Sexually Transmitted Infections
Conditions
Keywords
female entertainment worker, heterosexual men, entertainment establishment, condom use, sexually transmitted infection, Singapore
Brief summary
The investigators aim to assess the efficacy of a multi-component intervention on condom use and sexually transmitted infection (STIs) in female entertainment workers and men frequenting entertainment establishments (EEs), using a quasi-experimental design. Joo Chiat and Golden Mile Complex will be selected purposively as control cluster sites (n=220) with follow-up of entertainment workers at 6 weeks. The same sites will be used as intervention sites after a 3-months 'wash out' period. Self-reported condom use, vaginal swab samples for polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for cervical gonorrhoea and chlamydia infections, and throat swabs for culture for pharyngeal gonorrhoea will be assessed. Clark Quay will be the intervention venue for the heterosexual men while Tanjong Pagar will be the equivalent control site. Using time location sampling, cross-sectional samples of men patronising these establishments will be assessed on self-reported condom use at baseline (n=600) and 6 months after the intervention (n=400) in both intervention and control groups.
Detailed description
BACKGROUND: Globalisation has led to an influx of women from surrounding Asian countries with high prevalence of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) to work in entertainment establishments (EEs) in Singapore. Men frequenting EEs reported high levels of unprotected sex with commercial and casual partners. OBJECTIVES: The aim is to assess the efficacy of a multi-component intervention on STI prevention and condom use in female entertainment workers and men frequenting EEs in Singapore, using a quasi-experimental design. The hypothesis is that a comprehensive sexual health promotion program which incorporates behavioural (STI/HIV education, condom use and condom negotiation skills), biomedical (STI screening and treatment services) and structural components (free access to condoms) to female entertainment workers as well as behavioural (sexual well-being and safe sex edutainment) and structural (free access to condoms) interventions to men patronising EEs in Singapore will achieve an increase in condom use (for both target groups) and a reduction in incident STIs (only for female EE workers). METHODS: Female EE workers: Joo Chiat and Golden Mile Complex will be selected purposively as control cluster sites with 220 entertainment workers being recruited and followed up at 6 weeks. The same sites will be used as intervention sites with recruitment of a separate sample of 220 participants after a 3-months' 'wash out' period to ensure comparability. Self-reported condom use, vaginal swab samples for polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for cervical gonorrhoea and chlamydia infections, and throat swabs for culture for pharyngeal gonorrhoea will be assessed. The short follow-up period is because almost all of these women come to Singapore to work illegally on 1 to 2 months social visit passes. Heterosexual men: The investigators are unable to recruit heterosexual men from the same study sites of the female EE workers due to feasibility and safety considerations. Instead, Clark Quay will be selected purposively as the intervention site for the heterosexual men. Tanjong Pagar will be the equivalent control site. Using time location sampling, cross-sectional samples of men patronising these establishments will be assessed on self-reported condom use at baseline (n=600) and 6 months after the intervention (n=400) in both intervention and control groups. MAIN OUTCOMES: The primary outcomes for female EE workers are consistent condom use for vaginal sex with paid and casual partner respectively in the past 1 month and the secondary outcome is STI incidence. The primary outcomes for heterosexual men are condom use at last vaginal and oral sex respectively with casual partner in the past 6 months. POSSIBLE APPLICATIONS: The study will provide pertinent data for planning STI/HIV prevention programs for female entertainment workers and men patronising EEs in Singapore and the region.
Interventions
BEHAVIORALFemale entertainment worker intervention group
The following summarises the content of each session: Session 1 (on-site): The peer educator will play 2 videos, demonstrating 5 sexy ways of putting on a condom in a pleasurable manner, and another one focusing on condom negotiation skills. Session 2 (online): The peer educator will share an app game on condom usage and relevant online resources with the participants. Session 3 (onsite): There will be discussion of common problems encountered in condom usage and condom negotiation by the participants. The peer educators will then conduct role plays with the participants to demonstrate the counter-strategies. In addition, the peer educators will get the participants who have been successful in condom negotiation to share their success stories. Session 4 (online): The peer educator will share information about safe consumption of alcohol and tips to avoid getting drunk through the online platforms.
