Smoking Cessation
Conditions
Brief summary
Smoking is the number one cause of preventable death in the United States. Given the magnitude of the problem, interventions aimed at promoting smoking cessation have the potential to make large changes in improving health outcomes. Resources to aid with smoking cessation such as telephone-based counseling are generally underutilized. The electronic medical record (EMR) in use at Johns Hopkins has limited decision support to promote referral to the Maryland Quit Line, a free smoking cessation counseling resource. The investigators propose a cluster randomized trial (Implementation-RCT hybrid design) with a waitlist control at the 22 Johns Hopkins Community Physicians (JHCP) sites, which offer primary care. The intervention will include a multi-modality intervention to promote provider use of smoking cessation resources which include an Epic-based Best Practice Advisory (BPA) that allows providers to electronically refer to the Maryland State Quit Line, educational materials, and provider visits with Quit Line representatives to review use of smoking cessation practices. Sites will be randomized to one of three arms with increasing support: 1) six-month waitlist control; 2) BPA with optional educational modules; 3) BPA with online educational modules, a quick-reference educational document, and additional visit with Quit Line representatives. The investigators hypothesize that by implementing a new Epic BPA that allows providers to easily refer to the Maryland Quit Line electronically, investigators will increase use of this resource. The investigators also hypothesize that adding additional educational materials and having Quit Line representatives perform educational outreach visits will further increase use of the Quit Line and will increase prescription of medications to assist with smoking cessation. Ultimately The investigators hope to improve patient care by increasing providers' use the Maryland Quit Line and pharmacotherapy. The investigators hope that the use of these resources will decrease smoking rates and thereby improve patient health and outcomes while improving JHCP quality metrics.
Detailed description
Smoking is the number one cause of preventable death in the United States. Given the magnitude of the problem, interventions aimed at promoting smoking cessation have the potential to make large changes in improving health outcomes. Resources to aid with smoking cessation such as telephone-based counseling are generally underutilized. The electronic medical record (EMR) in use at Johns Hopkins has limited decision support to promote referral to the Maryland Quit Line, a free smoking cessation counseling resource. The investigators propose a cluster randomized trial (Implementation-RCT hybrid design) with a waitlist control at the 22 Johns Hopkins Community Physicians (JHCP) sites, which offer primary care. The intervention will include a multi-modality intervention to promote provider use of smoking cessation resources which include an Epic-based Best Practice Advisory (BPA) that allows providers to electronically refer to the Maryland State Quit Line, educational materials, and provider visits with Quit Line representatives to review use of smoking cessation practices. Sites will be randomized to one of three arms with increasing support: 1) six-month waitlist control; 2) BPA with optional educational modules; 3) BPA with online educational modules, a quick-reference educational document, and additional visit with Quit Line representatives. The investigators hypothesize that by implementing a new Epic BPA that allows providers to easily refer to the Maryland Quit Line electronically, The investigators will increase use of this resource. The investigators also hypothesize that adding additional educational materials and having Quit Line representatives perform educational outreach visits will further increase use of the Quit Line and will increase prescription of medications to assist with smoking cessation. Ultimately, the investigators hope to improve patient care by increasing providers' use the Maryland Quit Line and pharmacotherapy. The investigators hope that the use of these resources will decrease smoking rates and thereby improve patient health and outcomes while improving JHCP quality metrics. The primary goal of this study is to test the effectiveness of instituting an Epic BPA in increasing Maryland Quit Line referrals. The secondary goals are to measure the BPA's effect and the effect of additional provider education on patient engagement with the Quit Line, and on prescription of medications that aid in smoking cessation. Aim 1: In a three-arm, cluster randomized trial, to test the effectiveness of an Epic BPA with provider educational support and provider detailing in provision of smoking cessation services. Hypothesis 1: An Epic-based BPA to prompt providers to electronically refer people who are ready to quit smoking to the Maryland Quit Line will increase use of this service compared to waitlist control. Hypothesis 2: An Epic-based BPA supplemented with educational materials and academic detailing will increase Quit-Line referral compared to control. Hypothesis 3: Additional provider support including educational materials, in-person academic detailing, will increase successful referrals to the Quit Line and prescription of cessation pharmacotherapy compared to waitlist control and BPA only
Interventions
1. BPA: The BPA is an Epic prompt that fires when a provider opens an encounter with a patient who is actively smoking. Providers will be asked to assess smoking cessation readiness and to refer patients to the free Maryland Quit Line if the patient is receptive. The Quit Line will receive an electronic referral with the patient's details. A Quit Line certified smoking cessation counselor will then call the patient at a later date and provide counseling. Receptive patient will receive up to four calls. They will receive counseling from a trained quit coach and be offered free access to NRT. 2. Quit Line: This free telephone-based counseling service is offered to smoker in Maryland. Services offered include on-the-phone smoking cessation counseling and free nicotine replacement.
