Skip to content

Established Status Epilepticus Treatment Trial

A Multicenter, Randomized, Blinded, Comparative Effectiveness Study of Fosphenytoin, Valproic Acid, or Levetiracetam in the Emergency Department Treatment of Patients With Benzodiazepine-refractory Status Epilepticus.

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 3
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT01960075
Acronym
ESETT
Enrollment
478
Registered
2013-10-10
Start date
2015-10-31
Completion date
2019-05-31
Last updated
2021-06-14

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Benzodiazepine Refractory Status Epilepticus

Keywords

status epilepticus, refractory, benzodiazepine, fosphenytoin, levetiracetam, valproic acid

Brief summary

The primary objective is to determine the most effective and/or the least effective treatment of benzodiazepine-refractory status epilepticus (SE) among patients older than 2 years. There are three active treatment arms being compared: fosphenytoin (FOS),levetiracetam (LEV), and valproic acid (VPA). The second objective is comparison of three drugs with respect to secondary outcomes. The final objective is to ensure that the trial is informative for treatment of established SE in children by describing the effectiveness, safety, and rate of adverse reactions of these drugs in children.

Interventions

DRUGLevetiracetam
DRUGValproic acid

Sponsors

University of Michigan
CollaboratorOTHER
Medical University of South Carolina
CollaboratorOTHER
Children's National Research Institute
CollaboratorOTHER
University of Minnesota
CollaboratorOTHER
National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS)
CollaboratorNIH
University of Virginia
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
TRIPLE (Subject, Investigator, Outcomes Assessor)

Intervention model description

ESETT had 478 enrollments. They were 16 re-enrollers. This was an EFIC trial so all consents happened after treatment and all enrollments went through the same process of consent even if they were re-enrolled. Some information presented here only includes the first 400 patients since there was a prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped early for futility.

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
2 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

Patient witnessed to seize for greater than 5 minute duration prior to treatment with study drug; Patient received adequate dose of benzodiazepines. The last dose of a benzo was administered in the 5-30 minutes prior to study drug administration. The doses may be divided.; continued or recurring seizure in the Emergency Department; Age 2 years or older

Exclusion criteria

Known pregnancy; Prisoner; Opt-out identification; Treatment with a second line anticonvulsant (FOS, PHT, VPA, LEV, phenobarbital or other agents defined in the MoP) for this episode of SE; Treatment with sedatives with anticonvulsant properties other than benzodiazepines (propofol, etomidate, ketamine or other agents defined in the MoP); Endotracheal intubation; Acute traumatic brain injury; Known metabolic disorder; Known liver disease; Known severe renal impairment; Known allergy or other known contraindication to FOS, PHT, LEV, or VPA; Hypoglycemia \< 50 mg/dL; Hyperglycemia \> 400 mg/dL; Cardiac arrest and post-anoxic seizures

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Intention to TreatWithin 60 minutes after the start of study drug infusionDetermined by the absence of clinically apparent seizures and improving consciousness at 1 hour without other anticonvulsant medications. Intention to treat
Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Per-protocol AnalysisWithin 60 minutes after the start of study drug infusionDetermined by the absence of clinically apparent seizures and improving consciousness at 1 hour without other anticonvulsant medications. Per-protocol analysis
Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Adjudicated Outcomes AnalysisWithin 60 minutes after the start of study drug infusionDetermined by the absence of clinically apparent seizures and improving consciousness at 1 hour without other anticonvulsant medications. The Adjudicated outcomes analysis is different from Outcome measure 1 because a central clinical phenomenology core of four neurologists adjudicated from the medical records the time to seizure cessation, the time in status epilepticus before trial-drug initiation, and the cause of the seizure. For each enrollment, two neurologists from this core group conducted independent initial reviews and then determined a consensus or consulted a third adjudicator, as needed. Adjudicators were unaware of the treatment assignments and made determinations by medical record review.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Number of Participants With Seizure Cessation Within 20 Minutes for Patients With Treatment Successwithin 20 minutesNumber of participants with seizure cessation within 20 minutes of study drug initiation for patients with treatment success. This outcome measure was only reported in the Supplementary materials to the Primary Paper.
Number of Participants With Admission to Intensive Care UnitAdmission to intensive care unit after start of study drug infusion, where the ICU is the initial inpatient unit for the patientICU admission is recorded as occurring only if the ICU is the initial inpatient unit for the patient.
Length of Hospital Staylength of hospital stayLength of hospital stay in days
Length of ICU Staynumber of calendar days after the day of ED arrival until hospital discharge or subject end-of-studyLength of stay is determined by the number of calendar days after the day of ED arrival until hospital discharge or subject end-of-study.
Minutes From Start of Trial Drug Infusion to Termination of Seizures for Patients With Treatment Successstart of drug infusion to seizure cessationThe time to termination of seizures is the interval from the start of study drug infusion to cessation of clinically apparent seizure in those who meet the primary outcome.

