Skip to content

Comparison of learning focused cardiac ultrasound between self-directed and proctored simulator teaching

Non-inferiority trial of image acquisition for teaching focused cardiac ultrasound to medical students with and without a supervised training workshop.

Status
Completed
Phases
Unknown
Study type
Interventional
Source
ANZCTR
Registry ID
ACTRN12619000172101
Acronym
SIMTEACH3
Enrollment
138
Registered
2019-02-06
Start date
2019-05-01
Completion date
2020-07-10
Last updated
2025-12-08

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

None listed

Brief summary

Physician-performed focused cardiac ultrasound (FCU) is established in anaesthesia and critical practice and is increasingly taught in undergraduate medicine curricula. The most important barrier to adoption, reported by Conlin (Conlin et al., Anesth Analg 2017;125:1878–82) was lack of training opportunity, and identifies a strong need for a scalable teaching process that provides acceptable learning outcomes The traditional training model for FCU is a combination of didactic learning followed by proctored practical teaching of ultrasound image acquisition with FCU trainers (eg. iHeartScan, University of Melbourne), who are in short supply. Reliability on trainers restricts training to participants who can access the limited number of courses. Ultrasound simulators are increasingly adopted by medical institutions to teach FCU. We have developed an FCU course that reduces the requirement for trainers from one and a half days to only three hours (FCU TTE Course) using a cloud-based platform that provides eLearning of knowledge base and instruction to participants on their personal device on how to teach themselves image acquisition using an ultrasound simulator. We have demonstrated that the simulator course was more effective in teaching FCU image acquisition (Canty et al. J Crit Care 2019;49:38–44). This reduction in trainer time required to teach FCU increases the capacity for training FCU, however is still significantly restricted by the 3-hour proctored session. We have recently eliminated the requirement for trainers by replacing the 3-hour proctored learning session with an eLearning package and on-line automated assessment. The aim of this study is to determine whether the learning of image acquisition skills by medical students who complete the self-directed simulator course is non-inferior to students not exposed to the course, and to determine if the learning of cardiovascular clinical examination of patients with cardiac disease is improved. Justification and expected benefits There is increasing demand for FCU training and for this to begin in medical school. An entirely self-directed FCU teaching course that also course improves the learning of cardiovascular clinical examination would be a significant step to answering this demand.

Interventions

Arm1 - focused cardiac ultrasound simulator course that has the 3-hour proctored workshop replaced with an on-line self directed learning package a) This package contains text, figures, videos, and automatically marked multiple choice question (MCQ) review test b) The intervention is delivered as part of the course reading material and is performed before the ultrasound simulator training. The estimated time taken to complete the intervention is 1 hour. c) There are no restrictions on access to

Arm1 - focused cardiac ultrasound simulator course that has the 3-hour proctored workshop replaced with an on-line self directed learning package a) This package contains text, figures, videos, and automatically marked multiple choice question (MCQ) review test b) The intervention is delivered as part of the course reading material and is performed before the ultrasound simulator training. The estimated time taken to complete the intervention is 1 hour. c) There are no restrictions on access to the intervention, the online material can be accessed by a secure server (unique username and password for each participant) indefinitely as the resource is required to be reviewed during the ultrasound simulator practical training phase of the course d) The delivery (completion by each participant) of the intervention will monitored and ensured completed for every participant by checking completion using the administrative database. To complete the intervention each participant must obtain an adequate passmark (>=80%) in the online tutorial self assessment MCQ test. These results are automatically recorded in the administrative database.

Sponsors

University of Melbourne
Lead SponsorUniversity

Study design

Allocation
Randomised controlled trial
Intervention model
Parallel
Primary purpose
Educational / counselling / training
Masking
Open (masking not used)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
All
Age
18 Years to 60 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

Second year medical student at University of Melbourne 2019 rotating through the Austin Hospital.

Exclusion criteria

Nil

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ANZCTR · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026