Skip to content

Pilot Study to Compare Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate for Prevention of Migraine

A Randomized, Single-Blind Pilot Study to Compare the Efficacy and Cost-Effectiveness of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate for the Prevention of Migraine

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 4
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT00846495
Enrollment
55
Registered
2009-02-18
Start date
2009-08-31
Completion date
2011-01-31
Last updated
2012-01-13

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Migraine

Keywords

Migraine, Migraine prevention, Prodrome, Premonitory phase, Preemptive therapy

Brief summary

Subjects enrolled at 2 investigative sites will complete 3 visits. Following Visit 1, during a 1-month Baseline Period, subjects will treat with their usual medication and document any warning signs (Prodrome pre-headache) that a migraine will occur. Following randomization (like a flip of the coin) at Visit 2, subjects will treat daily with topiramate or during Prodrome with frovatriptan. Subjects complete a 2-month Treatment Period before exit at Visit 3.This study will compare the effectiveness of daily treatment vs. treatment during the pre-headache phase for prevention of migraine.

Interventions

DRUGtopiramate

topiramate 25mg 1 tab in PM x 1 week topiramate 25mg 1 tab in AM / 1 tab in PM x 1 week topiramate 25mg 1 tab in AM / 2 tabs in PM x 1 week topiramate 25mg 2 tabs in AM / 2 tabs in PM x 5 weeks

frovatriptan 5mg tab during premonitory phase of migraine

Sponsors

Endo Pharmaceuticals
CollaboratorINDUSTRY
Clinvest
Lead SponsorINDIV

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
PREVENTION
Masking
SINGLE (Investigator)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to No maximum
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

1. Subject has at least a one-year history of migraine with or without aura meeting International Headache Society criteria (see Appendix) 2. Subject has a 3-month history of averaging 3-6 migraines per month 3. Subject reports premonitory symptoms and the ability to predict at least 50% of high impact headaches 4. Subjects must currently or have in the past successfully utilized a triptan as an acute treatment for migraine as determined by the investigator. 5. Male or female at least 18 years of age 6. Subject of childbearing potential agrees to use adequate contraception during the study. Adequate methods of contraception are to be determined by the investigator and should be consistent with contraceptive care administered in the regular clinical use of frovatriptan and topiramate. 7. Subject is aware of prodrome symptoms that may include physiological, psychological or cognitive changes. These may include, but are not limited to such symptoms as Pre-Menstrual Syndrome (PMS), change in mood, energy level, appetite, food craving, nausea, sense of hearing, sense of smell or swelling/fluid retention, excessive yawning, head pain, muscle pain/tenderness, irritability, confusion, extreme sleepiness, impaired speech or impaired memory. (The subject should be able to differentiate these symptoms from other similar symptoms that do not precede migraine). The symptoms should precede migraine by 4-24 hours signaling an impending migraine attack. 8. Subject is able to understand instructions for the study and complete the diary 9. Subject is willing to give informed consent to participate in the study 10. Any migraine prophylactic medication must have a stabilized dosage for one month

Exclusion criteria

1. History of any medical condition that would confound the results of the study including but not limited to the following: * Hepatic disease or significant hepatic dysfunction * History of pancreatitis * History of thrombocytopenia * History of glaucoma * History of osteoporosis or osteopenia * Cardiovascular Disease - Coronary artery disease, Ischemic heart disease or Significant Arrhythmia * History of active Cerebrovascular Disease * Hypertension - Uncontrolled hypertension in a non-migrainous state (\> 160 mmHg systolic or \>95 mmHg. diastolic). Hypertension must be controlled effectively with medication for a period of 3 months. * Basilar or Hemiplegic Migraine * Significant peripheral vascular disease or Raynaud's Syndrome * Significant Active Renal, Hepatic, Gastrointestinal, Endocrine or * Neurological Disease * History of depression, mood problems or suicidal thoughts or behavior that in the opinion of the Investigator would interfere with participation in the study. 2. History of ergotamine, triptan, or analgesic abuse within past 3 months 3. History of current or recent drug or alcohol abuse that would interfere with participation in the study. 4. More than 15 headache days per month within past 3 months. 5. Women who are pregnant or breast feeding 6. Subjects with known hypersensitivity or intolerance to topiramate or any triptan-like medication 7. Subject is scheduled for surgical procedure to occur while enrolled in study.that in opinion of the Investigator would interfere with participation in the study. 8. Subject is on a ketogenic diet 9. Participation in another investigative drug study within the previous 30 days 10. Excluded medications: MAO Inhibitors, lithium, methylergonovine, methysergide, ergotamine-containing products, or topiramate daily for migraine prophylaxis.

