None listed
Conditions
Brief summary
Social anxiety disorder (SAD) is a common and debilitating mental illness, with sufferers frequently experiencing chronic anxiety in anticipation of, and during and following exposure to, social situations. Currently, group cognitive therapy is efficiacious for SAD, but some 80% fail to achieve normative functioning. The current project will investigate the utility of a novel treatment approach for SAD, namely imagery-enhanced cognitive behavioural group therapy (IE-CBGT). In this approach, imagery-based techniques are used to enhance existing evidence-based techniques within a 12-session treatment package. In this trial participants will be randomised to one of two conditions: i) IE-CBGT, or ii) a ‘gold-standard’ treatment, verbally-based CBGT (VB-CBGT, which relies on identifying and challenging anxiety-provoking beliefs predominantly within the verbal cognitive mode). A minimum of ninety-six individuals with SAD will be recruited through established referral pathways to the Centre for Clinical Interventions (CCI) from general practitioners, psychiatrists and psychologists and randomised into one of the two treatment groups. Between 6-12 patients will be admitted per group. The objectives of the project are threefold: i) to compare outcomes of IE-CBGT and current gold-standard VB-CBGT for SAD, across cognitive, behavioural, psychophysiological and emotional measures (i.e., questionnaires, behavioural tasks and physiological monitoring), ii) to evaluate unique and common mechanisms of change across the two treatments to inform theory and future treatment innovations, and iii) to compare the cost-effectiveness of the treatments to ensure that IE-CBGT has broader cost benefits in a health sector with limited resources and increasing demand. A standard battery of self-report questionnaires will be administered at baseline, and prior to each treatment session in line with current practice at CCI. Additional self-report questionnaires will be administered following sessions 4 and 8 and after the final treatment session. A routine CCI (group) follow-up appointment will be made 1-month after treatment completion with the treating psychologist. An additional individual assessment appointment will be made 1-month after treatment completion so that a diagnostic interview and self-report questionnaires can be administered. Another follow-up appointment will be made 6 months after treatment, allowing for fine-grained assessment of mechanisms of change to be assessed. Psychophysiological responses will be recorded during a social stress task at baseline and upon completion of the treatment sessions (at the individual assessment 1-month follow-up).
Interventions
This project aims to examine the efficacy, mechanisms of change, and cost-effectiveness of a novel group cognitive behavioural therapy, imagery-enhanced cognitive behavioural group therapy (IE-CBGT), compared to gold standard verbally-based cognitive behavioural group therapy (VB-CBGT), in patients with social anxiety disorder (SAD). Both protocols target the same maintaining factors (negative cognitions, avoidance, safety behaviours, self-focused attention, negative beliefs about how others’ perceive them, and core beliefs), but differ critically in the mode within which they are modified. The imagery-enhanced protocol encourages patients to focus on multi-sensory negative social images as a key maintaining factor and imagery monitoring, rather than focusing on verbal thoughts and thought monitoring. Cognitive challenging occurs within imagery rather than only using traditional verbal-linguistic methods. Behavioural experiment predictions are guided by negative imagery rather than thoughts, new information is incorporated into imagery, and coping imagery is constructed. Imagery exercises are included in all within-session behavioural experiments. Negative core beliefs are identified and challenged in IE-GCT via past imagery rescripting techniques, rather than more traditional verbal cognitive methods. Both protocols involve 12, 2-hour group therapy sessions (once/week) plus a one month group-based follow-up session of 2 hours duration. Groups comprise of between 6 and 12 patients. All treatment sessions will be facilitated by a registered psychologist with a masters or doctoral degree in clinical psychology. Clinicians will maintain an attendance register. Protocol adherence and homework completion will be monitored throughout the trial through coding of in-session audio recordings and use of the Homework Rating Scale (HRS-II), respectively. Additionally, the Working Alliance Inventory (WAI) and Gross Cohesion Scale will be used to measure therapist-client alliance and cohesiveness/bond amongst group members.
Sponsors
Study design
Eligibility
Inclusion criteria
At least 18 years of age, principle diagnosis of social anxiety disorder (as assessed by the SCID-5), Stable medications for at least 1 month, and willingness to be randomised.
Exclusion criteria
Bipolar disorder/psychosis or substance use disorder (all as judged by the SCID-5), currently receiving CBT elsewhere, high suicidal or self-harm risk (i.e., plans and/or intent).