Skip to content

Manual therapy and stretching for neck pain

Manual therapy vs stretching exercises in treatment of chronic neck pain: a randomised controlled trial

Status
Completed
Phases
Unknown
Study type
Interventional
Source
ANZCTR
Registry ID
ACTRN12617000495325
Acronym
MT Neck Pain Study
Enrollment
60
Registered
2017-04-05
Start date
2017-06-08
Completion date
2017-08-01
Last updated
2017-10-16

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

None listed

Brief summary

Chronic neck pain is a common problem among the adult population in industrialized countries. The prognosis for chronic neck pain is poor, as it seems to be a more persistent condition than low back pain. Chronic neck pain causes major financial loss, not only in terms of diagnosis and treatment, but also due to sick leave and premature retirement pensions. Numerous modalities of therapeutic intervention are available for treatment of chronic neck pain: manual therapy, physical therapy, drugs, behavior therapy, neural blockade, but their efficacy remains controversial. Systematic reviews show that manual therapy as well as exercises would be appropriate for treatment patients with chronic neck pain. Therefore the aim of study will determine whether manual therapy or stretching exercises for cervical spine are more effective in relieving pain and restoring function in people suffering from neck pain. The results of this study may become a contribution to improving the therapeutic effects and the health benefits in patients experiencing neck pain.

Interventions

Manual therapy group. Patients will receive 2 treatments weekly for 5 weeks. Treatment will consist of 2 components: 1. Local cryotherapy during each session will be performed just before manual therapy. 2. Low-velocity osteopathic type mobilisation of cervical joint. No manipulations, i.e. high-velocity thrusts with low-amplitude, will be applied. 1. Local cryotherapy will be performed using KRIOPOL R 30 (Kriomedpol, Poland). A stream of cold nitrogen vapor at temperature -130 degrees Celsiu

Manual therapy group. Patients will receive 2 treatments weekly for 5 weeks. Treatment will consist of 2 components: 1. Local cryotherapy during each session will be performed just before manual therapy. 2. Low-velocity osteopathic type mobilisation of cervical joint. No manipulations, i.e. high-velocity thrusts with low-amplitude, will be applied. 1. Local cryotherapy will be performed using KRIOPOL R 30 (Kriomedpol, Poland). A stream of cold nitrogen vapor at temperature -130 degrees Celsius will be applied during 3 minutes to the muscles on both sides of the cervical spine and to the muscles on both sides of the shoulder girdle. The distance among the apparatus nozzle and patients body surface will be 10 centimeters. 2. Manual therapy will be based on 6 osteopathic-type mobilisation techniques, which will be performed while the patient is placed supine. A. Translation upwards: the head and upper cervical spine is lifted up by pushing the spinous processes with both hands to apply force to the movement segment lying between the lifted vertebra and the one immediately below it. B. Translation sideways: the cervical vertebra is pushed alternately towards the right and the left side by force applied to each facet joint. Hands tightly support each side of the head and upper cervical column, which are moved directly sideways at each level being treated. C. Side bending: the cervical spine is bent alternately to each side. Hands support along each side of the head and cervical column with the pads of the finger tips over the mobilised facet joint. The head and cervical column are bent to each side and finger tips are then moved upwards over the next facet joint. D. Rotation and side bending in the same direction: the head is supported by the therapist's lower mid-abdomen and hands support the head and upper cervical spine. Hands overlie each other forming a bridge so that the heads of the metacarpal bones are over the facet joints. Prior to mobilisation the cervical column is moped sideways and rotated in the same direction to about half of total range of movement (ROM). The movement is then continued so that connective tissues become stretched without causing pain. The head and neck are returned after each movement to its starting position. The head is rotated to the other side for the same treatment. E. Rotation with small ROM: the pads of the tips of the middle and the ring fingers are placed over the spinous processes and the fingers then are straightened so that the middle phalanx of the fingers is over the facet joint. The head is supported with the hand on the opposite side allowing the movement to happen and the head returns to the middle position. The other side is treated by moving to the opposite side of the treatment table. F. Mobilization of upper cervical joints: both hands support the occiput with the tips of the middle and the ring fingers over the arch of the atlas on each side. The head is bent sideways slightly and turned in the opposite direction, causing the atlas to move against the finger tips. The mobilization will be performer 3 times in each direction. Each manual therapy session will not exceed 20 minutes. The treating practitioner will be physiotherapists with post-graduate qualification in manual therapy, recognized as titled musculoskeletal physiotherapists or specialist musculoskeletal physiotherapists by Polish Physiotherapy Association and have at least 10 years experience. The treating practitioners will receive specific training in implementation of the trial protocol, work-health and safety induction and training in emergency procedures. The treatment will take place in the Physiotherapy Laboratory of the Regional Hospital.

Sponsors

Pawel Lizis
Lead SponsorIndividual

Study design

Allocation
Randomised controlled trial
Intervention model
Parallel
Primary purpose
Treatment
Masking
Blinded (masking used) (Investigator, Outcomes Assessor)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
All
Age
25 Years to 60 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

Adults of both sex aged 25-60 years, permanently employed, motivated to continue working, motivated for exercising and treatment, and constant or frequently occurring neck pain of more than 6 months’ duration.

Exclusion criteria

Specific disorders of the cervical spine, such as disc prolapse, spinal stenosis, postoperative conditions in the neck and shoulder areas, history of severe trauma, instability, spasmodic torticollis, migraine (frequency more often than twice per month), peripheral nerve entrapment, fibromyalgia, hypermobility syndrome, shoulder diseases (tendonitis, bursitis, capsulitis), inflammatory rheumatic diseases, severe psychiatric illness and other diseases that prevent physical loading, pregnancy and other on-going therapies.

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ANZCTR · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026