Dental Caries
Conditions
Keywords
Caries, ICDAS, Lesion activity, Demineralisation, Imaging
Brief summary
This is a prospective, multi-centre, post-approval clinical study to assess the safety and the performance of the Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging System in aiding the identification of active caries lesions on the occlusal surfaces of human teeth. Following the identification of potential caries lesions by oral examination under ICDAS (International Caries Detection and Assessment System) guidelines, a disclosing solution will be applied which will cause areas of active demineralization (loss of calcium ions) to luminesce - these will be captured with an intra-oral camera to produce mapping images of the tooth surface. For the purposes of this study the presence / absence of luminescence will be used as an indicator of lesion activity / inactivity. The study will be deemed a success if the level of agreement between elevated luminescence with the Calcivis System, and areas of expected lesion activity as rated by the Investigators ICDAS staging, is above 70%, is not due to chance and correlates well with published data on active non-cavitated lesions in molars at various stages of eruption.
Detailed description
Dental caries (tooth decay) is a significant clinical and public health problem. The development of caries lesions involves a net mineral loss of dental tissue, which can lead to progressive loss of tooth structure surface, associated pain and disease. Detecting, assessing, diagnosing and treating such lesions are core activities in dentistry. Currently the main detection and diagnosis aids are visual inspection and the use of a probe, together with X-ray images. Determination of the activity status of a lesion (how likely it is to progress) is required to assess treatment needs. Currently methods are problematic and involve the clinician's subjective assessment and / or monitoring lesion progression over a number of visits. Therefore, this prospective, multi-centre, post-approval clinical study has been designed to assess the safety and performance of the Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging System in a clinical setting. The device under evaluation - the Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging System comprises a hand-held specialised intra-oral camera which takes images of the lesion on the tooth surface immediately before and after application of a disclosing solution which contains a photoprotein. This photoprotein will detect free calcium ions on the tooth surface and produces a visible light signal if the caries lesion is active. Patients attending routine dental appointments and / or patients on the dental practice register, who are identified by the Investigator as meeting all the study inclusion and exclusion criteria will be approached to discuss their possible participation in the study. Patients will be given a Patient Information Sheet to read and time to consider their participation. If they agree to participate, they will be asked to attend for two study visits, one week apart. Written informed consent will be taken before any study procedures are conducted. At Study Visit 1, pre-imaging demographics and oral hygiene information will be collected. All occlusal surfaces of the teeth (12 possible molars and pre-molars) will be cleaned by the Dentist, by brushing with dental paste and rinsing with tap water and using a 3-in-1 air / water spray, according to a Tooth Cleaning Protocol. The Dentist will then perform an oral examination identifying and noting the ICDAS score of each tooth to be imaged with the Calcivis System. Colour photographs will be taken with a standard intra-oral camera of each selected molar and surrounding mucosa. Each tooth selected for imaging will be air dried for 5 seconds immediately before application of the disclosing solution and imaging. Images of one sound tooth and one unrestored erupted, or erupting third molar with an ICDAS score of 1,2 or 3 will be imaged. An additional two teeth may be imaged (remaining erupted / erupting third molar and / or any other molar with an ICDAS score of 1,2 or 3), up to a maximum of four teeth. Immediately after imaging has been completed, patients rinse out with tap water and a second colour photograph will be taken with a standard intra-oral camera of each selected molar and surrounding mucosa. Any adverse events will be recorded. Post-imaging Questionnaires will be completed by all patients at the end of Study Visit 1, and User Questionnaires will be completed at the end of each Study Visit day. Patients will return after one week for Study Visit 2. At this visit, a final oral examination will be conducted and colour will be taken with a standard intra-oral camera of each selected molar and surrounding mucosa. Any adverse events observed or volunteered by the patient will be recorded. At the end of either Study Visit 1 or 2, the Dentist may share the images of the teeth imaged with the Calcivis System with the patient.
