Skip to content

Postoperative Intermittent Intrauterine Balloon Dilatation Therapy.

Prevention of Postoperative Adhesion Reformation by Intrauterine Balloon Therapy: a Randomized Controlled Trial

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT03131596
Enrollment
200
Registered
2017-04-27
Start date
2017-05-15
Completion date
2018-11-15
Last updated
2019-09-13

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Intrauterine Adhesion

Keywords

Intrauterine Adhesion, Hysteroscopy, Intrauterine balloon, Reformation, Prevention

Brief summary

In this prospective, randomized, controlled study, the investigators wish to determine the efficacy of intrauterine balloon (IUB) dilatation in the prevention of adhesion reformation when compared with the conventional management.

Detailed description

Patients The patients will be recruited from the Hysteroscopy Center of the Fuxing Hospital, Beijing, China. Before the surgery all patients with suspected Asherman syndrome will undergo preoperative evaluations, including a detailed history of the menstrual pattern, any previous intrauterine surgery, and reproductive history, as well as trans-vaginal ultrasonography. The severity and extent of intrauterine adhesions will be scored according to a classification system recommended by the American Fertility Society (AFS) (1988 version). The inclusion criteria include \[1\] women aged 18-40 years; \[2\] moderate to severe intrauterine adhesion (AFS score≥5); \[3\] first episode of hysteroscopic adhesiolysis in FuXing hospital; \[4\] written consent obtained; and \[5\] agreement to have second-look and an optional third-look hysteroscopy. The exclusion criteria include \[1\] minimal adhesion (AFS score \<5) and \[2\] previous hysteroscopic adhesiolysis in FuXing hospital. Study Design After the completion of hysteroscopic adhesiolysis, recruited patients will be randomized to one of the two treatment groups by computer-generated numbers: \[1\] having a Foley-catheter intrauterine balloon dilatation 2 weeks and 6 weeks after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis; \[2\] the control group without any additional treatment. A second-look hysteroscopy will be carried out in the early proliferative phase 4 weeks after the surgery and an optional third-look hysteroscopy will be carried out 8 weeks after the surgery. Power Calculation On the basis of the results of the two published retrospective cohort studies comparing the balloon and hormone therapy group (control group) in the prevention of adhesion reformation, we estimate that the adhesion reformation rate in the balloon group to be 20% and in the control group to be 45%. Accepting a type 1 error of 0.05, and a type 2 error of 0.10, the number of subjects in each arm of the randomized, controlled trial would be 79. Assuming that the dropout rate to be 20%, the total number of subject to be recruited would be 100 in each arm. Procedure Surgical procedure The surgery will be carried out by one of two experienced hysteroscopic surgeons with the use of a 8.5-mm rigid hysteroscope (Olympus) with 0.9% normal saline infusion under 120-150 mmHg pressure. The procedure will be performed under general anesthesia in a day surgery unit. Ultrasonographic guidance will be routinely used. Once the extent and severity of uterine adhesion has been assessed, the adhesions will be divided with the use of bipolar instrument until normal uterine anatomy is achieved. Postoperative treatments All subjects will be treated with oral antibiotics(Cefaclor 0.375 mg twice daily Tianjin Central Pharmaceutical Co Ltd., Tianjin, China.) for 5-7 days. In all cases hormone therapy also began from the day of operation, consisting of estradiol valerate at a dose of 4 mg/d for 21 days, with the addition of dydrogesterone at a dose of 10 mg/d for the last 7 days of the estrogen therapy. After the withdrawal bleed, the hormone therapy was repeated for a further two cycles, i.e. 3 months in total. Second-look hysteroscopy will be carried out in the early proliferative phase, 4 weeks after the initial operation; a third-look hysteroscopy will be carried out 8 weeks after the initial operation. After assessment of the extent and severity of any reformed adhesion, hysteroscopic adhesiolysis will also be carried out at the time of the second-look procedure, if adhesion has recurred. The surgeon who performs the second-look and third-look hysteroscopy will be blinded to the randomization. IUB dilatation IUB dilatation therapy will be performed using a Foley catheter(14fr) and according to the methodology published in the literature. This will be prepared by cutting the catheter tip protruding beyond the balloon. Once the catheter has reached the fundus, 3-4.5mls of saline will be slowly infiltrated into the balloon under ultrasound guidance in order to distend the cavity, thereby separating any reformed intrauterine adhesions. Statistical Analysis Intention-to-treat analysis was conducted primarily on all outcomes for all randomized subjects. Numerical data with normal distribution were presented as the mean ± standard deviation, whereas data with skewed distribution were presented as the median (interquartile range). The Student t test was used to compare normally distributed data between two groups and paired t test was used to compare normally distributed data within two groups. The Mann-Whitney U test was used to compare data with skewed distribution. Contingency table analysis and the χ2 test were used to compare categorical data. A p value of \< 0.05 was considered statistically significant. All statistical analysis was carried out with the use of SPSS 21.0. Outcome measures The primary outcome measure was defined as the AFS score at each follow-up, including the adhesion reformation rate, in addition to the menstrual improvement, which was evaluated according to Pictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart (PBAC) score. Secondary outcomes included pregnancy rate, miscarriage rate and ectopic rate. Data processing and analysis The investigators will ensure the confidentiality of sensitive data by minimizing the number of personnel who handle subject data. In addition, computer data will be encrypted as required to maximize security, while paper documents will be locked in filing cabinets, with only authorized personnel having access to the information. Ethical considerations IUB dilatation has been published as a novel technique with no untoward complications identified to date. The procedure will be performed according to the methodology available in the literature and the study has gained approval from the local ethical committee. Consent All subjects will be given a detailed explanation of the study and sufficient time to consider their participation. A written consent form will be signed by the patient and retained in the confidential records.

