Skip to content

Impact of Oral Antibiotic Treatment on C. Difficile

Exploratory Study of Impact of Oral Metronidazole, Vancomycin and Fidaxomicin on the Extent and Quantity of Host Carriage and Environmental Contamination With C. Difficile

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 4
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT02057198
Acronym
C-Diff
Enrollment
33
Registered
2014-02-06
Start date
2014-06-10
Completion date
2017-06-27
Last updated
2019-10-02

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

C. Difficile, Diarrhea, Enterocolitis

Brief summary

The overall aim is to characterize and to compare the extent and quantity of C. difficile stool shedding, perianal colonization and environmental contamination in patients who received oral fidaxomicin, oral metronidazole, or oral vancomycin. This is a prospective, randomized, microbiologic and molecular, study of environmental contamination from patients with proven C. difficile associated diarrhea (CDAD).

Detailed description

Background and Significance: C. difficile has emerged as one of the most important pathogens that threaten the health and quality of life for many populations. Data from different studies clearly indicate that shedding of viable spores and subsequent contamination of environmental surfaces play an important role in the transmission of C. difficile. We aim to perform an analysis of the impact of different oral antibiotic therapy on microbiologic kinetics in patients with C. difficile diarrhea, such as: shedding, colonization and environmental contamination. We believe data from this study can inform whether drug therapies may be used to interrupt disease transmission and to improve the infection control of C. difficile. Purpose of the Study: The purposes of this study are to 1) determine the impact of oral fidaxomicin, oral metronidazole and oral vancomycin on the baseline and the temporal variation of C. difficile isolated from specific body sites of a patient with microbiology-proven CDAD and 2) determine the impact of oral fidaxomicin, oral metronidazole and oral vancomycin on the baseline and the temporal variation of C. difficile isolated from targeted surfaces in a hospital room. , More specifically, we will establish the extent and quantity of C. difficile shedding, colonization and environmental contamination in patients who received oral fidaxomicin, oral metronidazole, or vancomycin and the duration that stool remains positive for C. difficile. This study will prospectively study the role of the environment in Healthcare Associated Infections (HAIs) in the modern healthcare setting and will specifically address many limitations of previous studies. The study will use modern diagnostic and molecular methods to describe the microbiologic characteristics and concordance of cultures from the environment and from patient, describe temporal variation and relationship in the microbiologic profiles of cultures obtained from the environment and from the patient, assess confounders such as hand hygiene and quality of cleaning, and provide longitudinal follow up for subsequent outcomes. This study will utilize microbiologic and molecular techniques to critically and prospectively examine the impact of the environmental bioburden on the risk of colonization and infection of hospitalized patients. Data from this study will provide novel, important information regarding the true impact of the hospital environment on the acquisition and spread of HAIs and Multi-Drug Resistant (MDR)-pathogens in hospitalized patients over time. As such, data collected in this study may provide important information about the mechanisms and relative frequency of how and when environmental sources of bacteria lead to colonization and infection in hospitalized patients. These data may in turn stimulate or justify the future development of novel preventive interventions. Design and Procedures/Study Interventions: This is a randomized, controlled study of patients with documented CDAD, defined as having polymerase chain reaction for C. difficile in a patient with more than 3 loose stools within 24 hours. Eligible patients for enrollment will be identified by microbiology-driven alerts or by orders for contact isolation for C. difficile. Study team will be alerted to approach the patient to provide information about the study and to obtain informed consent. This study will obtain microbiological cultures from 2 sources: 1) environmental surfaces in the room and 2) body surfaces of the patient at predefined intervals starting the day of enrol1ment. Cultures will be obtained on Day 1 (day of enrol1ment), Day 3 and Day 7 following admission to the room, at the end of each subsequent week (Day 14, Day 21, etc.), and on the day of discharge from the hospital room. Microbiological cultures will be obtained from the following body sites: perianal and stool specimens. Microbiological cultures will be obtained from 5 high-touch environmental surfaces as outlined in the protocol. Selection of Subjects: A total of 30 patients are anticipated to be enrolled in this study, 10 in each of the three treatment arms. Patients will be block-randomized to receive one of the three antibiotic treatments for CDAD described above. The study will enroll 10 patients receiving metronidazole therapy, 10 patients receiving oral vancomycin therapy and 10 patients receiving oral fidaxomicin therapy. As soon as the PI or study coordinator finds that a patient has a positive C. difficile result, the primary care provider (PCP) in hospital will be contacted to discuss the patient. If the PCP agrees to allow potential enrollment, the PCP will introduce the study to the patient. If the patient indicates willingness to participate, the PI or study coordinator will be introduced by the PCP or another caregiver known to the patient. The informed consent process will take place if the patient is interested in participating. The patient will be enrolled as a study subject if all eligibility criteria are met. The PCP will formally prescribe fidaxomicin, metronidazole or vancomycin following randomization. Fidaxomicin will be supplied by the study sponsor. Metronidazole and vancomycin will not be supplied by the sponsor. If the subject is randomized to receive fidaxomicin, the PI or study coordinator will notify the Duke Investigational Drug Service (IDS) that a subject is enrolling and will order this drug through the IDS. As soon as the 10th subject who is prescribed fidaxomicin enrolls, then enrollment will be closed to patients prescribed fidaxomicin. Enrollment will be closed to subjects taking metronidazole and vancomycin as soon as the 10th subject in each group is enrolled. The subject will begin treatment with the medication prescribed by the PCP in hospital. No compensation is being offered for participation in this study. Consent Process: The consent process will be conducted by a study coordinator or the principal investigator. This will typically occur in the patient's hospital room.. Subject's Capacity to Give Legally Effective Consent: Subjects will need to be able to give consent to participate in this study. Risk/Benefit Assessment: The risks are minimal for this study. First, patients may experience adverse effects from the antibiotics that they consent to receive. Each of three agents is recommended for the treatment of CDAD. Second, the microbiological samples that will be taken may cause some discomfort and minor bleeding which will be discussed with the patient during the consenting process. Declining to participate in the study will not affect the clinical care of the patient. Results of study specimens will not be analyzed in real-time and will not be sent back to clinicians. SAEs are not anticipated for this study. Any standard SAE events that may occur will be reported to the manufacturer and to the IRB. There is no direct benefit to the patient in the study. The sponsor will supply Fidaxomicin if this is prescribed for a patient enrolled in the study. The data from this study may prompt future studies that examine the use oral antibiotics to reduce the transmissibility of C. difficile. Data Analysis and Statistical Considerations: Descriptive statistics will be used to correlate culture results from the environment and the patient. Data and Safety Monitoring: PI will review and sign off on all adverse events or problems as they occur and will submit reports of such events to the IRB in accordance with HRPP policies and to the sponsor in accordance with the protocol. Privacy, Data Storage and Confidentiality: Privacy during swabbing shall be maintained by swabbing the patient in the patient's room with the door closed as would be appropriate for other patient care, using Universal Precautions. To ensure privacy the patient and environmental samples will use an automatically generated ID and room number in place of name, MRN or other personal identifiers. Data collected by the study will be entered into secure Access databases. All connections to the system, both external and internal, occur over encrypted channels. Access to components of the system is role-based and can only be granted by administrators of the system. All collected information is stored on a server hosted by Duke Medicine.