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Number of Migraine Attacks in Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily TopiramateTreatment Month 2Compare number of migraine attacks reported by participants using frovatriptan in a preemptive treatment paradigm vs. daily topiramate during Treatment Period Month 2
Number of Headache Days Reported by Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate to Prevent MigraineTreatment Month 2Measure the change in number of headache days between participants using frovatriptan in a preemptive treatment paradigm vs. daily topiramate to prevent migraine

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Quality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRandomization, End of Treatment Month 1, End of Treatment Month 2Quality of Life is measured by the Migraine Specific Quality of Life Questionnaire (MSQ), which includes 3 dimensions: Role Function Restrictive (degree to which performance of daily activities is limited), Role Function Preventive (degree to which performance of daily activities is interrupted), and Emotional Function (frustration and helplessness due to migraine). Scores range from 0 to 100. For each dimension, a higher score indicates a better health status. Participants completed the MSQ at Randomization, and after Treatment Months 1 and 2.
Participant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsTreatment Month 2Participant satisfaction is measured by the Patient Perception of Migraine Questionnaire (PPMQ). Questions were categorized within 6 dimensions: Efficacy, Functionality, Ease of Use, Cost, Bothersomeness of Side Effects, and Total Score. Scores range from 0 to 100. Higher scores represent better satisfaction. Participants completed the PPMQ 24 hours following each first dose of frovatriptan.
Number of Headache Days Each Month Following Initiation of Treatment With Study Medication2 MonthsMeasure the change in number of headache days reported by participants during each treatment month following initiation of treatment with study medication
Cost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigraineTreatment Months 1 and 2Average cost of study medication taken by each subject. Measured in dollars.
Adverse Events Associated With Study MedicationsTreatment Months 1 and 2Includes Adverse Events at or above 5% frequency per group.
Participants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment Paradigm2 MonthsCompare number of participants with greater than 50% reduction in migraine attacks and headache days from Baseline to Treatment Months 1 and 2

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Topiramate
Subjects randomized to Group A were provided with topiramate 25mg to titrate to a maximum dosage of 100mg during Month 1. One dose adjustment was allowed with 50mg/day the required minimum dosage. Group A subjects treated with daily topiramate during Months 2 and 3 and rescued any migraine headache that occurred with frovatriptan 2.5mg.
28
Frovatriptan
Subjects randomized to Group B were provided with frovatriptan 5mg to be utilized during prodrome at the point they were confident a disabling migraine would occur but before the onset of headache. Subjects were provided with frovatriptan 2.5mg for rescue of persistent or recurring headache between 4 and 24 hours following treatment during prodrome.
27
Total55

Withdrawals & dropouts

PeriodReasonFG000FG001
Overall StudyAdverse Event51
Overall StudyLack of Efficacy12
Overall StudyLost to Follow-up10
Overall StudyPhysician Decision10

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicFrovatriptanTopiramateTotal
Age, Categorical
<=18 years
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Age, Categorical
>=65 years
0 Participants0 Participants0 Participants
Age, Categorical
Between 18 and 65 years
27 Participants28 Participants55 Participants
Age Continuous37.33 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.46
37.61 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 10.3
37.47 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 9.82
Region of Enrollment
United States
27 participants28 participants55 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
21 Participants22 Participants43 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
6 Participants6 Participants12 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
— / —— / —
other
Total, other adverse events
17 / 285 / 27
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 280 / 27

