Skip to content

Ambu®AuraGain™ Versus I-gel® in Obese Patients

Prospective Randomized Comparison Between a Fiber Optic Intubation Via the Ambu® AuraGain ™ or the i-Gel® Laryngeal Mask Until a Complete Airway Protection in Obese Patients

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT03110393
Enrollment
44
Registered
2017-04-12
Start date
2017-04-20
Completion date
2017-09-06
Last updated
2018-01-08

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Obese

Keywords

Obese, Laryngeal Mask Airway, Anaesthesia

Brief summary

The aim of this study is the randomized comparison of two laryngeal mask (Intersurgical i-gel® and Ambu®AuraGain™) in obese patients

Detailed description

Since the incidence of a difficult intubation lies between 4.5% -7.5%, the search for alternative airway devices has been forced in the past. As an option, the laryngeal mask is suitable, which has been used as a universal airway with a high degree of safety in routine anesthesia. There are numbers of different laryngeal masks available which have the characteristic to insert an endotracheal tube through the ventilation lumen. The indications for these laryngeal masks can be extended due to continuous improvements in the laryngeal masks, these laryngeal masks can also be used in obese patients. Obese patients generally have a 4-fold increased risk of a difficult airway, and a BMI over 35 is a predictor of a difficult tracheal intubation. There are no studies comparing the Intersurgical i-gel® Laryngeal Mask and the Ambu®AuraGain ™ Laryngeal Mask in obese patients.

Interventions

Insert and intubation of an Ambu® AuraGain™ laryngeal mask

DEVICEIntersurgical i-gel

Insert and intubation of an Intersurgical i-gel®

Sponsors

Schulthess Klinik
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 70 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

* ASA 1-3 * Shoulder-/Elbow-/Hip-/Knee- or Foot - Surgery * Signed informed consent * BMI \> 35kg/m2

Exclusion criteria

* Non-sober patients (last meal \<6 h) * Symptomatic reflux disease * Hiatus hernia * Significant cardiovascular risk factors * Severe COPD * Gastric band or gastric bypass * Disease which allows an accurate examination of the physicians (e.g. neuromuscular, mental, metabolic disease) * Drug or drug abuse in the recent past * Legal immaturity (incompetence) * Acute disease, which calls into question the narcotic potential * Patients with whom the use of a laryngeal mask is contraindicated or otherwise not possible

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Time of successful intubationintraoperativeMeasurement of a fiberoptic intubation with the laryngeal mask. Start: Insertion of the fiberoptic into the larynxmask until the intubation has been done and after the fiberoptic has been removed.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Time of insertionintraoperativeThe time of Insertion of the laryngeal mask will be recorded.
Number of insertion attemptsintraoperativeNumber of insertions with the stomach tube will be registered
Gastric volumeintraoperativeMeasurement of the gastric volume
Positioning of the gastric probeintraoperativeDetermination of the position of the gastric probe after successful insertion by stethoscope.
Successful VentilationintraoperativeDetection of a successful Ventilation. There are two options: a tidal volume \> 6mL/kg lean body mass or endtidal pCO2 \< 6.7kPa
Oropharyngeal leak pressure of the Ambu®AuraGain ™intraoperativeThe oropharyngeal leak pressure of the AuraGain™ is measured with a measured cuff volume of 60cmH2O
Oropharyngeal leak pressure of the Intersurgical i-gel®intraoperativeThe oropharyngeal leak pressure of the Intersurgical i-gel® is measured.
Measurement of blood pressureintraoperativeMeasurement of blood pressure during 5min (1 measurement / minute).
Measurement of oxygen saturationintraoperativeMeasurement oxygen saturation during 5min (1 measurement / minute).
Measurement of heart rateintraoperativeMeasurement of heart rate during 5min (1 measurement / minute).
Number of Insertions (of the laryngeal mask)intraoperativeNumber of insertion attempts will be registered
Measurement CO2 (kPa):intraoperativeThe exhaled CO2 is determined continuously.
Number of intubation attemptsintraoperativeThe number of intubation attempts until successful intubation is recorded.
Reasons for the unsuccessful intubationintraoperativeThe reasons are listed in tabular form.
Number of esophageal intubationsintraoperativeThe number of esophageal intubations is measured.
Resistance (for an EET):intraoperativeThe resistance is measured with a score of 1- 4. 1: simple passage, no resistance, 2: little resistance for the passage, 3: significant resistance for the passage, 4: passage not possible
Location of the mask (Brimacombe)intraoperativeThe position of the mask is determined by pushing the fiber optic to a maximum of 1cm over the LMA and then using the Brimacombe score.
Swallowing (no / little / medium / strong)5hour postoperativeThe swallowing difficulties are questioned preoperatively and postoperatively (5 (± 1) h after anesthesia end).
Throat pain (no / little / medium / strong)5hour postoperativeThe throat pain is questioned preoperatively and postoperatively (5 (± 1) h after anesthesia end).
Hoarseness (no / little / medium / strong)5hour postoperativeThe swallowing difficulties, the throat pain and the hoarseness are questioned preoperatively and postoperatively (5 (± 1) h after anesthesia end).
Blood on laryngeal mask after intubationintraoperativeDetermination of the visible blood on the laryngeal mask after removal (no, little, much).
Maximum ventilation pressureintraoperativeThe maximum ventilation pressure is measured, which must be applied in order to adequately ventilate the patients. This is measured over 5 minutes

Countries

Switzerland

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026