Skip to content

Intra-operative Digital vs. Standard Mammography

A Comparison of Intra-Operative Digital Specimen Mammography to Standard Specimen Mammography

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 4
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT01766102
Enrollment
72
Registered
2013-01-11
Start date
2013-01-31
Completion date
2014-12-31
Last updated
2017-08-24

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Breast Cancer

Keywords

Mammography

Brief summary

A breast biopsy in the operating room may be needed in up to 15% of patients with an abnormality on mammogram. When an abnormality is present but there is no palpable mass, the abnormality must be localized with a wire before going to the operating room. This technique is also used when a breast cancer is present but there is no mass, in order to perform a targeted lumpectomy. Once the abnormality is surgically removed, the specimen with the wire is taken to the breast imaging department for a specimen x-ray to ensure that the targeted abnormality is present within the specimen. If the abnormality is close to the edge of the specimen, additional tissue is often removed. A newer method for evaluating the specimen is to perform imaging in the operating room. Portable digital mammography units are available for this purpose. The Biovision digital specimen mammography system is FDA-approved and currently in use in over 200 centers in the United States. Several studies have shown that intra-operative digital mammography is as accurate as standard specimen mammography and takes less time to perform. It may also decrease the chance of having to go back to the operating room to take more breast tissue after lumpectomy because of cancer cells near teh margin(s) of the specimen on final pathology. Having to go back to the operating room to take more tissue is called a re-excision. The purpose of this study is to compare standard specimen mammography to intra-operative specimen mammography to quantify potential operating room time savings and to determine if the use of intra-operative specimen mammography decreases re-excision rates. We aim to see if intra-operative specimen mammography is more efficient and if it decreases re-excision rates.

Detailed description

Before the research starts patients will undergo some screening procedures to determine if patients are eligible to participate. This includes a medical history and an assessment of the patient's breast abnormality by mammogram and/or ultrasound and/or breast MRI. Patients will not need to undergo any extra procedures apart from those needed by the patient's surgeon to plan the patient's breast surgery. If the screening process shows that a patient is eligible to participate in this research study, the patient will be enrolled and the study will proceed on the day of surgery. If a patient does not meet the eligibility criteria the patient will not be able to participate in this research study. Patients will be assigned to one of two arms of this study on the day of your surgery. Because no one knows which of the breast specimen imaging options is best, patients will be randomized into one of the study groups: the Standard Specimen Mammography arm or, the Intra-operative Specimen Mammography arm. Randomization means that the patient is put into a group by chance. It is like flipping a coin. Neither the patient nor the surgeon will choose what group the patient will be in. If the patient is in the Standard Specimen Mammography arm, the patient's breast specimen (biopsy or lumpectomy) will be taken to the Breast Imaging department for a mammogram, which is the way breast specimens are typically imaged. If the patient is in the Intra-Operative Specimen Mammography arm, the patient's breast specimen will be imaged right in the operating room at the time of the surgery. The patient's images will also be linked to the Breast Imaging department, so the radiologist can confirm the surgeon's findings.

Interventions

PROCEDUREIntra-operative Mammography

The patient's breast specimen will be imaged in the operating room in an intra-operative imaging device - Biovision SN #30042

There is not an added device associated with this arm.

Sponsors

Massachusetts General Hospital
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
DIAGNOSTIC
Masking
NONE

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
FEMALE
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* Newly diagnosed with a breast abnormality undergoing an excisional biopsy with wire localization or newly diagnosed with invasive breast cancer or ductal carcinoma undergoing a lumpectomy with wire localization * Ability to understand and willingness to sign a written informed consent document

Exclusion criteria

* Recurrent breast cancer * Palpable masses not requiring wire localization

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Comparison of Operative Time SavingsAt the time of the procedure (approximately 1 week after randomization)To compare the overall operative time savings using intra-operative digital mammography compared with standard specimen mammography.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Assessment of Radiographic and Pathologic Findings2 yearsAssessment of radiographic findings and pathologic findings to determine sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive values of intra-operative digital specimen mammography (ISM) and standard specimen mammography for determining margin status. * A true positive (TP) was defined as a positive margin by imaging (ISM or SSM) and pathology * A false positive (FP) was defined as a positive margin by imaging but negative by pathology * A true negative (TN) was defined as a negative margin by both imaging and pathology. * A false negative (FN) was defined as a negative margin by imaging but positive by pathology * The sensitivity \[TP/(TP + FN)\], specificity \[TN/(TN + FP)\], positive predictive value \[TP/ (TP + FP)\], and negative predictive value \[TN/(TN + FN)\] for identification of positive margins were calculated for ISM and SSM.

