None listed
Conditions
Brief summary
The primary purpose of this study is to conduct a series of Single Case Experimental Designs (SCEDs) that compare the effectiveness of conservative multimodal physiotherapy in reducing daily neck pain and improving self-efficacy whilst performing daily activities in individuals with Chronic Whiplash Disorder (WAD), in 3 individuals with Post Traumatic Stress Symptoms (PTSS) and 3 individuals without PTSS. The hypothesis is that multimodal conservative physiotherapy when performed in individuals without PTSS will be more effective in reducing daily neck pain intensity and improving self-efficacy whilst performing daily activities when compared to individuals with PTSS. This multiple baseline design study has several dependent variables that are measure simultaneously - including the Neck Disability Index, the Depression Anxiety and Stress Scale, EQ-5D-5L, the Pain Catastrophising scale, patient specific questions based on a self efficacy questionnaire and the Global Impression of Change scale. The intervention is introduced in a staggered sequence. Thus, at different stages of the study some tiers will be in the baseline (A) phase and others will be in the intervention (B) phase. This study will utilise an A1-B-A2 design to measure the effectiveness of a standard multimodal conservative physiotherapy intervention across the three phases: a baseline phase with no intervention (A1), intervention phase (B) and lastly a no intervention phase with follow-up (A2). The onset of the intervention start point will be randomly allocated, with two participants starting at day 5, another two on day 8 and the last two on day 11. During this 4 week intervention period, participants will have 8 one hour sessions of physiotherapy treatment. Afterwards, there will be a 4 week follow-up phase where the participants will have no contact with the intervention personnel, in order to determine the possible duration of improvement post intervention.
Interventions
Advice booklet All patients will be provided with an advice booklet Whiplash Injury Recovery: A Self Help Guide (2nd edition), co-authored by Prof Sterling and published by the Motor Accident Insurance Commission (MAIC), Qld. It provides information about whiplash, assurance about prognosis and advice to stay active and resume working; as well as information on correct posture, with pictorial descriptions of specific neck and upper limbs exercises and information on resuming functional daily activities. This second edition of the booklet was written based on consumer and health care professional feedback via focus groups. The booklet is based on the recommendations of the current Australian Guidelines for Whiplash Management (TRACsa, 2008). Conservative Multimodal Physiotherapy The 4-week exercise program will be carried out by the honors students under the supervision of the experienced physiotherapist (2 sessions per week). The exercise program will comprise specific exercises to improve the movement and control of the neck and shoulder girdle. Exercises will be tailored by the physiotherapist for each individual participant. The exercises will be of a low load nature and designed to be pain free. At the same time, the physiotherapist will guide the participant’s return to normal activities. The program begins with a clinical examination of the cervical and axio-scapular-girdle muscles and includes tests that assess an individual’s ability to recruit the muscles in a coordinated manner, and tests of muscle endurance at low levels of maximum voluntary contraction. The specific impairments identified are then addressed with an exercise program that is supervised and progressed by the physiotherapist. This specific treatment program as described in Jull et al (2008) focuses on activating and improving the coordination and endurance capacity of neck flexor, extensor and scapular muscles in specific exercises and functional tasks, and a graded program directed to the postural control system including exercises for balance, head relocation and eye movement control. Participants will also perform the exercises at home, once per day. Written and illustrated exercise instructions will be provided. A log book will be completed by participants to record compliance with the exercises. The exercise program follows the current Australian guidelines for the management of chronic whiplash (TRACsa, 2008). Physiotherapists providing the intervention and control Physiotherapy honours students who successfully complete a face-to-face, trial specific training workshop run by Prof Michele Sterling (MS) will provide the therapeutic interventions for this study. They will be supervised by a physiotherapist experienced in the management of whiplash injured individuals. The physiotherapy exercise sessions will be audited twice per honours student/physiotherapist (face to face by MS) to check for adherence to the exercise protocol.
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
Individuals with Whiplash Associated Disorder. > 12 weeks since injury. Aged 35 -65 years. Neck pain on numerical pain rating scale >= 5/10. Neck Disability Index at start of trial > 28%. Three individuals with moderate post-traumatic stress symptoms (revised Impact of Events Scale score > 24) and 3 individuals with minimal or no PTSS (r-IES < 20).
Exclusion criteria
Known or suspected serious spinal pathology (e.g. metastatic disease of the spine). Spinal surgery in the past 12 months. History of any mental health conditions such as bipolar disorder, psychosis, schizophrenia Score of 10 or more on the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9). Not fluent in English.