Skip to content

Surgery for the treatment of Otitis Media in Indigenous children, surgical sub-study

This 12 month,surgical sub-study is a multi-centred, randomized trial to compare the outcomes of two surgical interventions on chronic Otitis Media in Indigenous children living in remote communities of Australia

Status
Recruiting
Phases
Unknown
Study type
Interventional
Source
ANZCTR
Registry ID
ACTRN12613000102774
Acronym
OM, surgical sub-study
Enrollment
71
Registered
2013-01-25
Start date
2014-05-11
Completion date
2018-12-15
Last updated
2020-01-13

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

None listed

Brief summary

Otitis media (OME/AOM) is a major problem amongst Indigenous children living in remote Australian communities. Medical treatment often fails and ENT surgeons are called upon to provide surgical care. This multi-centre randomised trial compares the outcomes of two current treatments (Myringotomy/ adenoidectomy V grommet tubes/ adenoidectomy). There are 11 sites proposed across WA, NT & N Qld. 280 Indigenous children aged 3-10 years will be randomized into 2 groups; (1) adenoidectomy with ventilation tubes (VTA) (2) adenoidectomy with myringotomy only (MA) The children will be followed up with monthly phone calls for 12 months following surgery by which time the OM will likely have recurred if were to do so. At the end of 12 months study staff will visit the children in their community for hearing assessments and nasal swabs. The outcome measures will be a reduction in the prevalence of OME/AOM, hearing impairment, aural discharge / perforation, and the also effect of treatment on nasal colonisation with pathogenic bacteria.

Interventions

Comparison of outcomes of 2 surgical techniques in Indigenous children with OM living in remote communities. Arm 1: bilateral myringotomy with adenoidectomy Arm 2: bilateral grommet tube insertion and adenoidectomy Both surgical interventions are performed once only under general anaesthetic according to standard, current surgical protocols and each routinely take less than 30 minutes. Surgery is performed by ENT specialists. There is nothing novel involved with these procedures. The study o

Comparison of outcomes of 2 surgical techniques in Indigenous children with OM living in remote communities. Arm 1: bilateral myringotomy with adenoidectomy Arm 2: bilateral grommet tube insertion and adenoidectomy Both surgical interventions are performed once only under general anaesthetic according to standard, current surgical protocols and each routinely take less than 30 minutes. Surgery is performed by ENT specialists. There is nothing novel involved with these procedures. The study objective is to compare the outcomes of current interventions after 12 months. The target group is the same as the original study, ie Indigenous children aged 3-10 yrs who have chronic otitis media. The reason for the change was that North Queensland paediatricians believe that by the time surgery is recommended in Qld, the children have already undergone a supervised period of medical treatment to a degree not seen elsewhere in the country. However, there was an interest in Qld in addressing the surgical questions raised in this Trial. The redesigned project has been divided into 2 parts, 1. Surgery V surgery substudy – 280 children across NT / WA and North Qld. 2. Surgery v medical care substudy – 200 children in NT & WA only The total number of children (480) remains the same as originally proposed. The total number of children whose data will be analysed to compare the 2 surgeries is therefore 380. This comprises 280 from surgical sub-study and 100 from the surgical arm of the medical / surgical sub-study. The data from both studies will be entered into a common database.

Sponsors

University of Melbourne
Lead SponsorUniversity

Study design

Allocation
Randomised controlled trial
Intervention model
Parallel
Primary purpose
Treatment
Masking
Open (masking not used)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
All
Age
3 Years to 10 Years
Healthy volunteers
No

Inclusion criteria

- Indigenous children aged 3 - 10 years old living in remote communities - OME/AOM that has been present for greater than or equal to 6 months and failed medical treatment. The criteria for the diagnosis of glue ear will be the presence of an immobile tympanic membrane on pneumatic otoscopy, supported by an air-bone gap on audiometry and a Type B tympanogram. - A mild or moderate conductive hearing impairment, defined as a pure-tone average of greater than or equal to 20 dB when tested in a sound-proofed room, or greater than 30dB when tested in non sound-proofed conditions. Approximately 70% of children with OME/AOM are expected to meet this criterion.

Exclusion criteria

Children with any of the following conditions which may predispose to complications following adenoidectomy: Cleft palate Submucous cleft palate Down Syndrome Cranio-facial syndromes Generalised immunological diseases Bleeding diasthesis Requirement for concomitant tonsillectomy Also exclude Children requiring treatment of unilateral ear pathology

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ANZCTR · Data processed: Feb 4, 2026