Interventions

DRUGFidaxomicin
DRUGMetronidazole
DRUGVancomycin

Sponsors

Duke University
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* adult patients with microbiology-proven CDAD * provides informed consent * eligible to receive oral antibiotic therapy

Exclusion criteria

* prisoners * pregnant women * children \<18 years * patients who have contra-indications for perianal swabs, those who has medical conditions that would invalidate the results of the swabs * patients requiring intravenous therapy for treatment of CDAD * patients who do not consent and those who withdraw consent

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Change in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Days 0, 3, 7 and 14.Rodac plates were used to take environmental samples from 5 different sites within each patient's hospital room (bedrail, overbed table, sink, toilet seat, bathroom floor). Each Rodac plate samples a surface area of \ 25 cm2. 5 replicates were taken for each site and repeated on days 0, 3, 7, and 14. Median total colony counts are reported for each treatment group. Data from the specified time points were combined to construct a decay slope, representing the reduction in log(CFUs)/day for each treatment group. We compared the slope (rate of change) between treatment groups using mixed effects models.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Total Environmental Contamination According to Antibiotic Treatment GroupDays 0, 3, 7, and 14In addition to total colony counts over time, the investigators also assessed the proportion of positive cultures over time (from the 5 replicate Rodac plate samplings repeated at each of 5 sites within each patient room: bedrail, overbed table, sink, toilet seat and bathroom floor). The cumulative proportion of positive cultures (including days 0, 3, 7, 14) is reported according to each treatment group.
Molecular Relatedness of IsolatesDays 0-14When sufficient growth was available to permit sub-culture and ribotyping, we conducted ribotyping of each patient's stool C. difficile isolate for comparison to isolates from the same patient's hospital environment. Reported is the total percent of hospital room environmental isolates that match the ribotyping of the associated patient's stool sample (there is no averaging).
C. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDays 0, 3, 7, 14C. difficile was isolated and serially diluted to permit colony counts (CFU/g stool) over time for each patient.
Count of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDays 0, 3, 7, 14Count of stool cultures positive for C. difficile at each time point
Percentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDays 0, 3, 7, 14Percentage of stool cultures positive for C. difficile at each time point

