Skip to content

Closed Loop Propofol Administration in Pediatric Cardiac Surgery

Evaluation of Closed Loop Anaesthesia Delivery System for Propofol Anaesthesia in Pediatric Cardiac Surgery

Status
Completed
Phases
NA
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT01600287
Enrollment
40
Registered
2012-05-17
Start date
2012-01-31
Completion date
2012-12-31
Last updated
2013-08-09

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Automated Drug Delivery, Intraoperative Awareness, Pediatric Cardiac Surgery

Keywords

bispectral index, propofol, paediatric cardiac surgery, closed loop anaesthesia delivery system

Brief summary

The purpose of the study is to evaluate and compare the feasibility, efficacy and safety of IAADS (Improved Anaesthetic Agent Delivery System) for propofol anaesthesia against manual control using bispectral index in paediatric patients undergoing open heart surgery under cardio-pulmonary bypass.

Detailed description

Automated drug delivery has gained considerable interest in recent times. It is carried out by specially programmed electro-mechanical devices where dose rate adjustment is made independent of human intervention. The desired target is chosen by the clinician. The closed loop system depends upon a feedback signal to modify the rate of drug delivery. These have an advantage that they are able to overcome the individual pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic differences as well as the differing levels of surgical stimulation. Majority of studies on closed loop delivery of hypnotics has been done using propofol. CLADS(Closed loop anesthesia delivery system) is a BIS guided closed loop anaesthesia delivery system developed at PGIMER (Post graduate institute of medical education and research), Chandigarh and has been used successfully for administration of propofol in various situations, eg, non-cardiac surgery, cardiac surgery, post-operative sedation and high altitude. The system used will be IAADS, Improved anesthetic agent delivery system - the present and updated version of CLADS), a pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic model based adaptive system . There are only a few studies/reports regarding closed loop delivery of muscle relaxants in children. In this study, the efficacy of IAADS will be compared with manual control for administration of propofol using BIS as a control variable during induction and maintenance of anaesthesia in children undergoing elective open heart surgery. After approval from the Institutional ethics committee and written informed parental consent, 40 children, aged 5-18 years and ASA physical status II-III, planned for elective open heart surgery under general anaesthesia will be studied. Patients will be randomly allocated to one of two groups - the manual group and the IAADS group using computer-generated random numbers in sealed opaque envelopes. Exclusion criteria will be: patients weighing more than ±30% of ideal body weight, those with neurological/psychological disorders, on psychoactive medications, belonging to NYHA class IV, those with severe stenotic valvular lesions, with known allergy to propofol or any of its constituents, having severe pulmonary arterial hypertension, with cyanotic congenital heart disease and those who may require deep hypothermic circulatory arrest for repair. The investigator will be present during the procedure for data collection purpose only and was not involved in the conduct of anaesthesia. Patients will be premedicated with oral midazolam syrup 0.25mg/kg 30 minutes before shifting to operating room. EMLA cream will be applied to the site of venipuncture for at least one hour. Intravenous access will be obtained in the operating room. Routine physiological monitoring will be commenced (pulse oximetry, electrocardiography, non-invasive blood pressure). BIS will be obtained by disposable sensors (Aspect Medical System Inc. MA USA) attached to the forehead of the patients. The children resisting venous cannula placement will be excluded from the study and subjected to inhalational induction. Before induction, patients will receive fentanyl 3µg/kg over three minutes. In automatic mode, IAADS will calculate and titrate the initial and subsequent propofol infusion rate according to the weight of the patient, the risk status, the target BIS value which will be set at 50 for all cases. In manual mode, infusion rate will be determined by the attending anaesthesiologist according to the weight of the patient and target BIS of 50, with the aim to maintain BIS within 40-60. After loss of consciousness, patients will receive 0.1mg/kg of vecuronium bromide and trachea will be intubated after 4 minutes. The lungs will be ventilated with 100% O2; tidal volume and respiratory rate will be adjusted to maintain an EtCO2 of 30-35 mm Hg. Central venous catheter and arterial cannula will be inserted subsequently. Analgesia will be maintained with infusion of fentanyl at 1µg/kg/hr and additional boluses of 1µg/kg will be administered before skin incision, sternotomy and commencement of cardio-pulmonary bypass. Muscle relaxation will be maintained with vecuronium bromide. Tachycardia and hypertension will be treated with fentanyl bolus, esmolol, nitroglycerine as appropriate. Hypotension will be treated with fluid bolus, phenylephrine, inotropes as appropriate. Significant bradycardia will be treated with atropine sulphate. During CPB, infusion of fentanyl and propofol will be continued. MAP will be maintained between 30-50 mm Hg and any deviation from these limits will be treated with phenylephrine boluses or nitroglycerine infusion. Propofol will be administered as per IAADS protocol in automatic group and manually in control group. The number of times propofol infusion rate that will needed to be changed in the manual group will be noted. After skin closure, fentanyl and propofol infusion will be stopped, study protocol will be terminated and the patients will be shifted to ICU without antagonizing the muscle relaxant for elective mechanical ventilation. Patients will be given propofol infusion for postoperative sedation and will be extubated when standard criteria for weaning and extubation will be met. The children will be subjected to a structured interview as described by Lopez et a for conscious awareness; on second day after surgery and approximately one month later.

