Skip to content

Safety and Efficacy of Punctal Plug Insertion in Patients With Dry Eye

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 4
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT01684436
Enrollment
30
Registered
2012-09-13
Start date
2012-10-01
Completion date
2013-07-31
Last updated
2019-04-17

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Dry Eye

Brief summary

This study will access changes in tear protein levels and symptoms of dry eye following insertion of a punctal plug.

Interventions

Punctal plugs inserted into the study eye on Day 1.

Sponsors

Allergan
Lead SponsorINDUSTRY

Study design

Allocation
NA
Intervention model
SINGLE_GROUP
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* Patients with moderate to severe dry eye

Exclusion criteria

* Previous punctal plug insertion in the last 3 months or presence of plugs at the time of study * Contact lens wear in the 7 days prior to study start or during the study * LASIK procedure in the last year * Cataract or other eye surgery in the last 3 months * Corneal grafts

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Concentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline)A punctal plug (tear duct plug) is a device inserted into the tear duct (puncta) of the eye to block the tear duct from draining liquid from the eye. Tears were collected using the Schirmer's test strip. Tears are measured in the study eye for tear cytokine levels before punctal plug insertion in picogram(pg)/milliliter (mL)/millimeter (mm) of Schirmer's test strip moistened. Cytokines help with the generation of an immune response. Increased cytokine levels are representative of inflammation in the eye.
Concentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeWeek 3A punctal plug (tear duct plug) is a device inserted into the tear duct (puncta) of the eye to block the tear duct from draining liquid from the eye. Tears were collected using the Schirmer's test strip. Tears are measured in the study eye for tear cytokine levels before punctal plug insertion in picogram(pg)/milliliter (mL)/millimeter (mm) of Schirmer's test strip moistened. Cytokines help with the generation of an immune response. Increased cytokine levels are representative of inflammation in the eye.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Corneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline), Week 3The cornea is evaluated following ocular administration of fluorescein stain in the study eye. The cornea is the transparent front part of the eye which covers the iris and pupil. The cornea is divided into 5 regions. Each region is scored according to the extent of staining, with scores ranging from 0 to 4 points: 0=non-staining to 4=regional whole staining of the cornea with 0.5 unit intervals. The higher the staining score, the worse the dry eye condition.
Tear Film Break-up Time (TBUT)Week 0 (Baseline), Week 3TBUT is defined as the time to initial breakup of the tear film following a blink. The longer it takes, the more stable the tear film.
Schirmer's Test ScoreWeek 0 (Baseline), Week 3The Schirmer's Test measures the rate of tear secretion by the eye over 5 minutes (min). The results indicate the presence of dry eye (Normal = greater than or equal to 10 millimeters (mm) of tears, Dry Eye = less than 10 mm of tears). The smaller the number, the more severe the dry eye.
Dry Eye Questionnaire Irritation ScoreWeek 0 (Baseline), Week 3Severity of dry eye irritation is rated by the patient using a visual analogue scale (VAS). Patients put a mark on a 100 millimeter line where 0 (far left on the line)=no symptoms to 100 (far right on the line)=most severe symptoms. The higher the score, the more severe the symptoms.

Countries

Singapore

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Punctal Plug
Punctal plugs inserted into the study eye on Day 1.
29
Total29

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicPunctal Plug
Age, Continuous49.8 Years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 14.1
Sex: Female, Male
Female
23 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
6 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
— / —
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 30
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 30

Outcome results

Primary

Concentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study Eye

A punctal plug (tear duct plug) is a device inserted into the tear duct (puncta) of the eye to block the tear duct from draining liquid from the eye. Tears were collected using the Schirmer's test strip. Tears are measured in the study eye for tear cytokine levels before punctal plug insertion in picogram(pg)/milliliter (mL)/millimeter (mm) of Schirmer's test strip moistened. Cytokines help with the generation of an immune response. Increased cytokine levels are representative of inflammation in the eye.

