Skip to content

The ’40-Something’ Study: Preventing weight gain prior to menopause

The ’40-Something’ Study: A pilot weight control randomised controlled trial for healthy weight and overweight mid-age pre-menopausal women.

Status
Completed
Phases
Unknown
Study type
Interventional
Source
ANZCTR
Registry ID
ACTRN12611000064909
Acronym
nil
Enrollment
54
Registered
2011-01-18
Start date
2010-05-25
Completion date
2010-06-29
Last updated
2024-09-30

For informational purposes only — not medical advice. Sourced from public registries and may not reflect the latest updates. Terms

Conditions

None listed

Brief summary

BACKGROUND AND AIMS Middle age (45-54y), when most women experience menopause, is a particularly high risk stage for weight gain in women, and more than half the women in this age group are overweight or obese. Post-menopause is characterised by the absence of oestrogen resulting in abdominal deposition of body fat and subsequent development or exacerbation of metabolic syndrome. An estimated 48% of coronary events in women are attributable to metabolic syndrome, and risk of cardiovascular disease significantly increases after menopause. There is some evidence that intervention can prevent or minimise the body composition changes leading to post-menopausal obesity, making the years immediately prior to menopause a key stage for intervention. Despite the increased health risks associated with menopausal weight gain, no Australian interventions have been developed for this target group. A potential model for intervention exists within the Enhanced Primary Care (EPC) scheme of Medicare (funding of 5 Allied Health visits for those referred by a GP with chronic and complex problems). This model could be extended to the target group of women in the years immediately prior to menopause. The aim of this randomised control trial (the 40-Something Study) is to pilot test the feasibility of applying this model to the prevention of weight gain in non-obese women aged 44-50. Given the RCT will be a pilot of what will hopefully be a wider intervention, it will particularly assess the feasibility of recruiting into the study, ability to retain participants and will test the intervention and information only materials. RESEARCH PLAN The study has been designed to adhere to the CONSORT guidelines. An RCT design is being used to test the ability of a 12 month intensive intervention (four Dietitian appointments and one Exercise Physiologist appointment using motivational interviewing to advise on dietary and physical activity strategies) to prevent weight gain, in comparison to the provision of written information. Women were invited to participate if they were between 44 and 50y, still menstruating, BMI 18.5- 29.9 and able to attend appointments in Newcastle, NSW. Those in the healthy weight range (18.5-24.9kg/m2) at baseline will be given the goal of maintaining weight within 1kg, and provided with weight maintenance advice, (8300kJ/day, and at least 150 mins/week of PA). Women in the overweight range (25-29.9 kg/m2) at baseline will be advised to lose at least 7% of body weight, (by following a 6300kJ/day regime and 250 mins/wk of PA) before being given weight maintenance advice. After baseline data was collected the women were randomly allocated to intervention or control groups. All researchers except the Dietitian conducting the appointments with the intervention group will remain blind to the allocation condition. The primary outcome measures are weight and waist circumference, with secondary measures of biomarkers of metabolic syndrome. Baseline data has been collected on anthropometry, biomarkers of metabolic syndrome, and behaviours influencing weight gain including dietary intake, physical activity and dietary restraint, in addition to health and demographic data. The data will be collected again at 12 months after the intervention commenced. Compliance to the interventions in terms of dietary intake and PA is being measured 3 months after commencing the intervention. The study involves a comparison of a baseline measurement to a single follow-up measure to assess the success of the intervention (baseline to 12 months). Paired t-tests will be used to determine if there is a significant change in weight for each group with sub-analyses for those normal weight and overweight at baseline. Repeated measures analysis of covariance will be used to examine whether the groups (control and intervention) differ significantly on the amount of weight change between baseline and follow up. The project will be monitored by a Management Committee (meeting at least monthly) to oversee project implementation.

