Skip to content

Comparison of Full-dose Flu Vaccine to Half-dose Flu Vaccine

Clinical Study to Compare the Immune Response of Half Dose Trivalent Inactivated Influenza Vaccine (TIV) to Full Dose

Status
Completed
Phases
Phase 2
Study type
Interventional
Source
ClinicalTrials.gov
Registry ID
NCT00283283
Enrollment
1316
Registered
2006-01-27
Start date
2004-11-30
Completion date
2006-05-31
Last updated
2021-02-12

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

Influenza

Keywords

Influenza

Brief summary

This study compared full-dose Flu vaccine to half-dose Flu-vaccine during the 2004-2005 flu season.

Detailed description

This was a Phase II prospective, single-blind to dose, randomized study that compared the immunogenicity of subjects receiving half-dose Fluzone® compared to full-dose Fluzone®, 2004-2005 formulation. 1440 healthy subjects, ages 18-64 years old and not currently indicated for influenza vaccination under the interim ACIP guidelines, were divided into 8 strata based on age, gender, and previous exposure to influenza vaccine, and randomized to receive either half-dose (0.25mL) Fluzone® or full-dose (0.5mL) Fluzone® by intramuscular injection into the deltoid muscle.

Interventions

BIOLOGICALFluzone® (Aventis Pasteur inactivated influenza vaccine)

A/H1N1, A/New Caledonia/20/99; A/H3N2, A/Fujian/411/2002; B, B/Shanghai/361/2002

Sponsors

Walter Reed Army Medical Center
CollaboratorFED
United States Army Medical Materiel Development Activity
CollaboratorFED
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
CollaboratorFED
Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences
CollaboratorFED
Walter Reed Army Institute of Research (WRAIR)
CollaboratorFED
U.S. Air Force Office of the Surgeon General
CollaboratorFED
U.S. Army Medical Research and Development Command
Lead SponsorFED

Study design

Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Intervention model
PARALLEL
Primary purpose
PREVENTION
Masking
SINGLE (Subject)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
ALL
Age
18 Years to 64 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

* Able to understand and comply with all study procedures including availability for all study visits and follow up surveys within 6 months following study enrollment. * DEERS eligible beneficiaries eligible for influenza vaccination and able to give informed consent. * Age 18-49 * Patients presenting to travel clinic with no

Exclusion criteria

; * Household contacts and out-of-home caretakers of infants from 6-23 months of age; * Hospital and/or employees providing service to the public who are not eligible for the post-October 5th recommendations for priority immunization; * DOD employees eligible for influenza vaccination prior to October 5th but excluded in the post October 5th guidelines; * People living in dormitories or under other crowded conditions, to prevent outbreaks; * Ages 50-64 years of age who are not eligible for the post-October 5th recommendations for priority immunization and with no standard of care contraindications to vaccination. * Eligible in the Department of Defense for influenza vaccination

Design outcomes

Primary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Immune Response: Age 18-4921 days post-vaccincationImmune response as measured by viral strain specific hemaggluttination inhibition (HAI) antibody levels for subjects ages 18-49
Immune Response: Age 50-6421 days post-vaccincationImmune response as measured by viral strain specific hemaggluttination inhibition (HAI) antibody levels for subjects ages 50-64

Secondary

MeasureTime frameDescription
Medical Events: Unsolicited Adverse Events3 - 6 months following vaccinationAssessed through following subjects' recording of oral body temperature, completion of a 21-day symptom diary; subjects' completion of longer-term follow-up surveys to track respiratory symptoms; and a review of the Defense Medical Surveillance System (DMSS) hospitalization and outpatient medical visits database in order to track ICD-9 codes relevant to flu-like illness.

Other

MeasureTime frameDescription
Race/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureEnrollment DayRace/ethnicity data was only collected by age and cannot be separated out by dose as per the other Baseline Measures

Countries

United States

Participant flow

Recruitment details

Study participants were recruited at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center Allergy-Immunization Clinic, the Fort Belvoir DeWitt Allergy-Immunization Clinic and the Pentagon Health Clinic during the annual influenza immunization program.

Pre-assignment details

Enrollment was expanded to include subs with a history of flu vacs. From the originally enrolled subjects (1316), the final data analysis includes only members of the baseline re-vaccination population (1114).

Participants by arm

ArmCount
Full Dose, Age 18-49
Previously Vaccinated Subjects Receiving Full Dose Aged 18-49 Years
274
Half Dose, Age 18-49
Previously Vaccinated Subjects Receiving Half Dose Aged 18-49 Years
284
Full Dose, Age 50-64
Previously Vaccinated Subjects Receiving Full Dose Aged 50-64 Years
280
Half Dose, Age 50-64
Previously Vaccinated Subjects Receiving Half Dose Aged 50-64 Years
276
Total1,114

Baseline characteristics

CharacteristicFull Dose, Age 18-49Half Dose, Age 18-49Full Dose, Age 50-64Half Dose, Age 50-64Total
Age, Customized274 years284 years280 years276 years1114 years
Region of Enrollment
United States
274 participants284 participants280 participants276 participants1114 participants
Sex: Female, Male
Female
126 Participants121 Participants119 Participants118 Participants484 Participants
Sex: Female, Male
Male
148 Participants163 Participants161 Participants158 Participants630 Participants

