Scar Prevention, Scar Reduction
Conditions
Keywords
AZX100, Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale, POSAS, Visual Analog Scale, VAS, Trocar, Scarring, Scar reduction, Scar prevention
Brief summary
The purpose of this study was to determine the safety of AZX100 Drug Product and to determine whether it was effective in preventing or reducing scars that were made from trocars following arthroscopic shoulder surgery.
Interventions
Patients in the Placebo-only arm were dosed intradermally with placebo (saline) in three trocar sites on Day 9 (plus/minus 2 days) and Day 21 (plus/minus 2 days) after arthroscopic shoulder surgery. In the AZX100-placebo arm, 3 or 10 mg or placebo (saline) was administered intradermally at each of three trocar sites on each patient 9 ± 2 days and 21 ± 2 days after arthroscopic surgery. The three trocar sites (anterior, lateral, and posterior sides of the shoulder) were randomized to receive the same dose of study agent for both dose administrations.
AZX100 Drug Product 3 or 10 mg or placebo (saline) was administered intradermally at each of three trocar sites on each patient 9 ± 2 days and 21 ± 2 days after arthroscopic surgery. The three trocar sites (anterior, lateral, and posterior sides of the shoulder) were randomized to receive the same dose of study agent for both dose administrations.
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
* Scheduled for an arthroscopic shoulder surgery that will result in at least 3 trocar sites * Healthy male or non-pregnant female 18-75 years old * Non-diabetic * Body Mass Index 18-35 * No clinically significant abnormal values on blood test * Non-smoker for previous 6 months
Exclusion criteria
* History of acute or chronic disease * Cancer within previous 5 years, except for removed skin cancer * Hypersensitivity reaction * Allergy to general anesthesia, lidocaine, or epinephrine * Current skin disorder other than folliculitis or acne * On therapy with steroids * On therapy with a drug that affects collagen synthesis * Positive for HIV or hepatitis * Positive urine test for nicotine * Positive blood test for anti-AZX100 antibodies * Participated in another clinical study within 60 days before enrollment * Gave blood within 7 days before dosing * Gave plasma within 3 days before dosing * Tattoo on the shoulder area * Applied any prescribed or over the counter agents to the shoulder within 14 days before dosing, or intend to use any scar improving product * Visited a tanning salon within 14 days before dosing * History of drug addiction or excessive use of alcohol
Design outcomes
Primary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 12 months | Efficacy was based on the difference between mean POSAS scores of placebo and 3 mg AZX100, and placebo and 10 mg AZX100 12 months after shoulder surgery. Three trocar sites were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg or AZX100 10 mg or placebo at 9 days and 21 days after shoulder surgery. PSAS results included patients' ratings on a scale of 1-10 (1 was normal skin or no complaints and 10 was the worst imaginable scar or the worst difference) for the following: Is the scar painful? Is the scar itching? Is the color of the scar different? Is the scar more stiff? Is the thickness of the scar different? Is the scar irregular? The possible minimum score was 6 and the maximum (worst) score was 60. OSAS results included observers' ratings on a scale of 1-10 (1 was normal skin and 10 was the worst scar imaginable) for vascularization, pigmentation, thickness, relief, and pliability. The possible minimum score was 5 and the possible maximum (worst) score was 50. |
Secondary
| Measure | Time frame | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 12 months | Three trocar sites were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or saline placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days after surgery. Twelve months after surgery, images of the trocar sites were longitudinally evaluated and rated using a standard 100 mm Visual Analog Scale (VAS) by two blinded independent dermatologists, with 0 being normal skin and 100 being the worst scar imaginable. Efficacy was based on the difference between VAS scores of placebo and 3 mg AZX100 and placebo and 10 mg AZX100 for each of the two raters separately. Data from both raters was not combined. |
| Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 12 months | Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. 3D digital photography of each trocar scar was used to calculate scar length, width, minimum elevation, and maximum elevation in millimeters (mm) at 12 months. The minimum elevation value was calculated as the lowest point of the scar below the interpolated smooth skin surface. This was always a negative number. Negative values (closer to zero) were more desirable. The maximum elevation value was the highest point of the scar above the interpolated smooth skin surface. A smaller value was preferred. |
| Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 12 months | Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm, or AZX100 10 mg/cm, or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. 3D digital photography of each trocar scar was used to calculate positive volume, negative volume, and total volume in millimeters cubed (mm\^3) at 12 months. Positive volume included the scar volume that was calculated to be above the interpolated smooth skin surface. A smaller value was preferred. Negative volume included the volume of the scar calculated to be below the interpolated smooth skin surface. It was always a negative number; negative values (closer to zero) were more desirable. Total volume was calculated as the sum of positive volume and the absolute value of negative volume. Smaller values were more desirable. |
| Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 12 months | Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. A skin punch biopsy was taken of each trocar site at 12 months. The specimens were blindly scored in duplicate by a dermal pathologist for dermal collagen fiber density, maturity and orientation, where 0% was completely normal and 100% was completely abnormal. |
| Histological Evaluation of Number of Alpha Smooth Muscle Actin Cells | 12 months | Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. A skin punch biopsy was taken of each trocar site at 12 months. For exploratory purposes, the specimens were blindly scored in duplicate by a dermal pathologist for the estimated number of alpha-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA) positive cells per high powered field. Values ranged from 0 to several hundred. The number of α-SMA cells was assessed for exploratory purposes; therefore, at the time of this report, it was not known whether it was better to have a low or high α-SMA score. |
Countries
United States
Participant flow
Recruitment details
Enrollment in the study began in January 2009 and was completed in December 2009. All patients were enrolled in dermatological medical clinics.
Participants by arm
| Arm | Count |
|---|---|
| AZX100-Placebo Arm Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior will be randomized on each patient to receive one low dose of AZX100, one high dose of AZX100, or placebo. | 126 |
| Placebo-only Arm Three trocar sites on each patient will receive one dose of placebo. | 24 |
| Total | 150 |
Withdrawals & dropouts
| Period | Reason | FG000 | FG001 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Study | Lost to Follow-up | 7 | 1 |
| Overall Study | Withdrawal by Subject | 3 | 0 |
Baseline characteristics
| Characteristic | Placebo-only Arm | AZX100-Placebo Arm | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age, Categorical <=18 years | 0 Participants | 0 Participants | 0 Participants |
| Age, Categorical >=65 years | 5 Participants | 14 Participants | 19 Participants |
| Age, Categorical Between 18 and 65 years | 19 Participants | 112 Participants | 131 Participants |
| Age Continuous | 51.8 years STANDARD_DEVIATION 13.2 | 51.3 years STANDARD_DEVIATION 11.8 | 51.4 years STANDARD_DEVIATION 12 |
| Region of Enrollment United States | 24 participants | 126 participants | 150 participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Female | 7 Participants | 36 Participants | 43 Participants |
| Sex: Female, Male Male | 17 Participants | 90 Participants | 107 Participants |
Adverse events
| Event type | EG000 affected / at risk | EG001 affected / at risk |
|---|---|---|
| deaths Total, all-cause mortality | — / — | — / — |
| other Total, other adverse events | 125 / 126 | 21 / 24 |
| serious Total, serious adverse events | 8 / 126 | 2 / 24 |
Outcome results
Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores
Efficacy was based on the difference between mean POSAS scores of placebo and 3 mg AZX100, and placebo and 10 mg AZX100 12 months after shoulder surgery. Three trocar sites were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg or AZX100 10 mg or placebo at 9 days and 21 days after shoulder surgery. PSAS results included patients' ratings on a scale of 1-10 (1 was normal skin or no complaints and 10 was the worst imaginable scar or the worst difference) for the following: Is the scar painful? Is the scar itching? Is the color of the scar different? Is the scar more stiff? Is the thickness of the scar different? Is the scar irregular? The possible minimum score was 6 and the maximum (worst) score was 60. OSAS results included observers' ratings on a scale of 1-10 (1 was normal skin and 10 was the worst scar imaginable) for vascularization, pigmentation, thickness, relief, and pliability. The possible minimum score was 5 and the possible maximum (worst) score was 50.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: The efficacy analysis was based on patient data from the AZX100/Placebo cohort (i.e., not including the patients receiving placebo-only). In the ITT sample for the POSAS outcomes, available sample sizes were 122 at Day 42 and 113 at Month 12 (including 4 subjects who withdrew from the study but were still followed for safety until Month 12).