Interventions

OTHERIAADS

In automatic mode, the system requests an update of the BIS data every 5 seconds and calculates the BIS error (difference between the target and actual BIS value). This value along with the trends of BIS in the epoch of the last 30 seconds as well as in the last 5 minutes is passed on to a patient individualized, model based adaptive control algorithm. The algorithm uses the error to calculate an adjustment to the propofol delivery rate, but does not apply it immediately. Adjustments to the propofol delivery rate are only made every 30 seconds, taking into account the sum of previous six BIS error values, the trends of BIS in the epoch of last 30 seconds as well as in the last 5 minutes, time elapsed since the initiation of infusion, pharmacokinetics, the time delay factor between sensing and averaging of BIS data, the time delay factor between the change in infusion rate and the actual change in the plasma concentration of propofol as well as the peak effect of propofol.

OTHERManual propofol administration

In manual mode, the user can also control the propofol infusion rate manually, using the keyboard or the mouse of the PC. The PC displays a graph of the propofol delivery rate and trend of BIS value.

Sponsors

Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
5 Years to 18 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* Children, aged 5-18 years and ASA (American Society of Anesthesiology) physical status 2-3, planned for elective open heart surgery under general anaesthesia.

Exclusion criteria

* Patients weighing more than ±30% of ideal body weight. * Patients having neurological/psychological disorders or on psychoactive medications. * Patients belonging to NYHA (New York Heart Association) class IV. * Patients with severe stenotic valvular lesions, eg, mitral or aortic stenosis. * Patients with known allergy to propofol or any of its constituents. * Patients having severe pulmonary arterial hypertension. * Patients with cyanotic congenital heart disease. * Patients requiring deep hypothermic circulatory arrest during surgery.

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Percentage of Time Bispectral Index(BIS) Remains+/-10 of TargetApproximately 8 hoursThe primary outcome to be measured is the ability of the system to keep the depth of anesthesia in the target range, i.e, Bispectral Index(BIS) value of 50+/- 10. This will assess the ability of the system to prevent intra-operative awareness of the patients and at the same time avoid excessive depth of anesthesia with its accompanying adverse effects.

