None listed
Conditions
Brief summary
Hypermobility Spectrum Disorder is characterized by generalized joint hypermobility and musculoskeletal pain (Pacey 2014) and is now the recommended name for the condition previously referred to as Joint Hypermobility Syndrome (Castori 2017). It is diagnosed using the Beighton Scale, in individuals presenting with 6/9 hypermobile joints in addition to at least one painful joint for at least 3 months following exclusion of other heritable connective tissue disorders such as Ehlers Danlos Syndrome (Malfait 2017). The prevalence of Hypermobility Spectrum Disorder in children is variably reported, ranging from 2% to 64% depending on age, ethnicity and the defining criteria used (Murray 2006). Children with HSD experience a range of chronic symptoms and life impacts including: • Joint laxity which can lead to bony subluxations and dislocations and chronic joint instability. • Pain in joints or surrounding muscles and soft tissue. • Deconditioning of musculature surrounding joints causing ongoing exacerbation of symptoms. • Limited endurance with mobility and physical activities such as walking longer distances or negotiating stairs which impacts function at school and in the community. • Poor school attendance due to chronic pain which impacts negatively on academic learning. • Reduced, or absent participation in physical activity leading to poorer health outcomes such as bony development and cardiovascular fitness. • Any of the above factors can cause personal distress, decreased social interaction and isolation which can lead to mental health issues including anxiety and depression. Recent research has suggested that providing a physiotherapist-led exercise program is significantly effective in reducing pain, improving health-related quality of life, and increasing muscle strength in children with HSD and knee pain (Pacey 2013). However, it was also noted that there is limited research evidence about optimal type of exercise in adults and even less research available regarding children. This study focuses on researching the potential benefits of Physiotherapy-led Pilates as an effective alternative exercise program helpful in the management of children with HSD. The study design will involve a single case experimental design (SCED), with repeated measures during baseline and treatment phases, and a multiple baseline design (MBD) for the introduction of treatment to allow a smaller number of subjects to be studied in greater detail to provide a high level of evidence (Level II). The study hypothesis is that the study will show that: a) Children and young people will show a decrease in pain and an increase in their strength and endurance, which will improve their ability to participate in everyday activities such as school, sport and social activities. b) This improvement will be maintained for a period of at least 3 months following the intervention.
Interventions
The Pilates program will be designed and delivered by the chief researcher who is (i) an experienced physiotherapist with over 30 years clinical experience in paediatric physiotherapy and (ii) an accredited Pilates instructor for the past 15 years. The program will be provided on an individualized basis and include a structured combination of Pilates exercises performed on mat or Pilates equipment that is provided at an appropriate level and age for each child. Exercises will focus on basic muscle activation and patterns of movement that are the essential basis of Pilates. As pain is decreased and children improve in strength, body awareness and confidence, they will be progressed to a more challenging level of difficulty. The intervention will be provided for 45 minutes, 2 times per week for 8 weeks with a home program of 45 minutes to be performed on one additional day under parental supervision. This will meet basic guidelines for physical activity and strength training. Each session is divided into sections to focus on specific body areas. Section 1: Warm up (5 minutes) Prepares the body for work and is typically a selection of mat exercises that involve trunk movement. Some examples are 'the roll down' and 'pelvic curl'. Section 2: Regional Muscle training (30 minutes) Includes specific areas of the body to ensure a complete body program: - Foot work -develops the strength of muscles surrounding the knee, ankle and feet eg 'calf raises' in standing or 'prances' on the reformer. - Abdominal work -focuses on specifically developing the abdominal muscles even though the abdominals are engaged throughout the session eg 'chest lift' on the mat or 'hundred prep' on the reformer. - Hip work -works on control of the hip joint an control of the pelvic- lumbar region eg 'leg circle' on the mat and 'hip circle down' with legs in straps on the reformer. - Spinal articulation -works on spinal mobility and developing control of the deeper trunk muscles eg 'rolling like a ball' on the mat or 'bottom lift' on the reformer. - Arm work -works various muscle groups in the arm and shoulder girdle eg 'front support' on the mat or 'triceps' with arms in straps on the reformer. - Leg work -focus on upper leg and hip strength eg 'side leg lift' on the mat or 'skating' on the reformer. - Lateral flexion and rotation -works on symmetry of the rotators and lateral flexors of the trunk eg 'spine twist' on the mat or 'mermaid' on the reformer. - Back extension -exercises of the back extensors eg 'back extension' on the mat or 'breaststroke prep' on the reformer. Section 3: Full body integration -specifically works on full body motion, balance and co- ordination eg 'single leg standing' on the mat or 'scooter' performed on the reformer . Section 4: Stretching and cool down (5 minutes) Specific stretches depending on the need of the individual eg 'hamstring stretch' on the mat or slow full trunk movement in standing such as 'roll down' focusing on slow deep breathing. At each session the Pilates instructor will record which exercises were performed, the number of repetitions, the equipment and amount of resistance used (number and colour of springs used on the reformer denotes whether mild, medium or heavy resistance). The parent will be invited to observe each session and a photograph of the child performing the exercises will be taken to personalize the home program along with a written sheet which will include particular focus exercises that need additional training. The home program will be composed of a number of mat exercises that continue to strengthen many parts of the body. One combination would be 'roll down', 'pelvic curl', 'chest lift', 'leg circles', 'side leg lifts', 'back extension', 'thread a needle', 'front support','single leg standing' and 'cat stretch'. If the child had difficulty with co-ordinating transverse abdominus (deep abdominal muscle) with the pelvic stability then some focus exercises would be to practice isolating transverse abdominus, then progressing to pelvic tilt while maintaining a transverse abdominus contraction before progressing to holding the transverse abdominus contraction with a 'pelvic curl' exercise With the home program the parent will mark down the number of each exercise performed, sign and return it at the next session so adherence to the program can be monitored.
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
1. Score of > than or equal to 6 on the Beighton Scale for hypermobility. 2. Score of > or equal to 1 painful joint felt at least 3 x/week for a 3 month period in the last 6 months.
Exclusion criteria
1. Other heritable disorders of connective tissue 2. Other syndromes or significant complex medical or neurological conditions (that may confound the outcomes) 3. Other intellectual impairment or behavioural disorders (that impact on their ability to follow instructions)