Skip to content

Effects of Thiazide Diuretics on Sympathetic Nervous System in Hypertension

Neural Mechanisms of Thiazide-induced Insulin Resistance

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 4
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT00353652
Enrollment
166
Registered
2006-07-19
Start date
2005-01-31
Completion date
2013-01-31
Last updated
2019-02-06

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Hypertension

Keywords

Blood Pressure, High

Brief summary

Thiazide medications are often prescribed for individuals with high blood pressure, but research has shown that they may increase an individual's risk of developing diabetes. While it is unknown exactly how thiazide causes this response, it is likely that the nervous system is somehow involved. This study will evaluate the role of the nervous system in sugar metabolism, as well as determine the effect of thiazide and other medications on individuals with high blood pressure.

Detailed description

Thiazide medications, including chlorthalidone, are commonly prescribed for individuals with high blood pressure because they are inexpensive, effective at lowering blood pressure, and able to reduce the risk of heart failure and stroke. Despite these advantages, research has shown that thiazide medications may increase an individual's risk of developing diabetes. The exact mechanism that causes this remains unknown. Thiazide appears to increase sympathetic nervous system activity, thereby decreasing glucose reuptake and metabolism by skeletal muscle tissues. In turn, this tends to contribute to glucose intolerance and the development of diabetes. More research, however, is needed to confirm this link. Spironolactone, another blood pressure medication, does not pose the same risk for developing diabetes and may prove beneficial as a primary treatment for high blood pressure. The purpose of this study is to determine the role of the sympathetic nervous system in glucose metabolism in individuals with high blood pressure, as well as compare the effectiveness of thiazide, spironolactone, and other antihypertensive medications in reducing blood pressure. Results from this study may initiate the development of future clinical trials involving spironolactone as a primary treatment for reducing blood pressure. This study will enroll individuals with high blood pressure. Study# 1: All subjects were randomized to receive 3 months chlorthalidone (12.5-25 mg/d) or spironolactone (50-75 mg/d), using a single-blind 2-phase crossover design without washout between treatments. Each subject was followed every 4 wk for measurement of 24-h ambulatory BP and serum potassium (K). The doses of chlorthalidone and spironolactone were titrated to achieve 24-h ambulatory BP of less than 130/80mmHg in the same subject. During chlorthalidone treatment period, subject was given oral K supplementation according to a sliding scale to maintain serum K from 4.0-4.5 mmol/liter. Then, sympathetic nerve activity (SNA) is measured after 3 months of chlorthalidone and after 3 months of spironolactone. Arterial baroreflex sensitivity, glucose, and insulin are measured at baseline, after 3 months of chlorthalidone, and after 3 months of spironolactone. Insulin sensitivity will be measured using HOMA-IR. Study #2: All subjects are randomized to 3 months of fixed-dose Chlorthalidone 25 mg once daily alone, fixed-dose Chlorthalidone 25 mg once daily plus fixed-dose Spironolactone 25 mg once daily, and fixed-dose Chlorthalidone 25 mg once daily plus fixed-dose Irbesartan 150 mg once daily, using a single-blind 3-phase crossover design without washout between treatments. Then, SNA , Arterial baroreflex sensitivity, glucose, and insulin are measured after 3 months of each treatment phase.

Interventions

DRUGStudy#1: chlorthalidone (CTD), titrated dose

Participants in study #1 will receive 3 months of chlorthalidone (12.5-25 mg/d) at the dose titrated to achieve 24-h ambulatory BP \< 130/80 mmHg

DRUGStudy #1: spironolactone (SP), titrated dose

Participants in study #1 will receive 3 months spironolactone (25-75 mg/d), at the dose titrated to achieve 24-h ambulatory BP \< 130/80 mmHg.

DRUGStudy# 2 chlorthalidone (CTD), fixed dose

Participants in study #2 will receive 3 months of fixed-dose of CTD, at 25 mg/d.

DRUGStudy# 2 spironolactone (SP), fixed dose

Participants in study #2 will receive 3 months of fixed-dose SP at 25 mg daily.

