Skip to content

Behavioral Economics Field Experiment in HIV Testing

Behavioral Nudges, Information and Incentives for HIV Testing: A Field Experiment in Ecuador

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT03224741
Enrollment
7720
Registered
2017-07-21
Start date
2017-06-12
Completion date
2019-01-01
Last updated
2019-02-04

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

HIV/AIDS Serodiagnosis

Keywords

Behavioral Economics

Brief summary

The investigators propose to conduct a randomized controlled trial in collaboration with the Fundacion Raices, a non-governmental organization (NGO) with strong ties to the local community of Esmeraldas, Ecuador. A total of about 3,000 subjects will be involved in the full-scale study over the course of 2 years. In partnership with the Fundacion Raices, the research team will set up stands at four public places in the city of Esmeraldas: the malecon (esplanade on the town's waterfront), the Centro Comercial Multiplaza (Esmeraldas' large shopping mall), the municipal market (a popular destination for groceries, etc.), and a public park located in the city center. Each stand will feature a sign inviting individuals to stop and get their health checked, and will provide free refreshments (juice boxes and water). A monitor will approach individuals at the malecon/shopping center/municipal market/public park and ask whether they are interested to learn about a health initiative by the Fundacion Raices and a group of public health researchers. If an individual is interested, the monitor will begin the three steps of the experiment: 1. Participants fill out a brief, anonymous survey with demographics, socio- economic characteristics, and whether they have been tested for HIV/AIDS in the past. 2. Participants receive the script and actions associated with the experimental condition into which they are assigned to according to the randomization table. There are three experimental conditions: T1 = Information. T2 = Active Choice. T3 = Monetary incentive. 3. Whether participants subsequently showed up at a medical facility to get tested for HIV/AIDS is noted in the record.

Detailed description

The investigators propose to conduct a randomized controlled trial in collaboration with the Fundacion Raices, a non-governmental organization (NGO) with strong ties to the local community of Esmeraldas, Ecuador. A total of about 3,000 subjects will be involved in the full-scale study over the course of 2 years. In partnership with the Fundacion Raices, the research team will set up stands at four public places in the city of Esmeraldas: the malecon (esplanade on the town's waterfront), the Centro Comercial Multiplaza (Esmeraldas' large shopping mall), the municipal market (a popular destination for groceries, etc.), and a public park located in the city center. Each stand will feature a sign inviting individuals to stop and get their health checked, and will provide free refreshments (juice boxes and water). A monitor will approach individuals at the malecon/shopping center/municipal market/public park and ask whether they are interested to learn about a health initiative by the Fundacion Raices and a group of public health researchers. If an individual expresses interest, a field worker will begin the three steps of the experiment: (1) The participant completes a brief, anonymous survey with demographics, socio- economic, and past HIV/AIDS testing information. (2) The participant receives the script and actions associated with the assigned randomized experimental condition. There are three experimental conditions: - T1 = Information. T2 = Active Choice. T3 = Monetary incentive. (3) Whether the participant shows up at the medical facility to get tested is entered in the record. Randomization: The randomization will vary by week (i.e., all participants who present on the same week will be assigned to the same experimental condition) to minimize spillover effects due to communication between participants assigned to different groups, and to avoid confusion among the field staff. The implementation schedule will be designed to guarantee balance of treatment conditions across locations and days of the week. To provide the participants with privacy when filling the questionnaire, after the initial approach, the interaction between the participants and field staff will occur in a booth next to the desk which will obscure the participant from the view of others. Participants will be read a statement inviting participation; description of privacy protection measures; and solicitation of verbal consent. The investigators also plan to test our experimental conditions with subjects from high-risk population groups. For high-risk population groups, the investigators will rely on the previous experience of research team members in which Female Sex Workers (FSWs) and Men who have Sex with Men (MSM) were contacted through the official registry and local MSM association, respectively. A similar approach will be used in this project. Participants in these high-risk groups will be approached individually by field staff, after having been randomly assigned to one of three experimental conditions. Participants will be read a statement inviting participation; description of privacy protection measures; and solicitation of verbal consent. The investigators expect to include about 1,000 subjects from the high-risk populations. The medical testing facility where participants will go is Microlab - Laboratiorio Clinico Bacteriologico, centrally located in Esmeraldas (across the street from the Delfina Torres Public Hospital). It is a private facility staffed by healthcare professionals connected to the testing lab at the Medical School and Hospital of the Universidad San Francisco de Quito (USFQ) in Quito, Ecuador. Blood samples will be tested using standardized commercially available HIV testing kits. Participants in the financial incentive condition will receive their reward from the staff at the Microlab in Esmeraldas. The participants will not provide names to the lab personnel. Instead, they will give them the second portion of the registration card, which indicates their study identification number (ID). The lab staff will write the study ID onto the sample collection label. Blood samples will be sent to the testing facility at the USFQ. There, trained laboratory personnel will conduct the HIV screening test following Standard Operating Procedures. After conducting the test, laboratory personnel will record the results in an excel spreadsheet using the participant's ID number as identifier (i.e., there will be no record of name or other personal identifiable information). Afterwards, the results will be individually printed on a pre-designed HIV screening Test Results Form. Individual results will be put in an envelope. Envelopes will be sealed and sent back to the testing facility in Esmeraldas via a private carrier. After arrival, results will be archived in a locked unit and delivered to participants as they arrive to claim their results. Participants will receive their results in a timely manner, according to local health policies. HIV positive individuals will be encouraged to visit the local health district to enroll into the national HIV/AIDS program for treatment.