Adverse events

Event typeEG000
affected / at risk
EG001
affected / at risk
deaths
Total, all-cause mortality
0 / 5540 / 556
other
Total, other adverse events
18 / 55417 / 556
serious
Total, serious adverse events
2 / 5541 / 556

Outcome results

Primary

Immune Response: Age 18-49

Immune response as measured by viral strain specific hemaggluttination inhibition (HAI) antibody levels for subjects ages 18-49

Time frame: 21 days post-vaccincation

Population: From the 1263 subjects enrolled, final analysis includes baseline re-vaccinated subs who fit all inc/exc criteria and whose serum specimens were usable. Data summarizes the differences in influenza strain specific serologic responses according to vaccine dose and age. Antibodies were measured by Hemagglutination Inhibition. GMT=Geometric Mean Titer

ArmMeasureGroupValue (GEOMETRIC_MEAN)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseImmune Response: Age 18-49H1N1 - GMT28.8 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseImmune Response: Age 18-49H3N2 - GMT55.2 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseImmune Response: Age 18-49B - GMT69.6 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseImmune Response: Age 18-49H1N1 - GMT21.3 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseImmune Response: Age 18-49H3N2 - GMT45.0 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseImmune Response: Age 18-49B - GMT54.8 Anti-body response (GMT)
Primary

Immune Response: Age 50-64

Immune response as measured by viral strain specific hemaggluttination inhibition (HAI) antibody levels for subjects ages 50-64

Time frame: 21 days post-vaccincation

Population: From the 1263 subjects enrolled, final analysis includes baseline re-vaccinated subs who fit all inc/exc criteria and whose serum specimens were usable. Data summarizes the differences in influenza strain specific serologic responses according to vaccine dose and age. Antibodies were measured by Hemagglutination Inhibition. GMT=Geometric Mean Titer

ArmMeasureGroupValue (GEOMETRIC_MEAN)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseImmune Response: Age 50-64H1N1 - GMT21.4 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseImmune Response: Age 50-64H3N2 - GMT59.0 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseImmune Response: Age 50-64B - GMT52.1 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseImmune Response: Age 50-64H1N1 - GMT14.2 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseImmune Response: Age 50-64H3N2 - GMT39.1 Anti-body response (GMT)
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseImmune Response: Age 50-64B - GMT36.8 Anti-body response (GMT)
Secondary

Medical Events: Unsolicited Adverse Events

Assessed through following subjects' recording of oral body temperature, completion of a 21-day symptom diary; subjects' completion of longer-term follow-up surveys to track respiratory symptoms; and a review of the Defense Medical Surveillance System (DMSS) hospitalization and outpatient medical visits database in order to track ICD-9 codes relevant to flu-like illness.

Time frame: 3 - 6 months following vaccination

Population: Of the original population, 1203 previously vaccinated subjects completed the 3-day post vaccination side effects diary and have been included in the this analysis.

ArmMeasureGroupValue (NUMBER)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsRespiratory System10 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSkin and Appendages14 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsBody as a Whole0 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsUrogenital System0 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHematological and Lymphatic System2 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSymptions in Arm Given Shot13 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHeadache0 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsDigestive Sytem12 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSpecial Senses2 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsMusculoskeletal System6 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsCardiovascular System2 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsMusculoskeletal System5 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSkin and Appendages8 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsRespiratory System18 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsCardiovascular System2 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsBody as a Whole6 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSymptions in Arm Given Shot1 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsDigestive Sytem3 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHeadache2 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsUrogenital System4 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHematological and Lymphatic System0 Adverse events
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSpecial Senses2 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsRespiratory System5 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsBody as a Whole1 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsCardiovascular System0 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsDigestive Sytem2 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHematological and Lymphatic System1 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsMusculoskeletal System1 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSkin and Appendages1 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSpecial Senses0 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsUrogenital System0 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSymptions in Arm Given Shot0 Adverse events
Severe, Able to WorkMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHeadache1 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHematological and Lymphatic System0 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsBody as a Whole3 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsCardiovascular System0 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHeadache1 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSymptions in Arm Given Shot0 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsDigestive Sytem4 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsRespiratory System3 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSpecial Senses1 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsUrogenital System0 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsMusculoskeletal System1 Adverse events
Severe, Lost ProductivityMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSkin and Appendages0 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsBody as a Whole1193 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSkin and Appendages1180 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHematological and Lymphatic System1200 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSpecial Senses1198 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsDigestive Sytem1182 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsHeadache1199 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsUrogenital System1199 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsCardiovascular System1199 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsSymptions in Arm Given Shot1189 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsRespiratory System1167 Adverse events
No EventsMedical Events: Unsolicited Adverse EventsMusculoskeletal System1190 Adverse events
Other Pre-specified

Race/Ethnicity Baseline Measure

Race/ethnicity data was only collected by age and cannot be separated out by dose as per the other Baseline Measures

Time frame: Enrollment Day

ArmMeasureGroupValue (COUNT_OF_PARTICIPANTS)
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureAfrican American54 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureAsian14 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureWhite454 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureOther/unknown10 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Full DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureHispanic16 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureOther/unknown6 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureWhite491 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureAfrican American46 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureHispanic6 Participants
Age 18 - 49, Half DoseRace/Ethnicity Baseline MeasureAsian7 Participants

Source: ClinicalTrials.gov · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026