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Intra-operative Mammography
Intra-operative Specimen Mammography Intra-operative Mammography: The patient's breast specimen will be imagine in the operating room in an intra-operative imaging device - Biovision SN #30042
36
Standard Mammography
Standard Specimen Mammography Standard Mammography: There is not an added device associated with this arm.
36
Total72

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicTotalIntra-operative MammographyStandard Mammography
Age, Continuous58 years59 years57 years
Anesthesia Type
General
27 Participants12 Participants15 Participants
Anesthesia Type
MAC
45 Participants24 Participants21 Participants
Axillary Surgery
ALND
1 Participants1 Participants0 Participants
Axillary Surgery
None
31 Participants15 Participants16 Participants
Axillary Surgery
SLNB
40 Participants20 Participants20 Participants
BMI26 Kg/m^227 Kg/m^225 Kg/m^2
Reason for excision
Atypia
12 Participants7 Participants5 Participants
Reason for excision
Excisional Biopsy
7 Participants4 Participants3 Participants
Reason for excision
Invasive Carcinoma/DCIS
53 Participants25 Participants28 Participants
Region of Enrollment
United States
72 Participants36 Participants36 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
72 Participants36 Participants36 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Wire-localization Target
Clip
62 Participants29 Participants33 Participants
Wire-localization Target
Mass/ Calcs/ Arch distort
10 Participants7 Participants3 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 00 / 0
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 00 / 0
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 00 / 0

Outcome results

Primary

Comparison of Operative Time Savings

To compare the overall operative time savings using intra-operative digital mammography compared with standard specimen mammography.

Time frame: At the time of the procedure (approximately 1 week after randomization)

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEDIAN)
Intra-operative MammographyComparison of Operative Time SavingsProcedure Time48.5 Minutes
Intra-operative MammographyComparison of Operative Time SavingsOR Time68 Minutes
Standard MammographyComparison of Operative Time SavingsOR Time74 Minutes
Standard MammographyComparison of Operative Time SavingsProcedure Time54 Minutes
Comparison: H0: Procedure time is not significantly different based on mammography type usedp-value: 0.716t-test, 2 sided
Comparison: H0: Operating room time is not significantly different based on mammography type usedp-value: 0.676t-test, 2 sided
Secondary

Assessment of Radiographic and Pathologic Findings

Assessment of radiographic findings and pathologic findings to determine sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive values of intra-operative digital specimen mammography (ISM) and standard specimen mammography for determining margin status. * A true positive (TP) was defined as a positive margin by imaging (ISM or SSM) and pathology * A false positive (FP) was defined as a positive margin by imaging but negative by pathology * A true negative (TN) was defined as a negative margin by both imaging and pathology. * A false negative (FN) was defined as a negative margin by imaging but positive by pathology * The sensitivity \[TP/(TP + FN)\], specificity \[TN/(TN + FP)\], positive predictive value \[TP/ (TP + FP)\], and negative predictive value \[TN/(TN + FN)\] for identification of positive margins were calculated for ISM and SSM.

Time frame: 2 years

Population: Interpretation of margin status by the surgeon was available for 22 of 36 ISM patients. Interpretation of margin status was also available for 22 of 36 SSM patients.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (NUMBER)
Intra-operative MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsSensitivity50 Percent
Intra-operative MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsSpecificity89 Percent
Intra-operative MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsPositive Predicitve Value50 Percent
Intra-operative MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsNegative Predictive Value89 Percent
Standard MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsNegative Predictive Value80 Percent
Standard MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsSensitivity20 Percent
Standard MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsPositive Predicitve Value50 Percent
Standard MammographyAssessment of Radiographic and Pathologic FindingsSpecificity94 Percent

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026