Other

MeasureTime frameDescription
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life Threatening Hypotensionwithin 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusionLife-threatening hypotension within 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusion
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Seizure Recurrence60 minutes to 12 hours after start of study drug infusionacute seizure recurrence 60 minutes to 12 hours after start of study drug infusion
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life-threatening Cardiac Arrhythmiawithin 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusionLife-threatening cardiac arrhythmia within 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusion
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Endotracheal Intubationwithin 60 minutes of start of study drug infusionEndotracheal intubation within 60 minutes of start of study drug infusion
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Anaphylaxiswithin 6 hours of the start of study drug infusionsAcute anaphylaxis is defined as a clinical presentation consistent with life threatening allergic reaction occurring within 6 hours of the start of study drug infusions and manifested as urticaria in combination with either (1) a systolic blood pressure of \< 90 mmHg sustained for greater than 5 minutes, or (2) objective evidence of airway obstruction, and for which the patient was treated with antihistamines and/or steroids.
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Respiratory Depression24 hoursRespiratory depression is defined as impairment of ventilation or oxygenation necessitating definitive endotracheal intubation and mechanical ventilation. It is distinct from intubations performed only for airway protection in those with decreased levels of consciousness. It does not include those getting only supraglottic airways or transient bag-valve-mask support.
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Hepatic Transaminase or Ammonia Elevations24 hoursSafety outcome: Hepatic transaminase or ammonia elevations
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Purple Glove Syndrome24 hoursPurple glove syndrome is defined as the presence of all three of the findings of the objective edema: discoloration, and pain in the distal extremity in which study drug was administered, with or without known extravasation, and for which there is no other evident etiology.
Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Death30 daysSafety outcome: Death

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Recruitment details

ESETT had a total of 478 enrollments. This number includes 16 re-enrollers. This was an EFIC trial so all consents happened after treatment. All enrollments went through the same process of consent even if they were reenrolled. The first 400 patients were used in several parts of analyses since the trial stopped early for futility (prespecified).

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Fosphenytoin (FOS)
Administer 20 mg/Kg fosphenytoin intravenously up to a maximum dose of 1500 mg ( 75 Kg) over 10 minutes. Those weighing more than 75 Kg receive a fixed dose of 1500 fosphenytoin over 10 minutes. Fosphenytoin
118
Valproic Acid
Administer 40 mg/Kg valproic acid intravenously up to a maximum dose of 3000 mg (75 Kg) over 10 minutes. Those weighing more than 75 Kg receive a fixed dose of 3000 valproic acidover 10 minutes. Valproic acid
121
Levetiracetam
Administer 60 mg/Kg levetiracetam intravenously up to a maximum dose of 4500 mg ( 75 Kg) over 10 minutes. Those weighing more than 75 Kg receive a fixed dose of 4500 levetiracetam over 10 minutes. Levetiracetam
145
Total384