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Median Absolute Performance Error(MDAPE)Approximately 8 hoursThe difference between the observed and target of measure of depth of anesthesia (BIS) expressed as percentage of target BIS is calculated as performance error every 30 seconds. This value may be either '+' or '\_' indicating whether the observed measure is above the target (overshoot-+) or below the target (undershoot-\_).The median of the absolute values of performance errors (without considering the direction of error) is median absolute performance error. This outcome measures the magnitude of error or inaccuracy of the system studied. A lower value indicates a more precise system.This outcome is expressed as the mean of Median Absolute Performance Errors per participant.
Median Performance Error(MDPE)Approximately 8 hoursThe difference between the observed and target of measure of depth of anesthesia (BIS) expressed as percentage of target BIS is calculated as performance error every 30 seconds. This value may be either '+' or '\_' indicating whether the observed measure is above the target (overshoot-+) or below the target (undershoot-\_). The median value of all performance errors during propofol anesthesia is median performance error and is a measure of bias of the system. This outcome is expressed as the mean of Median Performance Errors per participant.
WobbleApproximately 8 hoursWobble measures the intra-individual variability in performance error.The median of the difference between individual performance errors throughout anesthesia and the median performance error for each participant is the wobble of that participant. The mean value per participant is indicated in the outcome measure.
Percentage of Time Heart Rate Remains Within 25% of Pre-op BaselineApproximately 8 hoursThe duration of time heart rate remains within 25% of the pre-operative baseline value during the period propofol (general anesthetic) is administered to the study population. This value is expressed as a percentage. This outcome is expressed as the mean of percentage of time per participant.
Percentage of Time Mean Arterial Pressure Remains Within 25% of Pre-op BaselineApproximately 8 hoursThe duration of time mean arterial pressure remains within 25% of the pre-operative baseline value during the period propofol (general anesthetic) is administered to the study population. This value is expressed as percentage. This outcome is expressed as the mean of percentage of time per participant
Intra-operative AwarenessApproximately 3 days and then 1 month laterThe number of patients who will be able to recall the intra-operative events when assessed postoperatively. This will be assessed by a structured protocol
Divergence8 hours (approx)slope of the linear regression curve of performance error against time.
Global Score8 hours (approx)overall performance assessment of the system calculated as= \[(MDAPE+Wobble)/percentage of time BIS remains within target\]x100 Lower score indicates better overall performance
Intraoperative Phenylephrine Used (Pre CPB)2 hours(approx)total phenylephrine dose needed to be used in the pre CPB period to maintain hemodynamic stability

Other

MeasureTime frameDescription
Minimum BIS During Induction15 minutesBispectral Index(BIS) is an EEG-based objective measure of anesthetic depth with values ranging from 100 to 0, lower number indicating greater depth of anesthesia. Values between 40 to 60 indicate adequate depth required for surgery. During induction of anesthesia, there is a tendency of overshooting the adequate depth of anesthesia, due to use of higher dose and rate of administration required for induction. The minimum BIS achieved during induction is a measure of this overshoot. The less the minimum value, the more is the overshoot, worse the outcome is. The minimum BIS during induction is automatically stored in the PC used for the study.
Percentage Fall in MAP During Induction15 minutespercentage fall in mean arterial pressure from baseline during induction
Total Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr)8 hours (approx)total propofol used based on per kg body weight per hour for the whole duration of surgery
Total Fentanyl Used (µg/kg)8 hours(approx)total fentanyl used in the whole duration of surgery on per kg body weight basis
Total Off CPB Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr6 hours(approx)total dosage of propofol used on per kg body weight per hour basis in the period before and after cardiopulmonary bypass period.
Number of Times Rate of Propofol Changed Manually8 hours(aprrox)Number of times rate of propofol needed to be changed manually
Induction Time10 minutesTime required for the first time achievement of two subsequent BIS values below or equal to 55
Induction Dose of Propofol10 minutesDose of propofol needed for induction

Countries

India

Participant flow

Recruitment details

51 patients assessed in surgical ward between january 2012 to september 2012, after excluding 11 patients, 40 remaining patients were randomised into two groups(IAADS & Manual) of 20 each- all patients in each group received allocated interventions- no patients needed to be excluded from final analysis.

Pre-assignment details

5 patients were initially excluded because of having cyanotic heart disease, 6 patients excluded subsequently as they resisted pre-induction venous cannula placement.

Participants by arm

ArmCount
IAADS Group
Both induction and maintenance of anesthesia was done automatically by IAADS according to age, sex, height of the patient, target BIS(50) entered, risk status and maximum allowable rate entered.
20
Manual Group
dosage of propofol was adjusted manually by the attending anesthesiologist through the keyboard of the PC attached to the syringe pump for both induction and maintenance.
20
Total40

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicManual GroupIAADS GroupTotal
Age, Categorical
<=18 years
20 Participants20 Participants40 Participants
Age, Categorical
>=65 years
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Age, Categorical
Between 18 and 65 years
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Age Continuous12 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.1
11.1 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 5.1
11.6 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 4.6
Region of Enrollment
India
20 participants20 participants40 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
9 Participants11 Participants20 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
11 Participants9 Participants20 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
— / —— / —
other
Total, other adverse events
0 / 200 / 20
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 200 / 20

Outcome results

Primary

Percentage of Time Bispectral Index(BIS) Remains+/-10 of Target

The primary outcome to be measured is the ability of the system to keep the depth of anesthesia in the target range, i.e, Bispectral Index(BIS) value of 50+/- 10. This will assess the ability of the system to prevent intra-operative awareness of the patients and at the same time avoid excessive depth of anesthesia with its accompanying adverse effects.