Interventions
Teeth imaged with the Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging System
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
1. Patient must be 16 to 25 years old 2. Patient must have at least one unrestored molar identified as sound according to the ICDAS coding system 3. Patient must have at least one unrestored erupting (in which case occlusal surface must be such that, apart from minimal presence of an operculum over the distal marginal ridge, it is clear of the gingivae (gum)) or erupted third molar with a caries lesion identified, coded 1, 2 or 3 (according to the ICDAS coding system) 4. Patient must be willing and able to give written informed consent 5. Patient must be willing and able to adhere to study schedule
Exclusion criteria
1. Recent tooth bleaching (within previous two weeks of imaging with the Calcivis System) 2. On-going re-mineralisation treatment including, but not limited to high concentration prescription fluoride toothpaste 3. Any patient with a fixed orthodontic appliance 4. Any patient currently taking part in a clinical research study, or has taken part in a clinical research study in the previous three months 5. Pregnant and / or nursing mothers
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage Agreement of Sound/Unsound Teeth Between ICDAS Score and Calcivis System | Day 0 | % agreement calculated as no. of teeth where ICDAS assessment & Calcivis System assessment is in agreement/total number of teeth assessed multiplied by 100. Agreement defined as a sound tooth without luminescence & an unsound tooth with luminescence. |
| Measure Safety of the Calcivis Caries Imaging System | Day 0 and Day 7 | Collection of all adverse events recorded and reported throughout the duration of the study |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Patient Experience | Day 0 | Completion of Patient Questionnaires after imaging with the Calcivis System |
| User Experience | 0 day | Completion of User Questionnaires after imaging with the Calcivis System |
Countries
United Kingdom
Participant flow
Recruitment details
A total of 42 Patients were recruited to the study from three UK General Dental Practices by four investigators. All 42 patients attended both Visit 1 and 2 and completed the study. There were no patient withdrawals. Patients were recruited at the three sites over an 8 month period from May 2014 to January 2015.
Participants by arm
| Arm | Count |
|---|---|
| Sound and Unsound Molars Imaging of unrestored sound molars (ICDAS 0) and third Molars (ICDAS 1,2 or 3) with the Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging Device
Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging System: Unrestored sound molars and unsound molars imaged with the Calcivis Caries Activity Imaging System | 42 |
| Total | 42 |
Baseline characteristics
| Characteristic | Sound and Unsound Molars |
|---|---|
| Age, Continuous | 21.7 years |
| Race/Ethnicity, Customized Asian | 0 participants |
| Race/Ethnicity, Customized Black African | 0 participants |
| Race/Ethnicity, Customized Caucasian | 42 participants |
| Race/Ethnicity, Customized Hispanic | 0 participants |
| Race/Ethnicity, Customized Other | 0 participants |
| Region of Enrollment United Kingdom | 42 participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Female | 20 Participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Male | 22 Participants |
Adverse events
| Event type | EG000 affected / at risk |
|---|---|
| deaths Total, all-cause mortality | — / — |
| other Total, other adverse events | 2 / 42 |
| serious Total, serious adverse events | 0 / 42 |
Outcome results
Measure Safety of the Calcivis Caries Imaging System
Collection of all adverse events recorded and reported throughout the duration of the study
Time frame: Day 0 and Day 7
Population: Adverse events
| Arm | Measure | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Measure Safety of the Calcivis Caries Imaging System | 2 adverse events |
Percentage Agreement of Sound/Unsound Teeth Between ICDAS Score and Calcivis System
% agreement calculated as no. of teeth where ICDAS assessment & Calcivis System assessment is in agreement/total number of teeth assessed multiplied by 100. Agreement defined as a sound tooth without luminescence & an unsound tooth with luminescence.
Time frame: Day 0
Population: All 42 patients recruited are included in the Safety Population, which included any subjects on whom the Calcivis System was used. 31 patients are included in the Agreement Population which included all subjects with at least one tooth with an eligible image. From the 31 patients, 65 teeth were analysed; in some patients multiple teeth were imaged.