Interventions

Equal numbers of healthy weight (BMI of 18.5-24.9kg/m2) and overweight (BMI 25-29.9kg/m2 ) women (44-50 years and still pre-menopausal) will be recruited and randomly allocated to an Intensive Intervention group (4 individual sessions with a Dietitian and 1 with an Exercise Physiologist) or to an Information Only control group over a 12 month period. 1. Intensive Intervention participants: Each intensive intervention participant will each have five consultations with a health professional (4 wi

Equal numbers of healthy weight (BMI of 18.5-24.9kg/m2) and overweight (BMI 25-29.9kg/m2 ) women (44-50 years and still pre-menopausal) will be recruited and randomly allocated to an Intensive Intervention group (4 individual sessions with a Dietitian and 1 with an Exercise Physiologist) or to an Information Only control group over a 12 month period. 1. Intensive Intervention participants: Each intensive intervention participant will each have five consultations with a health professional (4 with a Dietitian and 1 with an Exercise Physiologist) who will be registered Medicare providers. The professionals will be trained to promote changes in dietary intake and physical activity (PA) in order to achieve weight control goals using a written protocol, developed by researchers using Clinical Best Practice Weight Management Guidelines and principles of motivational interviewing (see point 2 for detail). The women will be provided with print materials as detailed below. Appointment 1-(baseline) 60 minutes with Dietitian: Discuss current weight and set weight maintenance/loss goals. Assess motivation levels. Provide dietary advice to consume a high nutritional quality diet providing around 8300kJ/6300kJ per day. Use a social cognitive framework to identify environmental barriers and find strategies to overcome them by increasing self efficacy. Provide pamphlet: ‘Weight control: how to maintain your weight as you approach menopause’ to healthy weight women or ‘Weight control: how to lose weight as you approach menopause’ to those overweight at baseline. Appointment 2- (baseline) 60 minutes with Exercise Physiologist: Discuss current PA levels and exercise experience. Conduct pre-exercise screening, assess injury history and determine exercise self efficacy. Evaluate compliance with current guidelines (150 mins/wk for healthy weight and 250mins/wk for overweight women as well as less than 3 hours/day sitting time) and discuss barriers and facilitators. Set goals for lifestyle PA (monitored by pedometers) and provide individualised exercise training program consisting of progressive resistance training and aerobic activity. Appointment 3 (3 months) 45 minute appointment with Dietitian: Check weight and discuss any weight change. Provide weight maintenance advice for overweight women reaching goal weight. Assess motivation. Discuss compliance with dietary advice using 4 day food record and pedometer data and discuss any barriers arising. Appointment 4 (6 months) 45 minute appointment with Dietitian: Check weight and discuss any weight change. Assess motivation. Discuss any barriers arising. Appointment 5 with Dietitian (9 months) 45 minute appointment with Dietitian: As per appointments 3 and 4 months, plus provide further weight maintenance advice. Advise how to stay motivated. Provide contact details for any queries. 2. Motivational interviewing (MI) Motivational interviewing techniques will be used by the practitioners DURING the interviews. this is not additional to the procedures described- it is the PROCESS that will be used. MI is used as an approach where the weight change goals and behaviour changes for dietary intake and physical activity are suggested by the client to promote autonomy. The dietitian and exercise physiologist faciltate this process. Participants are encouraged to take responsibility for their own changes. The communication style on the part of the participants is non-directive; it is questioning, reflective and affirming. The interviews will be audio-recorded, and evaluated by an experienced psychologist for compliance with MI techniques.

Sponsors

Professor Lauren Williams, University of Canberra
Lead SponsorIndividual

Study design

Allocation
Randomised controlled trial
Intervention model
Parallel
Primary purpose
Prevention
Masking
Blinded (masking used)

Eligibility

Sex/Gender
All
Age
44 Years to 50 Years
Healthy volunteers
Yes

Inclusion criteria

Inclusion Criteria: 1. women 44 to 50 years of age 2. have had a menstrual period in the preceding 3 months 3. able to attend appointments in Newcastle 4. baseline Body Mass Index 18.5 to 29.9kg/m2 5. Women who have not had a hysterectomy or oophorectomy 6. Women without seriously medical conditions such as heart disease, Type 1 and 2 diabetes 7. Not pregnant 8. Women who can read write and understand English

Exclusion criteria

1. Males 2. women no longer experiencing periods 3. women younger than 44 or older than 50 years of age 4. women who have had a hysterectomy 5. Women with Body Mass Index (BMI) of less than18.5 kg/m2 (Underweight) or above 29.9 kg/m2 (Obese). The rationale for these exclusions are based on incompatible goals i.e. the underweight need to gain weight, rather than prevent weight gain, while the obese need to lose at least 10% of body weight, which is outside the scope of the modest weight loss goals for the overweight women (7% or less).

Outcome results

None listed

Source: ANZCTR · Data processed: Mar 22, 2026