Time frame: Approximately 8 hours

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupPercentage of Time Bispectral Index(BIS) Remains+/-10 of Target77.4 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 13.07
Manual GroupPercentage of Time Bispectral Index(BIS) Remains+/-10 of Target75 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 11
Secondary

Divergence

slope of the linear regression curve of performance error against time.

Time frame: 8 hours (approx)

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupDivergence0.02 errors per secondStandard Deviation 0.17
Manual GroupDivergence-0.097 errors per secondStandard Deviation 0.219
Secondary

Global Score

overall performance assessment of the system calculated as= \[(MDAPE+Wobble)/percentage of time BIS remains within target\]x100 Lower score indicates better overall performance

Time frame: 8 hours (approx)

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupGlobal Score30.09 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 12.17
Manual GroupGlobal Score34.12 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 15.28
Secondary

Intra-operative Awareness

The number of patients who will be able to recall the intra-operative events when assessed postoperatively. This will be assessed by a structured protocol

Time frame: Approximately 3 days and then 1 month later

ArmMeasureValue (NUMBER)
IAADS GroupIntra-operative Awareness0 participants
Manual GroupIntra-operative Awareness0 participants
Secondary

Intraoperative Phenylephrine Used (Pre CPB)

total phenylephrine dose needed to be used in the pre CPB period to maintain hemodynamic stability

Time frame: 2 hours(approx)

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupIntraoperative Phenylephrine Used (Pre CPB)5.79 microgram per Kg body weightStandard Deviation 5.98
Manual GroupIntraoperative Phenylephrine Used (Pre CPB)16.92 microgram per Kg body weightStandard Deviation 10.92
Secondary

Median Absolute Performance Error(MDAPE)

The difference between the observed and target of measure of depth of anesthesia (BIS) expressed as percentage of target BIS is calculated as performance error every 30 seconds. This value may be either '+' or '\_' indicating whether the observed measure is above the target (overshoot-+) or below the target (undershoot-\_).The median of the absolute values of performance errors (without considering the direction of error) is median absolute performance error. This outcome measures the magnitude of error or inaccuracy of the system studied. A lower value indicates a more precise system.This outcome is expressed as the mean of Median Absolute Performance Errors per participant.

Time frame: Approximately 8 hours

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupMedian Absolute Performance Error(MDAPE)12 errors per participantStandard Deviation 3
Manual GroupMedian Absolute Performance Error(MDAPE)13 errors per participantStandard Deviation 4
Secondary

Median Performance Error(MDPE)

The difference between the observed and target of measure of depth of anesthesia (BIS) expressed as percentage of target BIS is calculated as performance error every 30 seconds. This value may be either '+' or '\_' indicating whether the observed measure is above the target (overshoot-+) or below the target (undershoot-\_). The median value of all performance errors during propofol anesthesia is median performance error and is a measure of bias of the system. This outcome is expressed as the mean of Median Performance Errors per participant.

Time frame: Approximately 8 hours

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupMedian Performance Error(MDPE)6 errors per participantStandard Deviation 8
Manual GroupMedian Performance Error(MDPE)-7 errors per participantStandard Deviation 5
Secondary

Percentage of Time Heart Rate Remains Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline

The duration of time heart rate remains within 25% of the pre-operative baseline value during the period propofol (general anesthetic) is administered to the study population. This value is expressed as a percentage. This outcome is expressed as the mean of percentage of time per participant.