| Arm | Measure | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Percentage Agreement of Sound/Unsound Teeth Between ICDAS Score and Calcivis System | 72.3 percentage agreement |
Patient Experience
Completion of Patient Questionnaires after imaging with the Calcivis System
Time frame: Day 0
Population: Patient Questionnaires comprised five questions and the patient was asked to tick the most appropriate response i.e very good, good etc. No numerical values were assigned to the responses
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any discomfort from Calcivis System use: marked | 1 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any discomfort from Calcivis System use:severe | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any discomfort with Calcivis System: not recorded | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Overall experience with Calcivis System:very good | 30 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Overall experience with Calcivis System:good | 9 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Overall exp. with Calcivis System: not good or bad | 2 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Overall experience with Calcivis System: bad | 1 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Overall experience with Calcivis System: very bad | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Overall exp. with Calcivis system: not recorded | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Image review with Dentist: very helpful | 21 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Image review with Dentist:Helpful | 16 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Image review with Dentist:not helpful or unhelpful | 2 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Image review with dentist: unhelpful | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Image review with Dentist: very unhelpful | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Image review with Dentist: not recorded | 3 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any pain from Calcivis System use: none | 34 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any pain from Calcivis System use: slight | 5 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any pain from Calcivis System Use: moderate | 2 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any pain from Calcivis System use: marked | 1 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any pain from Calcivis System use: severe | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any pain from Calcivis System use: not recorded | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any discomfort from Calvisi System use: none | 23 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any discomfort from Calcivis System use: minor | 17 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Any discomfort from Calcivis System use: moderate | 1 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Allow Calcivis System use in future: very happy | 35 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Allow Calcivis System use in furture: probably | 7 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Allow Calcivis System use in future: not sure | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Allow Calcivis System use in future: possibly | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Allow Calcivis System use in future: not allow | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | Patient Experience | Allow Calcivis System use in future: not recorded | 0 Patient Questionnaires |
User Experience
Completion of User Questionnaires after imaging with the Calcivis System
Time frame: 0 day
Population: User Questionnaires comprised nine questions and users were asked to tick the most appropriate response i.e. extremely easy, easy etc. No numerical values were assigned to the responses.
| Arm | Measure | Group | Value (NUMBER) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Disclsoing Solution prep.extremely difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of cleaning device:extremely easy | 15 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Calcivis System software use:extremely easy | 4 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Calcivis System software use:somewhat easy | 10 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Calcivis System software use:not easy or difficult | 2 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Calcivis System software use:somewhat difficult | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Calcivis System software use:extremely difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Calcivis System software use:not recorded | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Disclosing Solution preparation:extremely easy | 6 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Disclosing Solution preparation:somewhat easy | 7 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Disclosing Solution prep:not easy or difficult | 3 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Disclosing Solution prep:somewhat difficult | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Disclosing Solution prep:not recorded | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Syringe loading & fit applicator:extremely easy | 6 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Syringe loading & fit applicator: somewhat easy | 9 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Syringe load & fit applicator:not easy ordifficult | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Syringe load & fit applicator:somewhat difficult | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Syringe load & fit applicator:extremely difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Syring load & fit applicator:not recorded | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Device priming: extremely easy | 7 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Device priming: somewhat easy | 10 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Device priming: neither easy or difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Device priming: somewhat difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Device priming: extremely difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Device priming: not recorded | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of use of the device: extremely easy | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of use of the device:somwehat easy | 5 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of use of the device: not easy or difficult | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of use of the device: somewhat difficult | 6 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of use of the device: extremely difficult | 3 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of use of the device: not recorded | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Removal of applicator from device:extremeley easy | 12 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Removal of appliator from device: somewhat easy | 4 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Removal of applicator:not easy or difficult | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Removal of applicator:somewhat difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Removal of applicator:extremely difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Removal of applicator: not recorded | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of cleaning device:somewhat easy | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of cleaning device:not easy or difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of cleanig device:somewhat difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of cleaning device:extremely difficult | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Ease of cleaning device:not recorded | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Overall experience with Calcivis System:very good | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Overall experience with Calcivis System:good | 11 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Overall exp. with CS:not good or unsatisfactory | 2 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Overall exp. with CS:unsatisfactory | 2 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Overall exp.withCalcivis System:veryunsatisfactor | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Overall exp. with Calcivis System:not recorded | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Were IFU sufficient to understand:sufficient | 14 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Were IFU sufficient:somewhat sufficient | 1 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Were IFU sufficient:not sufficient or insufficient | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Were IFU sufficient:somewhat insufficient | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Were IFU sufficient to understand:insufficient | 0 User questionnaires |
| Sound and Unsound Molars | User Experience | Were IFU sufficient to understand:not recorded | 2 User questionnaires |