DRUGStudy# 2 irbsesartan (IR), fixed dose

Participants in study #2 will receive 3 months of fixed-dose IR at150 mg daily.

Sponsors

National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI)
CollaboratorNIH
University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center
Lead SponsorOTHER

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
CROSSOVER
Primary purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)

Masking description

Capsule was made to appear identical in appearance so that subjects are blinded to treatment assigned.

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 65 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

* Untreated stage 1 primary hypertension (systolic blood pressure between 140 to 159 mm Hg and diastolic blood pressure between 90 to 99 mm Hg)

Exclusion criteria

* Cardiopulmonary disease, as determined by medical history or by physical examination * Serum creatinine greater than or equal to 1.5 mg/dL * Diabetes mellitus or other systemic illness * Left ventricular hypertrophy by echocardiography or ECG * Hypersensitivity to chlorthalidone, spironolactone, eplerenone, angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, angiotensin receptor blocker, insulin, Evans blue dye, or clonidine * History of substance abuse (other than tobacco) * History of gouty arthritis * History of ACE inhibitor-induced cough or angioedema * Evidence of secondary hypertension * Pregnant

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frame
Sympathetic Nerve ActivityMeasured at 3 months

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood PressureMeasured at 3 months
Insulin3 monthsfasting plasma insulin
HOMA-IR3 monthsassessment of insulin resistance calculated by multiplying fasting plasma insulin (mU/l) with fasting plasma glucose (mmol/l) divided by 22.5.
Sympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity3 monthsslope relating percent change in SNA (% change in total activity from baseline) to diastolic BP.

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Pre-assignment details

119 subjects failed screening. 30 patients undergo 2-phase crossover study (chlorthalidone vs. spironolactone). 7 patients dropped out, 23 subjects completed study#1. 17 subjects undergo 3-phase study (chlorthalidone+placebo, chlorthalidone+spironolactone, and chlorthalidone+ irbesartan). 1 patients dropped out. 16 subjects completed study#2.

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Participants Study#1
study #1 has 2 arms. Arm 1. chlorthalidone (CTD) first then spironolactone (SP): subjects are randomized to receive 3 months of CTD first (12.5-25 mg/d), titrated to achieve 24-h BP \< 130/80 mmHg. Then, the subject is transitioned to treatment with spironolactone (25-75 mg/d) without washout period for 3 months. Following 3 month treatment period, sympathetic nerve activity, 24 h-ambulatory BP, fasting plasma glucose, insulin, HOMA IR, and baroreflex sensitivity are measured. After completion of the study procedures, the medication is discontinued. Arm 2. spironolactone (SP) first, then chlorthalidone (CTD): subjects are randomized to receive 3 months spironolactone first (25-75 mg/d), titrated to achieve 24-h BP \< 130/80 mmHg. Then, the subject is switched to CTD (12.5-25 mg/d) without washout period. Following 3 month treatment period, sympathetic nerve activity, 24 h-ambulatory BP, fasting plasma glucose, insulin, HOMA IR, and baroreflex sensitivity are measured.
30
Participants Study#2
study #2 has 6 arms. Arm 1. CTD alone 1st, CTD+ SP 2nd, CTD+IR 3rd: Subjects are randomized to receive 3 months of fixed-dose chlorthalidone (CTD, 25 mg/d) alone first, using a single-blind 3-phase crossover design. Then, subjects are treated with fixed-dose CTD (25 mg/d) plus fixed-dosespironolactone (SP) 25 mg daily for 3 months, then fixed-dose CTD (25 mg/d) plus fixed-dose irbsesartan (IR, 150 mg daily) for 3 months. Arm 2. fixed-dose CTD alone 1st, CTD+IR 2nd, CTD+SP3rd Arm3. fixed-dose CTD+SP1st, CTD alone 2nd, CTD+IR 3rd Arm 4. fixed-dose CTD+SP1st, CTD+IR 2nd, CTD alone 3rd Arm 5. CTD+IR 1st, CTD alone 2nd, CTD+SP 3rd Arm 6. CTD+IR 1st, CTD+SP 2nd, CTD alone 3rd
17
Total47

