unknown or Not Reported | 0 Participants |
| Race (NIH/OMB) White | 29 Participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Female | 33 Participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Male | 7 Participants |
Adverse events
| Event type | EG000 affected / at risk | EG001 affected / at risk | EG002 affected / at risk | EG003 affected / at risk | EG004 affected / at risk | EG005 affected / at risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| deaths Total, all-cause mortality | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 |
| other Total, other adverse events | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 |
| serious Total, serious adverse events | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 | 0 / 40 |
Outcome results
Primary
Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal
Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 24 hours following patch removal on Day 3 post 48 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.
Time frame: At Day 3 (24 hours post patch removal)
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 2 | Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 3 | Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 4 | Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Reference Product | Average Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
Primary
Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal
Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 15-30 minutes following patch removal on Day 2 post 24 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.
Time frame: At Day 2 (15-30 minutes post patch removal)
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 2 | Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 3 | Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 4 | Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Reference Product | Average Dermal Response Score at 30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on Scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
Primary
Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal
Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 48 hours following patch removal on Day 4 post 72 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.
Time frame: At Day 4 (48 hours post patch removal)
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 2 | Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 3 | Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Test Product 4 | Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
| Reference Product | Average Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 Score on scale | Standard Deviation 0 |
Primary
Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal
Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 15-30 minutes following patch removal on Day 2 post 24 hrs of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.
Time frame: At Day 2 (15-30 minutes post patch removal)
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Category | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 15-30 Minutes Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
Primary
Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal
Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 24 hours following patch removal on Day 3 post 48 hrs of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.
Time frame: At Day 3 (24 hours post patch removal)
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Category | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 24 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
Primary
Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal
Product tolerability was assessed by Dermal Response Score. Test sites were evaluated 48 hours following patch removal on Day 4 post 72 hours of patch application. Response score from 0 to 7; 0= No evidence of irritation, 1= Minimal erythema, barely perceptible, 2= Definite erythema, readily visible; minimal edema or minimal papular response, 3= Erythema and papules, 4= Definite edema, 5= Erythema, edema and papules, 6= Vesicular eruption, 7= Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.
Time frame: At Day 4 (48 hours post patch removal)
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Category | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 6 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 4 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 0 | 39 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 2 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 5 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Frequency of Dermal Response Score at 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | 7 | 0 Participants |
Secondary
Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal
A trained assessor assessed all patch sites.Following scores were used to express response observed at time of examination:0=No evidence of irritation,1=Minimal erythema;barely perceptible,2=Definite erythema,readily visible;or minimal edema; or minimal papular response,3=Erythema and papules,4=Definite edema,5=Erythema, edema,and papules,6=Vesicular eruption,7=Strong reaction spreading beyond test site.Other features indicative irritation (Superficial irritation) scores were:GradeA/Score0=Slight glazed appearance,GradeB/Score1=Marked glazing,GradeC/Score2=Glazing with peeling and cracking,GradeF/Score3=Glazing with fissures,Grade G/Score 3=Film of dried serous exudate covering all or portion of patch,Grade H/Score3=Small petechial erosions and/or scabs.The letter grades were converted to scores.Superficial irritation scores were only provided if there was a dermal response score \>0.No effect is 0 score(i.e. no evidence).Full Range 0-10.Lower score indicates better product tolerabily
Time frame: At Day 2 (15-30 minutes), Day 3 (24 hours) and Day 4 (48 hours) post patch removal
Population: The ITT (N= 39) population included all participants who were randomized into the study and have skin irritation scores from at least one of the test sites available.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Category | Value (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 1 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 2 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 3 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Test Product 4 | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade F/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade B/Score 1 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 3 (24 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade G/Score 3 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Missing | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | No effect | 39 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 2 (15-30 minutes) | Grade C/Score 2 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade A/Score 0 | 0 Participants |
| Reference Product | Number of Participants With Combined Skin Irritation (Dermal Response) Scores at 30 Minutes, 24 Hours and 48 Hours Post Patch Removal | Day 4 (48 hours) | Grade H/Score 3 | 0 Participants |