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 8.0 Units on a scale | Standard Deviation 4.1 |
| PSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 8.0 Units on a scale | Standard Deviation 4.7 |
| PSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 8.3 Units on a scale | Standard Deviation 5 |
| OSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 6.8 Units on a scale | Standard Deviation 2.7 |
| OSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 6.8 Units on a scale | Standard Deviation 2.5 |
| OSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Differences Among the 3 Dosage Groups in the Patient (PSAS) and Observer (OSAS) Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) Scores | 6.9 Units on a scale | Standard Deviation 2.5 |
Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width)
Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. 3D digital photography of each trocar scar was used to calculate scar length, width, minimum elevation, and maximum elevation in millimeters (mm) at 12 months. The minimum elevation value was calculated as the lowest point of the scar below the interpolated smooth skin surface. This was always a negative number. Negative values (closer to zero) were more desirable. The maximum elevation value was the highest point of the scar above the interpolated smooth skin surface. A smaller value was preferred.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: Efficacy analysis was based on patient data from the AZX100/Placebo cohort (i.e., not including patients receiving placebo-only). In the ITT sample for the scar objective measures, available sample sizes were 122 at Day 42 and 113 at Month 12 (including four subjects who withdrew from the study but were still followed for safety until Month 12).
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 8.75 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 4.12 |
| PSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 8.74 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 3.7 |
| PSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 9.59 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 3.84 |
| OSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 2.62 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 1.5 |
| OSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 2.59 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 1.31 |
| OSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 2.71 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 1.35 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | -0.26 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 0.19 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | -0.29 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 0.21 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | -0.27 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 0.2 |
| Scar Maximum Elevation for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 0.19 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 0.17 |
| Scar Maximum Elevation for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 0.18 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 0.13 |
| Scar Maximum Elevation for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Elevation, Length, Width) | 0.19 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 0.13 |
Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume)
Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm, or AZX100 10 mg/cm, or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. 3D digital photography of each trocar scar was used to calculate positive volume, negative volume, and total volume in millimeters cubed (mm\^3) at 12 months. Positive volume included the scar volume that was calculated to be above the interpolated smooth skin surface. A smaller value was preferred. Negative volume included the volume of the scar calculated to be below the interpolated smooth skin surface. It was always a negative number; negative values (closer to zero) were more desirable. Total volume was calculated as the sum of positive volume and the absolute value of negative volume. Smaller values were more desirable.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: Efficacy analysis was based on patient data from the AZX100/Placebo cohort (i.e., not including patients receiving placebo-only). In the ITT sample for the scar objective measures, available sample sizes were 122 at Day 42 and 113 at Month 12 (including four subjects who withdrew from the study but were still followed for safety until Month 12).