Outcome results

Primary

Number of Headache Days Reported by Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate to Prevent Migraine

Measure the change in number of headache days between participants using frovatriptan in a preemptive treatment paradigm vs. daily topiramate to prevent migraine

Time frame: Treatment Month 2

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
TopiramateNumber of Headache Days Reported by Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate to Prevent Migraine4.75 Headache DaysStandard Deviation 2.59
FrovatriptanNumber of Headache Days Reported by Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate to Prevent Migraine2.79 Headache DaysStandard Deviation 3.26
Primary

Number of Migraine Attacks in Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate

Compare number of migraine attacks reported by participants using frovatriptan in a preemptive treatment paradigm vs. daily topiramate during Treatment Period Month 2

Time frame: Treatment Month 2

Population: Number of Units Analyzed is equivalent to number of migraine attacks reported during 2nd Treatment Month.

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
TopiramateNumber of Migraine Attacks in Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate1.35 Migraine attacksStandard Deviation 1.31
FrovatriptanNumber of Migraine Attacks in Participants Using Frovatriptan in a Preemptive Treatment Paradigm vs. Daily Topiramate2.12 Migraine attacksStandard Deviation 1.75
Secondary

Adverse Events Associated With Study Medications

Includes Adverse Events at or above 5% frequency per group.

Time frame: Treatment Months 1 and 2

ArmMeasureValue (NUMBER)
TopiramateAdverse Events Associated With Study Medications26 Adverse Events
FrovatriptanAdverse Events Associated With Study Medications11 Adverse Events
Secondary

Cost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of Migraine

Average cost of study medication taken by each subject. Measured in dollars.

Time frame: Treatment Months 1 and 2

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
TopiramateCost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigrainePreventive Medication Taken343.56 Dollars (US)Standard Deviation 50.4774
TopiramateCost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigraineRescue Medication Taken38.33 Dollars (US)Standard Deviation 10.45
TopiramateCost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigraineAll Study Medication Taken381.89 Dollars (US)Standard Deviation 51.8816
FrovatriptanCost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigrainePreventive Medication Taken101.41 Dollars (US)Standard Deviation 10.304
FrovatriptanCost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigraineRescue Medication Taken59.94 Dollars (US)Standard Deviation 9.54
FrovatriptanCost of Frovatriptan vs. Topiramate as Preventive Treatment of MigraineAll Study Medication Taken161.35 Dollars (US)Standard Deviation 70.1844
Secondary

Number of Headache Days Each Month Following Initiation of Treatment With Study Medication

Measure the change in number of headache days reported by participants during each treatment month following initiation of treatment with study medication

Time frame: 2 Months

Population: Number of Units Analyzed is equivalent to number of headache days reported during Treatment Months 1 and 2.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
TopiramateNumber of Headache Days Each Month Following Initiation of Treatment With Study MedicationTreatment Month 21.75 Headache DaysStandard Deviation 1.86
TopiramateNumber of Headache Days Each Month Following Initiation of Treatment With Study MedicationTreatment Month 14.20 Headache DaysStandard Deviation 2.88
FrovatriptanNumber of Headache Days Each Month Following Initiation of Treatment With Study MedicationTreatment Month 13.96 Headache DaysStandard Deviation 2.84
FrovatriptanNumber of Headache Days Each Month Following Initiation of Treatment With Study MedicationTreatment Month 23.42 Headache DaysStandard Deviation 2.98
Secondary

Participant Satisfaction With Study Medications

Participant satisfaction is measured by the Patient Perception of Migraine Questionnaire (PPMQ). Questions were categorized within 6 dimensions: Efficacy, Functionality, Ease of Use, Cost, Bothersomeness of Side Effects, and Total Score. Scores range from 0 to 100. Higher scores represent better satisfaction. Participants completed the PPMQ 24 hours following each first dose of frovatriptan.