Time frame: Approximately 8 hours

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupPercentage of Time Heart Rate Remains Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline83.3 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 11.7
Manual GroupPercentage of Time Heart Rate Remains Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline80.5 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 19.6
Secondary

Percentage of Time Mean Arterial Pressure Remains Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline

The duration of time mean arterial pressure remains within 25% of the pre-operative baseline value during the period propofol (general anesthetic) is administered to the study population. This value is expressed as percentage. This outcome is expressed as the mean of percentage of time per participant

Time frame: Approximately 8 hours

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupPercentage of Time Mean Arterial Pressure Remains Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline83.8 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 10.5
Manual GroupPercentage of Time Mean Arterial Pressure Remains Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline72.8 percentage of timeStandard Deviation 18.4
Secondary

Wobble

Wobble measures the intra-individual variability in performance error.The median of the difference between individual performance errors throughout anesthesia and the median performance error for each participant is the wobble of that participant. The mean value per participant is indicated in the outcome measure.

Time frame: Approximately 8 hours

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupWobble9 errors per participantStandard Deviation 3
Manual GroupWobble11 errors per participantStandard Deviation 4
Other Pre-specified

Induction Dose of Propofol

Dose of propofol needed for induction

Time frame: 10 minutes

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupInduction Dose of Propofol2.06 mg per kg body weightStandard Deviation 0.79
Manual GroupInduction Dose of Propofol2.95 mg per kg body weightStandard Deviation 1.03
Other Pre-specified

Induction Time

Time required for the first time achievement of two subsequent BIS values below or equal to 55

Time frame: 10 minutes

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupInduction Time186.2 secondsStandard Deviation 91.2
Manual GroupInduction Time160.6 secondsStandard Deviation 42
Other Pre-specified

Minimum BIS During Induction

Bispectral Index(BIS) is an EEG-based objective measure of anesthetic depth with values ranging from 100 to 0, lower number indicating greater depth of anesthesia. Values between 40 to 60 indicate adequate depth required for surgery. During induction of anesthesia, there is a tendency of overshooting the adequate depth of anesthesia, due to use of higher dose and rate of administration required for induction. The minimum BIS achieved during induction is a measure of this overshoot. The less the minimum value, the more is the overshoot, worse the outcome is. The minimum BIS during induction is automatically stored in the PC used for the study.

Time frame: 15 minutes

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupMinimum BIS During Induction45 Bispectral IndexStandard Deviation 6
Manual GroupMinimum BIS During Induction36 Bispectral IndexStandard Deviation 11
Other Pre-specified

Number of Times Rate of Propofol Changed Manually

Number of times rate of propofol needed to be changed manually

Time frame: 8 hours(aprrox)

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
IAADS GroupNumber of Times Rate of Propofol Changed Manually0 times per hour
Manual GroupNumber of Times Rate of Propofol Changed Manually18 times per hour
Other Pre-specified

Percentage Fall in MAP During Induction

percentage fall in mean arterial pressure from baseline during induction

Time frame: 15 minutes

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupPercentage Fall in MAP During Induction18.5 percentage of fall from baselineStandard Deviation 13
Manual GroupPercentage Fall in MAP During Induction24 percentage of fall from baselineStandard Deviation 8
Other Pre-specified

Total Fentanyl Used (µg/kg)

total fentanyl used in the whole duration of surgery on per kg body weight basis

Time frame: 8 hours(approx)

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupTotal Fentanyl Used (µg/kg)12.03 microgram per kg body weightStandard Deviation 4.51
Manual GroupTotal Fentanyl Used (µg/kg)12.5 microgram per kg body weightStandard Deviation 4.31
Other Pre-specified

Total Off CPB Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr

total dosage of propofol used on per kg body weight per hour basis in the period before and after cardiopulmonary bypass period.

Time frame: 6 hours(approx)

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupTotal Off CPB Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr6.29 mg per kg body weight per hourStandard Deviation 2.48
Manual GroupTotal Off CPB Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr7.82 mg per kg body weight per hourStandard Deviation 2.1
Other Pre-specified

Total Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr)

total propofol used based on per kg body weight per hour for the whole duration of surgery

Time frame: 8 hours (approx)

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
IAADS GroupTotal Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr)4.81 mg per kg body weight per hourStandard Deviation 1.98
Manual GroupTotal Propofol Used (mg/kg/hr)6 mg per kg body weight per hourStandard Deviation 2

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026