Time frame: Week 0 (Baseline)

Population: All patients who completed the study

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterferon (IFN)2.24 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 2.02
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-10 (IL10)4.69 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 3.54
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-12 (IL12)9.08 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 9.98
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-13 (IL13)29.81 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 26.53
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-17A (IL17A)0.57 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 0.48
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-1B (IL1B)0.63 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 0.37
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeMatrix metallopeptidase 9 (MMP9)1519.82 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1516.92
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-2 (IL2)0.88 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 0.59
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-4 (IL4)17.66 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 21.59
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-6 (IL6)6.11 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 6.73
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterleukin-8 (IL8)74.00 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 55.03
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeInterferon γ-Induced Protein-10 (IP10)2384.86 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1198.08
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeMonocyte Chemotactic Protein 1 (MCP1)49.08 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 46.91
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeMacrophage Inflammatory Protein 1 Alpha (MIP1A)0.59 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 0.56
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeRegulate Activation Normal T-Cell Express (RANTE)21.20 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 15.57
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Before Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeTumor Necrosis Factor Alpha (TNFA)1.54 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1.46
Primary

Concentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study Eye

A punctal plug (tear duct plug) is a device inserted into the tear duct (puncta) of the eye to block the tear duct from draining liquid from the eye. Tears were collected using the Schirmer's test strip. Tears are measured in the study eye for tear cytokine levels before punctal plug insertion in picogram(pg)/milliliter (mL)/millimeter (mm) of Schirmer's test strip moistened. Cytokines help with the generation of an immune response. Increased cytokine levels are representative of inflammation in the eye.

Time frame: Week 3

Population: All patients who completed the study

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIFN3.12 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 2.69
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL103.97 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 3.35
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL127.34 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 6.05
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL1329.14 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 23.35
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL17A0.55 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 0.39
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL1B1.10 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1.03
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeMMP91445.53 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1415.09
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL21.05 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1.1
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL49.75 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 8.31
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL64.31 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 3.66
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIL861.07 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 57.15
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeIP102769.17 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1479.5
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeMCP168.08 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 62.1
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeMIP1A0.61 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 0.73
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeRANTE29.55 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 26.99
Punctal PlugConcentration of Tear Cytokine Levels Following Punctal Plug Insertion in the Study EyeTNFA1.37 picogram/milliliter/millimeter(pg/ml/mm)Standard Deviation 1.21
Secondary

Corneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study Eye

The cornea is evaluated following ocular administration of fluorescein stain in the study eye. The cornea is the transparent front part of the eye which covers the iris and pupil. The cornea is divided into 5 regions. Each region is scored according to the extent of staining, with scores ranging from 0 to 4 points: 0=non-staining to 4=regional whole staining of the cornea with 0.5 unit intervals. The higher the staining score, the worse the dry eye condition.

Time frame: Week 0 (Baseline), Week 3

Population: All patients who completed the study

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline): Superior0.57 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.85
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline): Inferior1.33 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.93
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline): Nasal0.67 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.89
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline): Temporal0.72 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.96
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 0 (Baseline): Central0.91 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.95
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 3: Superior0.48 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.62
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 3: Inferior1.22 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.85
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 3: Nasal0.41 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.84
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 3: Temporal0.36 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.74
Punctal PlugCorneal Fluorescein Staining Score in the Study EyeWeek 3: Central0.57 Scores on a ScaleStandard Deviation 0.73
Secondary

Dry Eye Questionnaire Irritation Score

Severity of dry eye irritation is rated by the patient using a visual analogue scale (VAS). Patients put a mark on a 100 millimeter line where 0 (far left on the line)=no symptoms to 100 (far right on the line)=most severe symptoms. The higher the score, the more severe the symptoms.

Time frame: Week 0 (Baseline), Week 3

Population: All patients who completed the study

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Punctal PlugDry Eye Questionnaire Irritation ScoreWeek 0 (Baseline)53.81 Millimeters (mm)Standard Deviation 26.5
Punctal PlugDry Eye Questionnaire Irritation ScoreWeek 336.22 Millimeters (mm)Standard Deviation 24.89
Secondary

Schirmer's Test Score

The Schirmer's Test measures the rate of tear secretion by the eye over 5 minutes (min). The results indicate the presence of dry eye (Normal = greater than or equal to 10 millimeters (mm) of tears, Dry Eye = less than 10 mm of tears). The smaller the number, the more severe the dry eye.

Time frame: Week 0 (Baseline), Week 3

Population: All patients who completed the study

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Punctal PlugSchirmer's Test ScoreWeek 0 (Baseline)5.07 Millimeters (mm)Standard Deviation 2.76
Punctal PlugSchirmer's Test ScoreWeek 36.28 Millimeters (mm)Standard Deviation 5.11
Secondary

Tear Film Break-up Time (TBUT)

TBUT is defined as the time to initial breakup of the tear film following a blink. The longer it takes, the more stable the tear film.

Time frame: Week 0 (Baseline), Week 3

Population: All patients who completed the study

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Punctal PlugTear Film Break-up Time (TBUT)Week 0 (Baseline)2.21 SecondsStandard Deviation 0.57
Punctal PlugTear Film Break-up Time (TBUT)Week 32.42 SecondsStandard Deviation 0.76

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026