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Fidaxomicin
200 mg. 2 times a day for 10 days Fidaxomicin
11
Metronidazole
500 mg.orally 3 times daily for 10 days Metronidazole
10
Vancomycin
125 mg. orally 4 times a day for 10 days Vancomycin
10
Total31

Withdrawals & dropouts

PeriodReasonFG000FG001FG002
Overall StudyDeath001
Overall StudyDischarged early; lost to followup010

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicFidaxomicinTotalVancomycinMetronidazole
Age, Continuous60.6 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 22
62 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 16.1
63.4 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.6
62.2 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 15.1
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Hispanic or Latino
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Not Hispanic or Latino
11 Participants31 Participants10 Participants10 Participants
Ethnicity (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
American Indian or Alaska Native
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Asian
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Black or African American
5 Participants14 Participants4 Participants5 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
More than one race
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
Unknown or Not Reported
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Race (NIH/OMB)
White
6 Participants17 Participants6 Participants5 Participants
Region of Enrollment
United States
11 participants31 participants10 participants10 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
4 Participants15 Participants5 Participants6 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
7 Participants16 Participants5 Participants4 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
EG002
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
2 / 110 / 102 / 10
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 110 / 100 / 10
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 110 / 100 / 10

Outcome results

Primary

Change in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.

Rodac plates were used to take environmental samples from 5 different sites within each patient's hospital room (bedrail, overbed table, sink, toilet seat, bathroom floor). Each Rodac plate samples a surface area of \ 25 cm2. 5 replicates were taken for each site and repeated on days 0, 3, 7, and 14. Median total colony counts are reported for each treatment group. Data from the specified time points were combined to construct a decay slope, representing the reduction in log(CFUs)/day for each treatment group. We compared the slope (rate of change) between treatment groups using mixed effects models.

Time frame: Days 0, 3, 7 and 14.

Population: Only completed participants were included in the analysis.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEDIAN)
FidaxomicinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 056 Colony forming units (CFUs)
FidaxomicinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 37 Colony forming units (CFUs)
FidaxomicinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 70 Colony forming units (CFUs)
FidaxomicinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 140 Colony forming units (CFUs)
MetronidazoleChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 140 Colony forming units (CFUs)
MetronidazoleChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 033 Colony forming units (CFUs)
MetronidazoleChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 715 Colony forming units (CFUs)
MetronidazoleChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 353 Colony forming units (CFUs)
VancomycinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 140 Colony forming units (CFUs)
VancomycinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 324 Colony forming units (CFUs)
VancomycinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 70 Colony forming units (CFUs)
VancomycinChange in Total Median Total Colony Forming Units (CFU) of C. Difficile Identified in the Hospital Room Environment for Each Antibiotic Treatment Group.Day 0149 Colony forming units (CFUs)
p-value: 0.5295% CI: [-0.34, 0.05]Mixed Models Analysis
p-value: 0.6695% CI: [-0.69, 0.35]Mixed Models Analysis
Secondary

C. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over Time

C. difficile was isolated and serially diluted to permit colony counts (CFU/g stool) over time for each patient.

Time frame: Days 0, 3, 7, 14

Population: Only completed participants were included in the analysis.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
FidaxomicinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 0815940 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 949503
FidaxomicinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 372200 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 156429
FidaxomicinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 70 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 0
FidaxomicinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 140 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 0
MetronidazoleC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 140 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 0
MetronidazoleC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 02233564 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 3845558
MetronidazoleC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 70 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 0
MetronidazoleC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 31200 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 283
VancomycinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 140 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 0
VancomycinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 3400 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 693
VancomycinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 70 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 0
VancomycinC. Difficile Shedding in Stool Over TimeDay 035340 CFU/g stoolStandard Deviation 41612
Comparison: Data from the specified time points were combined to construct a decay slope, representing the reduction in log(CFUs)/day for each treatment group. We compared the slope (rate of change) between treatment groups using mixed effects models. Data from the specified time points were combined to construct a decay slope, representing the reduction in log(CFUs)/day for each treatment group. We compared the slope (rate of change) between treatment groups using mixed effects models.p-value: 0.0595% CI: [-0.67, -0.19]Mixed Models Analysis
Comparison: Data from the specified time points were combined to construct a decay slope, representing the reduction in log(CFUs)/day for each treatment group. We compared the slope (rate of change) between treatment groups using mixed effects models. Data from the specified time points were combined to construct a decay slope, representing the reduction in log(CFUs)/day for each treatment group. We compared the slope (rate of change) between treatment groups using mixed effects models.p-value: 0.00295% CI: [-1.14, -0.57]Mixed Models Analysis
Secondary