Time frame: Treatment Month 2

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
TopiramateParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsEfficacy76.7857 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 21.04
TopiramateParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsFunctionality77.8214 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 22.68
TopiramateParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsEase of Use91.6607 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 11.5639
TopiramateParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsCost81.2536 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 19.85
TopiramateParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsBothersomeness of Side Effects95.1786 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 6.08
TopiramateParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsTotal Score82.0925 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 15.77
FrovatriptanParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsBothersomeness of Side Effects95.5398 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 6.81
FrovatriptanParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsEfficacy75.1977 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 30.21
FrovatriptanParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsCost59.0886 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 32.86
FrovatriptanParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsFunctionality76.3648 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 29.98
FrovatriptanParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsTotal Score81.1417 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 21.76
FrovatriptanParticipant Satisfaction With Study MedicationsEase of Use92.6989 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 11.36
Secondary

Participants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment Paradigm

Compare number of participants with greater than 50% reduction in migraine attacks and headache days from Baseline to Treatment Months 1 and 2

Time frame: 2 Months

ArmMeasureGroupValue (NUMBER)
TopiramateParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmMigraine Attacks Treatment Month 111 Participants
TopiramateParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmHeadache Days Treatment Month 17 Participants
TopiramateParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmMigraine Attacks Treatment Month 215 Participants
TopiramateParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmHeadache Days Treatment Month 216 Participants
FrovatriptanParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmHeadache Days Treatment Month 213 Participants
FrovatriptanParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmMigraine Attacks Treatment Month 113 Participants
FrovatriptanParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmMigraine Attacks Treatment Month 215 Participants
FrovatriptanParticipants With Greater Than 50% Reduction in Migraine Attacks and Headache Days Per Month Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmHeadache Days Treatment Month 19 Participants
Secondary

Quality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment Paradigm

Quality of Life is measured by the Migraine Specific Quality of Life Questionnaire (MSQ), which includes 3 dimensions: Role Function Restrictive (degree to which performance of daily activities is limited), Role Function Preventive (degree to which performance of daily activities is interrupted), and Emotional Function (frustration and helplessness due to migraine). Scores range from 0 to 100. For each dimension, a higher score indicates a better health status. Participants completed the MSQ at Randomization, and after Treatment Months 1 and 2.

Time frame: Randomization, End of Treatment Month 1, End of Treatment Month 2

ArmMeasureGroupValue (MEAN)Dispersion
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Restrictive - Treatment Month 180.29 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 19.33
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Preventive - Treatment Month 293.95 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 7.57
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Preventive - Baseline77.75 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 16.02
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmEmotional Function - Baseline60.67 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 22.47
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Restrictive - Treatment Month 286.64 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 13.98
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmEmotional Function - Treatment Month 180.00 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 25.68
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Preventive - Treatment Month 185.25 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 18.32
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmEmotional Function - Treatment Month 291.46 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 10.49
TopiramateQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Restrictive - Baseline56.00 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 15.88
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmEmotional Function - Treatment Month 275.10 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 24.04
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Restrictive - Baseline59.88 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 16.65
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Restrictive - Treatment Month 166.48 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 18.75
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Restrictive - Treatment Month 271.84 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 19.57
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Preventive - Baseline77.50 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 18.53
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Preventive - Treatment Month 179.25 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 21.96
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmRole Function Preventive - Treatment Month 284.96 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 16.67
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmEmotional Function - Baseline64.71 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 23.13
FrovatriptanQuality of Life in Subjects Utilizing Each Treatment ParadigmEmotional Function - Treatment Month 173.18 Score on a ScaleStandard Deviation 21.59

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026