Interventions

PROCEDUREIUB dilatation therapy

A Foley catheter (size 14fr) will be prepared by cutting the excess catheter tip protruding beyond the balloon prior to insertion into the uterine cavity. Once the catheter has reached the fundus, 3-4.5mls of saline will be slowly introduced into the balloon under ultrasound guidance, in order to directly visualize the distention of the cavity and division of any intrauterine adhesions, if present.

Sponsors

Fu Xing Hospital, Capital Medical University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
PREVENTION
Masking
SINGLE (Investigator)

Masking description

Both surgeons conducting the hysteroscopic surgery and follow-up hysteroscopy were blinded to the patient group allocation.

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
FEMALE
Age
18 Years to 40 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

1. women aged 18-40 years; 2. moderate to severe intrauterine adhesion (AFS score≥5); 3. no previous history of hysteroscopic adhesiolysis in our hospital; 4. written consent obtained 5. agreement to have second-look and third-look hysteroscopy.

Exclusion criteria

1. minimal adhesion (AFS score \<5); 2. previous hysteroscopic adhesiolysis in our hospital.

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Number of Participants With Adhesion Reformation (American Fertility Society Score of Greater Than 0) 8 Weeks Later After the Index Surgeryat 8 weeks post-operationThe American Fertility Society (AFS) score ranges from 0-12, while represented the severity of the adhesions. Mild 1-4, Moderate 5-8, Severe 9-12. The lower the AFS score is, the better the prognosis the patient is. When the surgery was finished the AFS score should be 0. The reformation of intrauterine adhesions was evaluated by third-look hysteroscopy, if the score was greater than 0, a adhesion reformation was considered.
The American Fertility Society Score 8 Weeks After Operationat 8 weeks post-operationThe American Fertility Society(AFS) score of each group was evaluated again at third-look hysteroscopy in order to reflect the efficacy of the treatment. The original AFS score was recorded in baseline characteristics part. The AFS score ranges from 0-12, while represented the severity of the adhesions. Mild 1-4, Moderate 5-8, Severe 9-12. The lower the AFS score is, the better the prognosis the patient is. When the surgery was finished the AFS score score should be 0.
Pictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart Score 8 Weeks After Operationat 8 weeks post-operationThe Pictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart (PBAC) score was used to represent the menstrual flow volume of the patient. The PBAC score was evaluated again at 8 weeks after surgery. A higher PBAC score after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis means a better outcome.The PBAC score of a normal women usually range from 30-100 points. The minium value of PBAC score is 0, which means the patient is amenorrhea. The maximum value of PBAC score is 1000. We measured the score before and 8 weeks after the operation in order to assess if there was any improvement (higher than before) in menstrual flow.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Pregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopywithin 12 months after third look hysteroscopy(8 weeks post-operation)number of patients who have pregnancy, miscarriage and ectopic pregnancy within12 months follow-up

Countries

China

Participant flow

Recruitment details

208 patients with moderate to severe (American Fertility Society score ≥ 5) Asherman syndrome who underwent hysteroscopic adhesiolysis were recruited from May 1st,2017 to January 1st,2018.

Pre-assignment details

1 patients was excluded follow the criteria strictly and 7 patients declined to participant. In total, 8 patients were excluded before assignment to groups.

Participants by arm

ArmCount
IUB Dilatation Therapy
The patient will have a Foley-catheter intrauterine balloon dilatation 2 weeks and 6 weeks after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis. A second-look hysteroscopy was carried out in the early proliferative phase 4 weeks after the surgery and an optional third-look hysteroscopy will carried out 8 weeks after the surgery. IUB dilatation therapy: A Foley catheter (size 14fr) will be prepared by cutting the excess catheter tip protruding beyond the balloon prior to insertion into the uterine cavity. Once the catheter has reached the fundus, 3-4.5mls of saline will be slowly introduced into the balloon under ultrasound guidance, in order to directly visualize the distention of the cavity and division of any intrauterine adhesions, if present.
94
Control Group
Patient will not undergo any balloon therapy. A second-look hysteroscopy will be carried out in the early proliferative phase 4 weeks after the surgery and an optional third-look hysteroscopy will be carried out 8 weeks after the surgery.
97
Total191