BPA with Quitline Referral plus 1)Consolidated educational hand out: The hand out will include a information about counseling, pharmacotherapy, and cessation referrals 2)Online modules: Providers will be directed to optional, self-paced educational modules through the Maryland HABITS program 3)Academic detailing: This will include a single session during a clinic day in which counseling experts from the MD Quit Line will visit providers in their practice setting.
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
* Johns Hopkins Community Physicians Primary Care Practices (Internal Medicine and Family Medicine)
Exclusion criteria
* None
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 6 months | Number of referrals made out of total eligible for referral. |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Prescription of Pharmacotherapy for Smoking Cessation | 12 months | Nicotine replacement, Varenicline or Bupropion prescription. |
| Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | 6 months | Number of patients that accepted services or declined or were not reached or were already enrolled. |
| Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 12 months | Number of referrals made out of total eligible for referral. |
Countries
United States
Participant flow
Pre-assignment details
Waitlist Control Sites A and B were together (8) in the first 6 months after which they were randomized to A (4) and B (4).
Participants by arm
| Arm | Count |
|---|---|
| Waitlist Control - A BPA+ Enhanced Education will be rolled out to waitlist control sites after 6 months. | 0 |
| Waitlist Control - A BPA+ Enhanced Education will be rolled out to waitlist control sites after 6 months. | 4 |
| Waitlist Control - B BPA will be rolled out to waitlist control sites after 6 months. | 0 |
| Waitlist Control - B BPA will be rolled out to waitlist control sites after 6 months. | 4 |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) Clinicians will receive an email describing the BPA and order set, along with internet links to MD Quit Line without additional supplemental education.
Best Practices Advisory (BPA): 1. BPA: The BPA is an Epic prompt that fires when a provider opens an encounter with a patient who is actively smoking. Providers will be asked to assess smoking cessation readiness and to refer patients to the free Maryland Quit Line if the patient is receptive. The Quit Line will receive an electronic referral with the patient's details. A Quit Line certified smoking cessation counselor will then call the patient at a later date and provide counseling. Receptive patient will receive up to four calls. They will receive counseling from a trained quit coach and be offered free access to NRT.
2\. Quit Line: This free telephone-based counseling service is offered to smoker in Maryland. Services offered include on-the-phone smoking cessation counseling and free nicotine replacement. | 0 |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) Clinicians will receive an email describing the BPA and order set, along with internet links to MD Quit Line without additional supplemental education.
Best Practices Advisory (BPA): 1. BPA: The BPA is an Epic prompt that fires when a provider opens an encounter with a patient who is actively smoking. Providers will be asked to assess smoking cessation readiness and to refer patients to the free Maryland Quit Line if the patient is receptive. The Quit Line will receive an electronic referral with the patient's details. A Quit Line certified smoking cessation counselor will then call the patient at a later date and provide counseling. Receptive patient will receive up to four calls. They will receive counseling from a trained quit coach and be offered free access to NRT.
2\. Quit Line: This free telephone-based counseling service is offered to smoker in Maryland. Services offered include on-the-phone smoking cessation counseling and free nicotine replacement. | 7 |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education Clinicians will receive an email describing the new smoking BPA, educational materials offered, and a small tutorial on using the BPA and a new smoking cessation smart set in Epic. Education materials will include the educational hand out and academic detailing from Maryland Quit Line counselors.