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 4.74 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 8.95 |
| PSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 4.05 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 4.25 |
| PSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 4.44 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 4.46 |
| OSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | -8.42 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 8.66 |
| OSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | -9.44 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 12.77 |
| OSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | -9.59 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 13.01 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 13.16 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 11.53 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 13.49 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 13.36 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Objective Measures Via 3D Photography (Volume) | 14.03 Millimeters cubed | Standard Deviation 13.68 |
Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography
Three trocar sites were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or saline placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days after surgery. Twelve months after surgery, images of the trocar sites were longitudinally evaluated and rated using a standard 100 mm Visual Analog Scale (VAS) by two blinded independent dermatologists, with 0 being normal skin and 100 being the worst scar imaginable. Efficacy was based on the difference between VAS scores of placebo and 3 mg AZX100 and placebo and 10 mg AZX100 for each of the two raters separately. Data from both raters was not combined.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: Efficacy analysis was based on patient data from the AZX100/Placebo cohort (i.e., not including patients receiving placebo-only). In the ITT sample for the VAS outcome, available sample sizes were 122 at Day 42 and 113 at Month 12 (including four subjects who withdrew from the study but were still followed for safety until Month 12).
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 10.96 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 8.58 |
| PSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 11.78 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 9.91 |
| PSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 11.86 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 7.21 |
| OSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 17.23 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 12.25 |
| OSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 17.49 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 11.66 |
| OSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Between-group Mean Differences in Visual Analog Scale Scores Rated by Independent Blinded Raters Using 3D Photography | 18.49 Millimeters | Standard Deviation 11.2 |
Histological Evaluation of Collagen
Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. A skin punch biopsy was taken of each trocar site at 12 months. The specimens were blindly scored in duplicate by a dermal pathologist for dermal collagen fiber density, maturity and orientation, where 0% was completely normal and 100% was completely abnormal.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: This analysis was based on patient data from the AZX100/Placebo cohort (i.e., not including patients receiving placebo-only). In the ITT sample for the histology analyses, available sample sizes were 122 at Day 42 and 113 at Month 12 (including four subjects who withdrew from the study but were still followed for safety until Month 12).
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 24.20 Percent | Standard Deviation 24.08 |
| PSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 19.43 Percent | Standard Deviation 21.79 |
| PSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 25.34 Percent | Standard Deviation 23.18 |
| OSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 22.72 Percent | Standard Deviation 23.59 |
| OSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 17.95 Percent | Standard Deviation 21.52 |
| OSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 23.64 Percent | Standard Deviation 22.68 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for Placebo Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 23.41 Percent | Standard Deviation 24.54 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 18.52 Percent | Standard Deviation 21.73 |
| Scar Minimum Elevation for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Collagen | 24.77 Percent | Standard Deviation 24 |
Histological Evaluation of Number of Alpha Smooth Muscle Actin Cells
Three trocar sites designated as anterior, lateral and posterior were randomized on each patient to receive AZX100 3 mg/cm or AZX100 10 mg/cm or placebo/cm at 9 days and 21 days following shoulder surgery. A skin punch biopsy was taken of each trocar site at 12 months. For exploratory purposes, the specimens were blindly scored in duplicate by a dermal pathologist for the estimated number of alpha-smooth muscle actin (α-SMA) positive cells per high powered field. Values ranged from 0 to several hundred. The number of α-SMA cells was assessed for exploratory purposes; therefore, at the time of this report, it was not known whether it was better to have a low or high α-SMA score.
Time frame: 12 months
Population: This analysis was based on patient data from the AZX100/Placebo cohort (i.e., not including patients receiving placebo-only). In the ITT sample for the histology analyses, available sample sizes were 122 at Day 42 and 113 at Month 12 (including four subjects who withdrew from the study but were still followed for safety until Month 12).
| Arm | Measure | Value (MEAN) | Dispersion |
|---|---|---|---|
| PSAS Results for Placebo Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Number of Alpha Smooth Muscle Actin Cells | 22.07 Cells per high-powered field | Standard Deviation 47.02 |
| PSAS Results for 3 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Number of Alpha Smooth Muscle Actin Cells | 24.78 Cells per high-powered field | Standard Deviation 58.25 |
| PSAS Results for 10 mg AZX100 Trocar Scars | Histological Evaluation of Number of Alpha Smooth Muscle Actin Cells | 32.80 Cells per high-powered field | Standard Deviation 64.56 |