Withdrawals & dropouts

PeriodReasonFG000FG001
Overall StudyLost to Follow-up30
Overall StudyProtocol Violation33

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicIUB Dilatation TherapyTotalControl Group
AFS score before operation10 units on a scale10 units on a scale10 units on a scale
Age, Continuous31.2 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.7
32.0 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.5
32.0 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.4
PBAC score before operation19.4 units on a scale
STANDARD_DEVIATION 8.6
19.1 units on a scale
STANDARD_DEVIATION 8.3
18.8 units on a scale
STANDARD_DEVIATION 7.8
Race (NIH/OMB)
American Indian or Alaska Native
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Asian
94 Participants191 Participants97 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Black or African American
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
More than one race
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
White
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
94 Participants191 Participants97 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 940 / 97
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 940 / 97
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 940 / 97

Outcome results

Primary

Number of Participants With Adhesion Reformation (American Fertility Society Score of Greater Than 0) 8 Weeks Later After the Index Surgery

The American Fertility Society (AFS) score ranges from 0-12, while represented the severity of the adhesions. Mild 1-4, Moderate 5-8, Severe 9-12. The lower the AFS score is, the better the prognosis the patient is. When the surgery was finished the AFS score should be 0. The reformation of intrauterine adhesions was evaluated by third-look hysteroscopy, if the score was greater than 0, a adhesion reformation was considered.

Time frame: at 8 weeks post-operation

Population: Intention-to-treat analysis was conducted on all outcomes.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
IUB Dilatation TherapyNumber of Participants With Adhesion Reformation (American Fertility Society Score of Greater Than 0) 8 Weeks Later After the Index Surgery21 Participants
Control GroupNumber of Participants With Adhesion Reformation (American Fertility Society Score of Greater Than 0) 8 Weeks Later After the Index Surgery38 Participants
Comparison: 200 patients were eligible and randomised in a 1:1 fashion. 9 patients did not complete the full protocol, resulting in 94 cases in the balloon group and 97 cases in the control group included in the final analysis. Intention-to-treat analysis was conducted.The null hypothesis is the percentage of the patients with reformed uterine adhesion in balloon group will less than the percentage of the patients with reformed uterine adhesion in control group. A Chi-squared analysis was used.p-value: 0.012Chi-squared
Primary

Pictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart Score 8 Weeks After Operation

The Pictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart (PBAC) score was used to represent the menstrual flow volume of the patient. The PBAC score was evaluated again at 8 weeks after surgery. A higher PBAC score after hysteroscopic adhesiolysis means a better outcome.The PBAC score of a normal women usually range from 30-100 points. The minium value of PBAC score is 0, which means the patient is amenorrhea. The maximum value of PBAC score is 1000. We measured the score before and 8 weeks after the operation in order to assess if there was any improvement (higher than before) in menstrual flow.

Time frame: at 8 weeks post-operation

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IUB Dilatation TherapyPictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart Score 8 Weeks After Operation51.3 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 7.5
Control GroupPictorial Blood Loss Assessment Chart Score 8 Weeks After Operation31.6 score on a scaleStandard Deviation 8.1
p-value: <0.001t-test, 2 sided
Primary

The American Fertility Society Score 8 Weeks After Operation

The American Fertility Society(AFS) score of each group was evaluated again at third-look hysteroscopy in order to reflect the efficacy of the treatment. The original AFS score was recorded in baseline characteristics part. The AFS score ranges from 0-12, while represented the severity of the adhesions. Mild 1-4, Moderate 5-8, Severe 9-12. The lower the AFS score is, the better the prognosis the patient is. When the surgery was finished the AFS score score should be 0.

Time frame: at 8 weeks post-operation

Population: The AFS score of each group was evaluated again after the whole procedure in order to reflect the efficacy of the treatment.

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
IUB Dilatation TherapyThe American Fertility Society Score 8 Weeks After Operation0 score on a scale
Control GroupThe American Fertility Society Score 8 Weeks After Operation2 score on a scale
p-value: <0.001Wilcoxon (Mann-Whitney)
Secondary

Pregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopy

number of patients who have pregnancy, miscarriage and ectopic pregnancy within12 months follow-up

Time frame: within 12 months after third look hysteroscopy(8 weeks post-operation)

ArmMeasureGroupValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
IUB Dilatation TherapyPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of pregnancy27 Participants
IUB Dilatation TherapyPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of live birth and ongoing pregnancy18 Participants
IUB Dilatation TherapyPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of patients have miscarriage8 Participants
IUB Dilatation TherapyPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of patients have ectopic pregnancy1 Participants
Control GroupPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of patients have ectopic pregnancy1 Participants
Control GroupPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of pregnancy26 Participants
Control GroupPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of patients have miscarriage9 Participants
Control GroupPregnancy Outcome Within 12 Months Follow-up After Third Look Hysteroscopynumber of live birth and ongoing pregnancy16 Participants
p-value: >0.05Chi-squared

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026