BPA + Enhanced Education: BPA with Quitline Referral plus 1)Consolidated educational hand out: The hand out will include a information about counseling, pharmacotherapy, and cessation referrals 2)Online modules: Providers will be directed to optional, self-paced educational modules through the Maryland HABITS program 3)Academic detailing: This will include a single session during a clinic day in which counseling experts from the MD Quit Line will visit providers in their practice setting. | 0 |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education Clinicians will receive an email describing the new smoking BPA, educational materials offered, and a small tutorial on using the BPA and a new smoking cessation smart set in Epic. Education materials will include the educational hand out and academic detailing from Maryland Quit Line counselors.
BPA + Enhanced Education: BPA with Quitline Referral plus 1)Consolidated educational hand out: The hand out will include a information about counseling, pharmacotherapy, and cessation referrals 2)Online modules: Providers will be directed to optional, self-paced educational modules through the Maryland HABITS program 3)Academic detailing: This will include a single session during a clinic day in which counseling experts from the MD Quit Line will visit providers in their practice setting. | 7 |
| Total | 22 |
Baseline characteristics
| Characteristic | — | Waitlist Control - B | Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | BPA+ Enhanced Education | Total | Waitlist Control - A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age, Customized NA | — participants | — | — | — | — | — |
| Race/Ethnicity, Customized NA | — participants | — | — | — | — | — |
| Region of Enrollment United States | — | 4 Practice Sites | 7 Practice Sites | 7 Practice Sites | 22 Practice Sites | 4 Practice Sites |
| Sex/Gender, Customized NA | — participants | — | — | — | — | — |
Adverse events
| Event type | EG000 affected / at risk | EG001 affected / at risk | EG002 affected / at risk | EG003 affected / at risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| deaths Total, all-cause mortality | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
| other Total, other adverse events | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
| serious Total, serious adverse events | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 | 0 / 0 |
Outcome results
Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line
Number of referrals made out of total eligible for referral.
Time frame: 6 months
Population: This assessment was on number of service referrals made out of eligible encounters and not individual participants. Individual participants analyzed was not collected. Referrals were not made for Waitlist control groups A and B because they were not randomized yet at this time to either BPA or BPA+ Enhanced Education. Data not collected from the waitlist groups at this time point as the intervention had not been rolled out.
| Arm | Measure | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 623 referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 405 referrals |
Patient Engagement With the Quit Line
Number of patients that accepted services or declined or were not reached or were already enrolled.
Time frame: 6 months
Population: This assessment was on number of service referrals and not individual participants. Individual participants analyzed was not collected. This assessment was not done for Waitlist control groups A and B. Due to differences in the timeline of data collection between data from the EMR (within the trial period) and those received from the quitline (monthly summary reports), there are minor discrepancies between the referral totals of this outcome and outcome 1.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Declined | 27 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Not reached | 346 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Already enrolled | 6 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Pending/incomplete | 114 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Accepted services | 133 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Pending/incomplete | 75 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Accepted services | 80 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Declined | 17 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Already enrolled | 4 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Not reached | 216 service referrals |
Patient Engagement With the Quit Line
Number of patients that accepted services or declined or were not reached or were already enrolled.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: This assessment was on number of service referrals and not individual participants. Individual participants analyzed was not collected. This assessment was not done for Waitlist control groups A and B.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Accepted services | 100 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Not reached | 289 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Already enrolled | 6 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Pending/incomplete | 39 service referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Declined | 80 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Pending/incomplete | 32 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Accepted services | 80 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Declined | 77 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Already enrolled | 7 service referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Patient Engagement With the Quit Line | Not reached | 291 service referrals |
Prescription of Pharmacotherapy for Smoking Cessation
Nicotine replacement, Varenicline or Bupropion prescription.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: Data was not collected for this outcome measure.
Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line
Number of referrals made out of total eligible for referral.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: This assessment was on number of service referrals made out of eligible encounters and not individual participants. Individual participants analyzed was not collected.
| Arm | Measure | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|
| Waitlist Control - A | Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 272 referrals |
| Waitlist Control - B | Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 186 referrals |
| Best Practices Advisory (BPA) | Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 284 referrals |
| BPA+ Enhanced Education | Provider Electronic Referrals to the Maryland Quit Line | 203 referrals |