Interventions

Subjects in this condition will be read a script informing them of the benefits and importance of routine HIV/AIDS testing for themselves, the benefits for one's partner and loved ones, and for the broader community; they are also given a flyer including the same information.Iin addition, they will be told that if they will get tested for HIV/AIDS within the next two weeks, they will receive $10 (the US dollar became Ecuador's official currency in 2001).

BEHAVIORALInformation

Subjects assigned to this condition are read a script informing them of the benefits and importance of routine HIV/AIDS testing for themselves, the benefits for one's partner and loved ones, and for the broader community; they are also given a flyer including the same information. Then, they are invited to get tested in the next two weeks.

BEHAVIORALActive Choice

Subjects in this condition will receive the same information and flyer as in T1; in addition, they are told that they have the opportunity to express their intention to get tested for HIV/AIDS. To this aim, they will be given a sheet of paper and asked to tick one of two boxes. The first box will say I intend to get tested within the next two weeks, and the second will say I will consider getting tested within the next two weeks but I am not ready to commit at this time. They will also be asked to write their initials at the bottom of the sheet, and will be told to keep it. This is a form of soft commitment which has proven effective in other contexts (Bryan et al. 2010).

Sponsors

Universidad San Francisco de Quito
CollaboratorOTHER
University of South Florida
CollaboratorOTHER
Johns Hopkins University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
FACTORIAL
Primary purpose
SCREENING
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)

Masking description

The subject receives the script and actions associated with the experimental condition she/he is assigned to according to the randomization. The subject receives a card consisting of three detachable parts. Each part includes a numerical ID that uniquely identifies each participant. The first part of the card will remain with the researchers. The second part of the card does to the medical personnel at the health facility if and when they go there to get tested. The third part of the card will remain with the participant. This procedure and the study ID will enable the research team to (a) associate participants to the treatment conditions and (b) determine the outcomes (whether they got tested or not, and what the results were), while preserving the anonymity of the participants.

Intervention model description

Randomized Control Trial

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

* All participants able to understand the instructions and provide consent

Exclusion criteria

* Under 18 years of age (age of consent)

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Proportion of participants in each experimental condition that showed up for the HIV sero test.2 weeksThe outcome measure is a relative proportion of participants in each experimental condition that showed up at the 'Microlab - Laboratiorio Clinico Bacteriologico' to provide a blood sample for the HIV sero test. It is calculated as the number of tested participants divided by the total number of participants enrolled into each experimental condition. An enrolled participant is defined as an individual that received the information and instructions in T1, T2 and T3.

Countries

Ecuador

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026