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicTotalFosphenytoin (FOS)Valproic AcidLevetiracetam
Age, Continuous32.8 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 25.6
32.8 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 25.4
32.2 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 25.4
33.3 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 26
Age, Customized
Age
0 - 5 yr
82 Participants24 Participants28 Participants30 Participants
Age, Customized
Age
11 - 20 yr
37 Participants10 Participants18 Participants9 Participants
Age, Customized
Age
21 - 40 yr
70 Participants20 Participants19 Participants31 Participants
Age, Customized
Age
41 - 60 yr
86 Participants26 Participants26 Participants34 Participants
Age, Customized
Age
6 - 10 yr
39 Participants15 Participants7 Participants17 Participants
Age, Customized
Age
=> 61 yr
70 Participants23 Participants23 Participants24 Participants
Final Diagnosis
Non-epileptic spell
37 Participants11 Participants13 Participants13 Participants
Final Diagnosis
Seizure/Status Epilepticus
334 Participants104 Participants102 Participants128 Participants
Final Diagnosis
Unable to adjudicate
13 Participants3 Participants6 Participants4 Participants
Prior history of epilepsy260 Participants80 Participants83 Participants97 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Hispanic Ethnicity
63 Participants18 Participants22 Participants23 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Race/Ethnicity
Black
165 Participants49 Participants54 Participants62 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Race/Ethnicity
Other, >1 race, or unknown
59 Participants20 Participants18 Participants21 Participants
Race/Ethnicity, Customized
Race/Ethnicity
White
160 Participants49 Participants49 Participants62 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
171 Participants47 Participants56 Participants68 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
213 Participants71 Participants65 Participants77 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
EG002
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
3 / 1252 / 1257 / 150
other
Total, other adverse events
28 / 12522 / 12525 / 150
serious
Total, serious adverse events
57 / 12546 / 12564 / 150

Outcome results

Primary

Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Adjudicated Outcomes Analysis

Determined by the absence of clinically apparent seizures and improving consciousness at 1 hour without other anticonvulsant medications. The Adjudicated outcomes analysis is different from Outcome measure 1 because a central clinical phenomenology core of four neurologists adjudicated from the medical records the time to seizure cessation, the time in status epilepticus before trial-drug initiation, and the cause of the seizure. For each enrollment, two neurologists from this core group conducted independent initial reviews and then determined a consensus or consulted a third adjudicator, as needed. Adjudicators were unaware of the treatment assignments and made determinations by medical record review.

Time frame: Within 60 minutes after the start of study drug infusion

Population: The difference from Participant Flow is because the total of 384 is from the first 400 patients and excludes 16 re-enrollers in the study. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Adjudicated Outcomes Analysis57 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Adjudicated Outcomes Analysis60 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Adjudicated Outcomes Analysis67 Participants
Primary

Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Intention to Treat

Determined by the absence of clinically apparent seizures and improving consciousness at 1 hour without other anticonvulsant medications. Intention to treat

Time frame: Within 60 minutes after the start of study drug infusion

Population: The difference from Participant Flow is because the total of 384 is from the first 400 patients and excludes 16 re-enrollers in the study. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Intention to Treat53 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Intention to Treat56 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Intention to Treat68 Participants
Primary

Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Per-protocol Analysis

Determined by the absence of clinically apparent seizures and improving consciousness at 1 hour without other anticonvulsant medications. Per-protocol analysis

Time frame: Within 60 minutes after the start of study drug infusion

Population: The analysis population for this outcome is the Per-protocol population, which is all patients who completed the study without major protocol deviations.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Per-protocol Analysis37 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Per-protocol Analysis43 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Clinical Cessation of Status Epilepticus - Per-protocol Analysis51 Participants
Secondary

Length of Hospital Stay

Length of hospital stay in days

Time frame: length of hospital stay

Population: The difference from Participant Flow is because the total of 384 is from the first 400 patients and excludes 16 re-enrollers in the study. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Length of Hospital Stay3 days
Valproic AcidLength of Hospital Stay3 days
LevetiracetamLength of Hospital Stay3 days
Secondary

Length of ICU Stay

Length of stay is determined by the number of calendar days after the day of ED arrival until hospital discharge or subject end-of-study.

Time frame: number of calendar days after the day of ED arrival until hospital discharge or subject end-of-study

Population: The difference from Participant Flow is because the total of 384 is from the first 400 patients and excludes 16 re-enrollers in the study. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Length of ICU Stay1 days
Valproic AcidLength of ICU Stay1 days
LevetiracetamLength of ICU Stay1 days
Secondary

Minutes From Start of Trial Drug Infusion to Termination of Seizures for Patients With Treatment Success

The time to termination of seizures is the interval from the start of study drug infusion to cessation of clinically apparent seizure in those who meet the primary outcome.

Time frame: start of drug infusion to seizure cessation

Population: The analysis population here is different than Participant Flow because it includes only the patients who had this data available. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Minutes From Start of Trial Drug Infusion to Termination of Seizures for Patients With Treatment Success11.7 minutes
Valproic AcidMinutes From Start of Trial Drug Infusion to Termination of Seizures for Patients With Treatment Success7.0 minutes
LevetiracetamMinutes From Start of Trial Drug Infusion to Termination of Seizures for Patients With Treatment Success10.5 minutes
Secondary

Number of Participants With Admission to Intensive Care Unit

ICU admission is recorded as occurring only if the ICU is the initial inpatient unit for the patient.