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicParticipants Study#1Participants Study#2Total
Age, Continuous49.3 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 2
50.6 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 2.3
49.7 years
STANDARD_DEVIATION 2.2
Region of Enrollment
United States
30 participants17 participants47 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
9 Participants4 Participants13 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
21 Participants13 Participants34 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
EG002
affected / at risk
EG003
affected / at risk
EG004
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 260 / 270 / 170 / 170 / 17
other
Total, other adverse events
1 / 260 / 270 / 170 / 170 / 17
serious
Total, serious adverse events
0 / 260 / 270 / 170 / 170 / 17

Outcome results

Primary

Sympathetic Nerve Activity

Time frame: Measured at 3 months

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Study#1: Chlorthalidone (CTD), Titrated DoseSympathetic Nerve Activity46 bursts/minStandard Error 4
Study #1: Spironolactone (SP), Titrated DoseSympathetic Nerve Activity40 bursts/minStandard Error 3
Study# 2 Chlorthalidone (CTD), Fixed DoseSympathetic Nerve Activity49 bursts/minStandard Error 3
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus SP Fixed DoseSympathetic Nerve Activity42 bursts/minStandard Error 3
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus IR Fixed DoseSympathetic Nerve Activity52 bursts/minStandard Error 2
Secondary

24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood Pressure

Time frame: Measured at 3 months

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Study#1: Chlorthalidone (CTD), Titrated Dose24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood Pressure127.4 mmHgStandard Error 2
Study #1: Spironolactone (SP), Titrated Dose24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood Pressure128.6 mmHgStandard Error 2
Study# 2 Chlorthalidone (CTD), Fixed Dose24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood Pressure123.5 mmHgStandard Error 2
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus SP Fixed Dose24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood Pressure121.6 mmHgStandard Error 3
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus IR Fixed Dose24-hour Ambulatory Systolic Blood Pressure119.8 mmHgStandard Error 3
Secondary

HOMA-IR

assessment of insulin resistance calculated by multiplying fasting plasma insulin (mU/l) with fasting plasma glucose (mmol/l) divided by 22.5.

Time frame: 3 months

Population: unequal randomization by chance

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
Study#1: Chlorthalidone (CTD), Titrated DoseHOMA-IR1.91 mU/l*mmol/l
Study #1: Spironolactone (SP), Titrated DoseHOMA-IR1.33 mU/l*mmol/l
Study# 2 Chlorthalidone (CTD), Fixed DoseHOMA-IR1.87 mU/l*mmol/l
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus SP Fixed DoseHOMA-IR0.85 mU/l*mmol/l
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus IR Fixed DoseHOMA-IR1.42 mU/l*mmol/l
Secondary

Insulin

fasting plasma insulin

Time frame: 3 months

ArmMeasureValue (MEDIAN)
Study#1: Chlorthalidone (CTD), Titrated DoseInsulin8.24 mU/liter
Study #1: Spironolactone (SP), Titrated DoseInsulin7.6 mU/liter
Study# 2 Chlorthalidone (CTD), Fixed DoseInsulin7.6 mU/liter
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus SP Fixed DoseInsulin4.87 mU/liter
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus IR Fixed DoseInsulin6.8 mU/liter
Secondary

Sympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity

slope relating percent change in SNA (% change in total activity from baseline) to diastolic BP.

Time frame: 3 months

ArmMeasureValue (MEAN)Dispersion
Study#1: Chlorthalidone (CTD), Titrated DoseSympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity-9.1 % change from baseline per mmHgStandard Deviation 3.8
Study #1: Spironolactone (SP), Titrated DoseSympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity-15.2 % change from baseline per mmHgStandard Deviation 3.2
Study# 2 Chlorthalidone (CTD), Fixed DoseSympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity-12.9 % change from baseline per mmHgStandard Deviation 7.8
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus SP Fixed DoseSympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity-11.3 % change from baseline per mmHgStandard Deviation 8.8
Study# 2 CTD Fixed Dose 25 mg/d Plus IR Fixed DoseSympathetic Baroreflex Sensitivity-12.0 % change from baseline per mmHgStandard Deviation 7

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026