BEHAVIORALHeterosexual men intervention group
This will be delivered via 3 main activities: 1. Edutainment in the form of talk-shows based on 6 themes of sexual well-being and safe sex, held in the EE setting hosted by a famous female local comedian. 2. Web portal named THINK: This contains educational materials based on 6 themes of sexual health and safe sex, HIV risk profiling tool to calculate the risk of contracting HIV, videos on true life experiences of heterosexual men engaging in high risk sexual behaviour and another video on exit strategies to avoid casual or paid sex, online support for STI testing services and consultation with a clinical sexologist. 3. Public education event/photo booth: i. Distribution of pamphlets and brochures on sexual well-being and safe sex ii. Interactions with health promoters iii. Photo taking on safe sex messages iv. Free access to condoms and lubricants
Sponsors
Ministry of Health, Singapore
National Skin Centre, Singapore
National University of Singapore
Study design
Allocation
NON_RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
PREVENTION
Masking
SINGLE (Caregiver)
Eligibility
Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 69 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes
Inclusion criteria
For female EE workers: Female entertainment worker who is either a Vietnamese or Thai between the ages of 18 to 69 years old satisfying the 2 criteria: (i) Planning to work for at least 6 weeks after the baseline survey in Singapore (ii) Have engaged in vagina, oral or anal sex with either a casual or paid male partner in the past month The casual or paid male partner need not come from the EE that the female EE worker works in. For heterosexual men: Male resident who is either a Singapore Citizen or a Permanent Resident between the ages of 21 to 69 years satisfying the 2 criteria: (i) Patronise the EEs in the site at least once in the past 6 months (ii) Have engaged in vagina, oral or anal sex with either a casual or paid female partner in the past 6 months The casual or paid female partner need not come from the EEs in the site that the heterosexual man has patronised.
Exclusion criteria
For female EE workers in the intervention group only: Female EE workers who have participated in the control group would be excluded from participating in the intervention group For heterosexual men during the post-intervention survey of the control group only: Heterosexual men from the control site who have patronised EEs in the intervention site or who have been exposed to the interventions in the past 6 months would be excluded from the post-intervention survey for the control group. For heterosexual men during the post-intervention survey of the intervention group only: Heterosexual men from the intervention site who have not been exposed to at least 1 of the 3 main activities of the intervention in the past 6 months would be excluded from the post-intervention survey for the intervention group.
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Consistent condom use for vaginal sex with paid partners (for female entertainment workers) | 1 month | This is assessed by 2 questions, Did the participant ever have vaginal sex in the past 1 month? (Options of no and yes) and If the participant had vaginal sex, how often did she use condoms with paid partners? (Options of not applicable, never, sometimes and always). Participants who give the answer as 'Yes' to the first question and 'Always' to the second question are classified as having consistent condom usage for vaginal sex with paid partners. |
| Consistent condom use for vaginal sex with casual partners (for female entertainment workers) | 1 month | This is assessed by 2 questions, Did the participant ever have vaginal sex in the past 1 month? (Options of no and yes) and If the participant had vaginal sex, how often did she use condoms with casual partners? (Options of not applicable, never, sometimes and always). Participants who give the answer as 'Yes' to the first question and 'Always' to the second question are classified as having consistent condom usage for vaginal sex with causal partners. |
| Condom use at last vaginal sex with casual partners (for heterosexual men) | 6 months | This is determined by 2 questions, Did the participant ever have vaginal sex in the past 6 months? (Options of no and yes) and If the participant had vaginal sex, did he use a condom the last time he had vaginal sex with the casual partner? (Options of not applicable, no and yes). Participants who give the answer as 'Yes' to the first question and 'Yes' to the second question are classified as having used condom at last vaginal sex with casual partners. |
| Condom use at last oral sex with casual partners (for heterosexual men) | 6 months | This is determined by 2 questions, Did the participant ever have oral sex in the past 6 months? (Options of no and yes) and If the participant had oral sex, did he use a condom the last time he had oral sex with the casual partner? (Options of not applicable, no and yes). Participants who give the answer as 'Yes' to the first question and 'Yes' to the second question are classified as having used condom at last oral sex with casual partners. |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| HIV knowledge (for both target groups) | 1 month for female entertainment workers and 6 months for heterosexual men | — |
| Success in condom negotiation (for female entertainment workers) | 1 month | — |
| Number of sexual partners (for both target groups) | 1 month for female entertainment workers and 6 months for heterosexual men | — |
| STI incidence (for female entertainment workers) | 6 weeks | This is defined as having a positive laboratory test result for a new episode of cervical chlamydia, cervical gonorrhoea or pharyngeal gonorrhoea at 6 weeks post-intervention. |
| Consistent and last condom use with regular partners (for both target groups) | 1 month for female entertainment workers and 6 months for heterosexual men | — |
| Consistent condom use for oral sex with casual partners (for heterosexual men) | 6 months | — |
| Consistent and last condom use with female entertainment workers (for heterosexual men) | 6 months | — |
| HIV/STI testing uptake (for heterosexual men) | 6 months | — |
| Consistent condom use for oral sex with paid partners (for female entertainment workers) | 1 month | — |
| Consistent condom use for oral sex with casual partners (for female entertainment workers) | 1 month | — |
| Consistent condom use for vaginal sex with casual partners (for heterosexual men) | 6 months | — |
Countries
Singapore
Contacts
Primary ContactMee Lian Wong, MBBS, MPH, MD
Outcome results
None listed