Count of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. Difficile

Count of stool cultures positive for C. difficile at each time point

Time frame: Days 0, 3, 7, 14

Population: Only completed participants were included in the analysis.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (NUMBER)
FidaxomicinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 020 Number of positive stool cultures
FidaxomicinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 140 Number of positive stool cultures
FidaxomicinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 36 Number of positive stool cultures
FidaxomicinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 70 Number of positive stool cultures
MetronidazoleCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 33 Number of positive stool cultures
MetronidazoleCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 70 Number of positive stool cultures
MetronidazoleCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 140 Number of positive stool cultures
MetronidazoleCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 021 Number of positive stool cultures
VancomycinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 140 Number of positive stool cultures
VancomycinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 017 Number of positive stool cultures
VancomycinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 32 Number of positive stool cultures
VancomycinCount of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 70 Number of positive stool cultures
Secondary

Molecular Relatedness of Isolates

When sufficient growth was available to permit sub-culture and ribotyping, we conducted ribotyping of each patient's stool C. difficile isolate for comparison to isolates from the same patient's hospital environment. Reported is the total percent of hospital room environmental isolates that match the ribotyping of the associated patient's stool sample (there is no averaging).

Time frame: Days 0-14

Population: Ribotyping could only be conducted in instances where sufficient growth occurred from both patient and environmental samples to permit subculture.

ArmMeasureValue (NUMBER)
FidaxomicinMolecular Relatedness of Isolates68.1 percent of matching isolates
MetronidazoleMolecular Relatedness of Isolates80.0 percent of matching isolates
VancomycinMolecular Relatedness of Isolates77.8 percent of matching isolates
p-value: 0.99Chi square (2 proportion test)
p-value: 0.52Chi square (2 proportion test)
Secondary

Percentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. Difficile

Percentage of stool cultures positive for C. difficile at each time point

Time frame: Days 0, 3, 7, 14

Population: Only completed participants were included in the analysis.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (NUMBER)
FidaxomicinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 0100 % of positive stool cultures
FidaxomicinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 360 % of positive stool cultures
FidaxomicinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 70 % of positive stool cultures
FidaxomicinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 140 % of positive stool cultures
MetronidazolePercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 140 % of positive stool cultures
MetronidazolePercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 095.5 % of positive stool cultures
MetronidazolePercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 70 % of positive stool cultures
MetronidazolePercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 375 % of positive stool cultures
VancomycinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 140 % of positive stool cultures
VancomycinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 333 % of positive stool cultures
VancomycinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 70 % of positive stool cultures
VancomycinPercentage of Stool Specimens From Patients That Are Positive for C. DifficileDay 085 % of positive stool cultures
p-value: 0.48Chi square (two proportion test)
p-value: 0.66Chi square (two proportion test)
Secondary

Total Environmental Contamination According to Antibiotic Treatment Group

In addition to total colony counts over time, the investigators also assessed the proportion of positive cultures over time (from the 5 replicate Rodac plate samplings repeated at each of 5 sites within each patient room: bedrail, overbed table, sink, toilet seat and bathroom floor). The cumulative proportion of positive cultures (including days 0, 3, 7, 14) is reported according to each treatment group.

Time frame: Days 0, 3, 7, and 14

Population: Only completed participants were included in the analysis.

ArmMeasureValue (NUMBER)
FidaxomicinTotal Environmental Contamination According to Antibiotic Treatment Group13.4 percentage of positive cultures
MetronidazoleTotal Environmental Contamination According to Antibiotic Treatment Group18.6 percentage of positive cultures
VancomycinTotal Environmental Contamination According to Antibiotic Treatment Group7.6 percentage of positive cultures
p-value: <0.001Chi square (2 proportion test)
p-value: 0.01Chi square (2 proportion test)

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 21, 2026