Time frame: Admission to intensive care unit after start of study drug infusion, where the ICU is the initial inpatient unit for the patient

Population: The difference from Participant Flow is because the total of 384 is from the first 400 patients and excludes 16 re-enrollers in the study. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Admission to Intensive Care Unit70 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Admission to Intensive Care Unit71 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Admission to Intensive Care Unit87 Participants
Secondary

Number of Participants With Seizure Cessation Within 20 Minutes for Patients With Treatment Success

Number of participants with seizure cessation within 20 minutes of study drug initiation for patients with treatment success. This outcome measure was only reported in the Supplementary materials to the Primary Paper.

Time frame: within 20 minutes

Population: The population is different than Participant flow because it is only those with treatment success. This outcome measure was only reported in the Supplementary materials to the Primary Paper.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Seizure Cessation Within 20 Minutes for Patients With Treatment Success43 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Seizure Cessation Within 20 Minutes for Patients With Treatment Success43 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Seizure Cessation Within 20 Minutes for Patients With Treatment Success53 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Anaphylaxis

Acute anaphylaxis is defined as a clinical presentation consistent with life threatening allergic reaction occurring within 6 hours of the start of study drug infusions and manifested as urticaria in combination with either (1) a systolic blood pressure of \< 90 mmHg sustained for greater than 5 minutes, or (2) objective evidence of airway obstruction, and for which the patient was treated with antihistamines and/or steroids.

Time frame: within 6 hours of the start of study drug infusions

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Anaphylaxis0 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Anaphylaxis0 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Anaphylaxis0 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Respiratory Depression

Respiratory depression is defined as impairment of ventilation or oxygenation necessitating definitive endotracheal intubation and mechanical ventilation. It is distinct from intubations performed only for airway protection in those with decreased levels of consciousness. It does not include those getting only supraglottic airways or transient bag-valve-mask support.

Time frame: 24 hours

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Respiratory Depression16 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Respiratory Depression10 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Respiratory Depression12 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Seizure Recurrence

acute seizure recurrence 60 minutes to 12 hours after start of study drug infusion

Time frame: 60 minutes to 12 hours after start of study drug infusion

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Seizure Recurrence14 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Seizure Recurrence14 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Acute Seizure Recurrence16 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Death

Safety outcome: Death

Time frame: 30 days

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Death3 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Death2 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Death7 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Endotracheal Intubation

Endotracheal intubation within 60 minutes of start of study drug infusion

Time frame: within 60 minutes of start of study drug infusion

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Endotracheal Intubation33 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Endotracheal Intubation21 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Endotracheal Intubation30 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Hepatic Transaminase or Ammonia Elevations

Safety outcome: Hepatic transaminase or ammonia elevations

Time frame: 24 hours

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Hepatic Transaminase or Ammonia Elevations0 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Hepatic Transaminase or Ammonia Elevations1 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Hepatic Transaminase or Ammonia Elevations1 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life-threatening Cardiac Arrhythmia

Life-threatening cardiac arrhythmia within 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusion

Time frame: within 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusion

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life-threatening Cardiac Arrhythmia0 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life-threatening Cardiac Arrhythmia0 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life-threatening Cardiac Arrhythmia1 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life Threatening Hypotension

Life-threatening hypotension within 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusion

Time frame: within 60 minutes of the start of study drug infusion

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life Threatening Hypotension4 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life Threatening Hypotension2 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Life Threatening Hypotension1 Participants
Other Pre-specified

Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Purple Glove Syndrome

Purple glove syndrome is defined as the presence of all three of the findings of the objective edema: discoloration, and pain in the distal extremity in which study drug was administered, with or without known extravasation, and for which there is no other evident etiology.

Time frame: 24 hours

Population: The first 400 patients were analyzed for this outcome. The first 400 patients were used because of the prespecified stopping rule and the trial stopped for futility.

ArmMeasureValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Fosphenytoin (FOS)Number of Participants With Safety Outcome: Purple Glove Syndrome0 Participants
Valproic AcidNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Purple Glove Syndrome0 Participants
LevetiracetamNumber of Participants With Safety Outcome: Purple Glove Syndrome0 Participants

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 28, 2026